Home › Collection › Documents
Front: Hamilton's sworn certificate of four days' attendance in Bagby v. Bettisworth, with "five" struck out and "four" written in.
Witness-attendance certificate of Artois Hamilton in Bagby v. Bettisworth, Hancock County Circuit Court, 1840
Artois Hamilton, witness; certified by S. Otho Williams, deputy clerk of the circuit court
A printed witness-attendance certificate from the Hancock County Circuit Court, completed by hand and dated 3 October 1840. Carthage hotelkeeper Artois Hamilton swears to four days at court as a witness for John Bagby in his suit against David Bettisworth, and deputy clerk S. Otho Williams certifies the oath. Four years later Bettisworth served as constable in the proceedings against Joseph and Hyrum Smith, and Hamilton helped care for the brothers' bodies. The subject and outcome of the 1840 suit are unknown.
- Inventory no.
- D-0005
- Author / maker
- Artois Hamilton, witness; certified by S. Otho Williams, deputy clerk of the circuit court
- Place
- Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 3 October 1840
- Format / binding
- One leaf. Printed form with ornamental border at left, completed in manuscript on the front. Signed by Artois Hamilton and by S. Otho Williams as clerk. Manuscript filing endorsement on the reverse, signed by Williams.
- Signed
- Yes
- Parties
- John Bagby, plaintiff; David Bettisworth, defendant
- Court
- Hancock County Circuit Court, September Term 1840
- Witness
- Artois Hamilton, four days' attendance for the plaintiff
- Signatories
- Artois Hamilton; S. Otho Williams, clerk
- Endorsement
- Filed 3 October 1840, S. Otho Williams, Clerk
Condition
Folded, with one horizontal fold across the front and further fold lines visible on the reverse. Light overall toning. Printing shows through faintly on the reverse. No tears or losses visible in the photographs.
The story behind this item
The document
This is a printed court form completed by hand. The heading places it in the Circuit Court of Hancock County, Illinois, at the September Term 1840. John Bagby is entered as plaintiff and David Bettisworth as defendant. Artois Hamilton, being duly sworn, states that he attended the court as a witness in the case for four days at the instance of the plaintiff. The attendance entry shows "five" struck out and "four" written beside it. Hamilton signed at the right. S. Otho Williams signed the certification as clerk on 3 October 1840 and endorsed the reverse "Filed 3 October 1840".
What the paper was for
A witness could claim compensation for attending court. This certificate recorded Hamilton's time so that the allowable fee could be entered among the taxable costs of the lawsuit. The four days are days of attendance, which may or may not have included testimony. Hamilton may have testified, waited to be called, or remained available while the case proceeded. The term opened on Monday, 28 September 1840, under Judge Peter Lott, in the brick courthouse at Carthage that the county had accepted in 1839. A certificate dated Saturday, 3 October is consistent with four court days within that week.
The witness and the clerk
Artois Hamilton was born in Massachusetts on 15 August 1795 and arrived in Carthage on 22 July 1835. He became the town's hotelkeeper and also engaged in farming, lumber milling, and land development. In June 1844 his hotel stood a short distance from the Carthage jail. After the attack of 27 June he assisted the wounded and helped manage the bodies of Joseph and Hyrum Smith, which were taken to the hotel and conveyed toward Nauvoo. He died at Carthage on 4 July 1873.
Samuel Otho Williams worked in the Hancock County clerk's office by 1839, as deputy under the elected circuit clerk, Wesley Williams. Later genealogical sources identify him as Wesley's son and place his birth in 1819. By 1844 he was a lieutenant in the Carthage militia. His letter to John A. Prickett of 10 July 1844 is a major source for his view of the crisis. He died on 28 November 1844.
The parties
David Bettisworth was born in Virginia on 14 July 1814 and came to Hancock County with his family in 1833, settling in Chili Township. He was about twenty-six when Bagby sued him. Documentary summaries identify him as a merchant and a constable. On 12 June 1844 he went to Nauvoo with warrants arising from the destruction of the Nauvoo Expositor press, and Joseph Smith was in his custody during stages of the proceedings that followed. He was a constable and was never the Carthage jailer; George W. Stigall held that office. Bettisworth died on 8 November 1866.
John Bagby is the least securely identified of the four. He was probably the Virginia-born pioneer who settled near Blandinsville, McDonough County, about 1829 or 1830, lived for a time in Hancock County, and later returned. That identification remains probable. No connection to Walter Bagby, a different Hancock County figure active in anti-Mormon politics, has been established.
What it proves and what remains open
The paper establishes the parties, the court and term, Hamilton's four days of attendance for Bagby, and Williams's certification on 3 October 1840. It joins in one 1840 court record three men who appear four years later in the history of Joseph and Hyrum Smith's final days.
The cause of action, the amount demanded, Hamilton's testimony, the verdict or judgment, and the allocation of costs are unknown. The declaration and judgment have not been located. No evidence shows that the 1840 lawsuit concerned the Church or the later conflict. None of the principals has been shown to be a Latter-day Saint, and no adequate evidence of Masonic membership has been found for any of them.
Related items
More documents


