Home › Collection › Manuscripts
Case wrapper: assessment of $2,170.53 and 'Judgment Oct term 1841,' State Bank of Ill. vs Montague, John (IMG_3753)
Mortgage and scire facias papers, State Bank of Illinois v. John Montague, Hancock County, 1840-1841
John and Virginia Montague, mortgagors; Browning and Bushnell, attorneys; S. Ortho Williams, clerk pro tempore, Hancock Circuit Court
Original case papers in a Hancock County mortgage suit. On 16 April 1840 John and Virginia Montague of Warsaw mortgaged Warsaw lots to the State Bank of Illinois to secure a $2,060.58 note, with Mark Aldrich and L. Allen Key as sureties. In 1841 the bank sued by scire facias through Browning and Bushnell, the firm of Joseph Smith's 1841 counsel. The wrapper records judgment at the October 1841 term for $2,170.53. The papers join Warsaw men who later stood among Nauvoo's organized opponents.
- Inventory no.
- M-0041
- Author / maker
- John and Virginia Montague, mortgagors; Browning and Bushnell, attorneys; S. Ortho Williams, clerk pro tempore, Hancock Circuit Court
- Place
- Warsaw and Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 16 April 1840 to October term 1841
- Format / binding
- Group of handwritten case papers photographed in eleven views (IMG_3753 to IMG_3763): case wrapper with pencil assessment; attorneys' direction for scire facias with endorsed reverse; original mortgage signed by John and Virginia Montague with drawn seals, Andrew Monroe's acknowledgment with drawn seal, and recording certificate signed by Charles D. Bagby as deputy recorder; writ of scire facias reciting the mortgage, signed by S. Ortho Williams, clerk pro tempore, with embossed court seal; sheriff's return and fee account signed by Wm. D. Abernethy. Ink on ruled and unruled paper; pencil and red crayon on the wrapper.
- Signed
- Yes
- Parties
- State Bank of Illinois v. John Montague (Virginia Montague struck from process)
- Court
- Hancock County Circuit Court, October term 1841
- Amount
- $2,060.58 debt; $2,170.53 assessed with interest
- Sureties
- Mark Aldrich and L. Allen Key
- Attorneys
- Browning and Bushnell
Condition
Folded in panels, with fold lines throughout. General toning. Ink show-through on the mortgage leaves. Small notch at the left edge of the attorneys' direction and a small edge loss on its reverse. Edge wear and chipping to the wrapper.
The story behind this item
The papers
This group preserves both sides of one debt. The original mortgage of 16 April 1840 conveys Warsaw lots from John Montague and his wife Virginia to the President, Directors and Company of the State Bank of Illinois as security for $2,060.58. It carries Justice of the Peace Andrew Monroe's acknowledgment and the Hancock County recorder's certificate. The 1841 court papers follow. Browning and Bushnell direct the clerk to issue a scire facias on the mortgage. The clerk's writ recites the whole mortgage and summons Montague to the October 1841 term at Carthage. The sheriff's return records service, and a wrapper notes the judgment and assessment.
The debt and the property
Montague signed a promissory note as principal, payable four months after date at the bank's Quincy branch. Mark Aldrich and L. Allen Key signed as sureties. The mortgage bound the lots for any balance due, even if the note was renewed, reduced or given new sureties. The security covered numbered lots across several Warsaw blocks, from Block 26 to Block 76, plus twenty feet on the east side of Lot 9 in Block 24. Monroe certified that he examined Virginia Montague separately and that she relinquished her dower voluntarily. The deed was recorded on 17 April 1840 in Book H, pages 336 to 338, number 3666.
The bank goes to court
The attorneys' direction was filed on 30 August 1841. The writ issued the next day under S. Ortho Williams, clerk pro tempore, and bears an embossed Hancock Circuit Court seal. An interlineation describes Virginia as "since deceased," with the place and date left blank, and her name is struck from the summons. The report treats this as the document's statement; her death has not been independently verified. Sheriff Wm. D. Abernethy served a copy on Montague on 17 September 1841. The wrapper reads "Judgment Oct term 1841" and assesses $2,170.53, being the debt plus $109.95 interest. A faint pencil note calls for special execution against the mortgaged premises.
The names on the papers
The people named here figure in later Hancock County history. Orville H. Browning had been Joseph Smith's principal counsel in the June 1841 extradition hearing, and his firm with Nehemiah Bushnell also pursued older debts owed by Joseph. The report states that the collector identifies the hand of the direction as Browning's or Bushnell's; it does not assign it to either partner. Mark Aldrich negotiated a Warsaw land agreement with Joseph in August 1841. By 1843 he was named in Warsaw's anti-Mormon correspondence organization, and in May 1845 he was tried and acquitted for Joseph Smith's murder. Montague served as senior warden of the Warsaw lodge in 1843, sat on the nominating committee of the January 1845 anti-Mormon meeting, and in March 1846 wrote for the lodge defending men accused in the murder.
Context in the report
The accompanying research report uses the case as a doorway into the Warsaw circle before Carthage. It covers the Chittenden family, Calvin A. Warren, Jacob C. Davis and others. It reproduces newspaper notices, a lumber bill to Joseph Smith, a Warren letter and a county map from outside sources. Those images are context and are not part of this item.
What remains unresolved
The papers prove the bank's claim, the named financial relationships and the 1841 judgment assessment. They do not show payment or a sale of the lots. The full judgment entry and the disposition of the parcels remain unlocated. The writ appears to render the mortgage's Block 68 as "Sixty Eight (48)"; the report retains the discrepancy as a reading, not a title abstract. Some wrapper identifiers, cancelled lines and altered pronouns remain uncertain readings. The report states that the mortgage does not establish any link between the bank dispute and later anti-Mormon conduct.
Related items
More manuscripts


