Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Thomas Dixon's note to George Caffee, 30 June 1842, payable in wheat at the market price

Manuscripts · Hancock County, Illinois · 30 June 1842 to 1843

Case papers in Caffee v. Dixon, debt on a note payable in wheat, Hancock County, 1842-1843

Thomas Dixon, note maker; James C. Graham, justice of the peace; Matthias Avise, deputy clerk; Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk; George W. Stigall, deputy sheriff

The papers of a small debt case from Hancock County in the Nauvoo years. On 30 June 1842 Thomas Dixon promised George Caffee $12.50, payable in wheat at the market price. Justice James C. Graham entered a default judgment, and Dixon appealed to the circuit court on a fifty-dollar bond. The packet carries the names and hands of county officers tied to Nauvoo history, including deputy clerk Matthias Avise, circuit clerk Jacob B. Backenstos, and the office of Sheriff William Backenstos.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0044
Author / maker
Thomas Dixon, note maker; James C. Graham, justice of the peace; Matthias Avise, deputy clerk; Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk; George W. Stigall, deputy sheriff
Place
Hancock County, Illinois
Date
30 June 1842 to 1843
Format / binding
Case packet No. 70 in the Hancock Circuit Court: manuscript promissory note signed by Thomas Dixon, with filing endorsement on the reverse; two manuscript justice's transcripts signed by James C. Graham, J.P. (22 November 1842 and certified 13 March 1843), each with filing endorsements on the reverse; printed appeal bond completed by hand, signed by John Wilson as surety and witnessed by M. Avise; printed injunction and appeal summons forms with handwritten returns signed for the sheriff by G. W. Stigall, D.S.; and the folded case wrapper.
Signed
Yes
Parties
George Caffee, plaintiff and appellee; Thomas Dixon, defendant and appellant
Amount
$12.50 note; judgment $12.61 debt and interest plus costs; $50 appeal bond
Courts
Justice court of James C. Graham; Hancock County Circuit Court, case No. 70
Signatories
Thos Dixon; James C. Graham, J.P.; Jno. Wilson; M. Avise; J. B. Backenstos; G. W. Stigall, D.S.

Condition

Photographs show the papers folded for filing, with fold lines and light toning. Damage on the March transcript crosses the witness's surname. The case wrapper has losses at the upper edge affecting its heading. Ink shows through on several leaves.

The story behind this item

The note and the lawsuit

The case began with a short promissory note dated 30 June 1842. Thomas Dixon promised to pay George Caffee twelve dollars and fifty cents on or before 1 September, and the note allowed the debt to be "Discharged in wheate at the market price." The amount was fixed in dollars; the grain needed to pay it would depend on its value. The note does not say what Caffee had supplied, and it states no number of bushels.

On 2 November 1842 a summons issued from James C. Graham, justice of the peace, to constable John Welch, returnable on 12 November. Graham's fuller transcript records that Welch served the summons by reading it on 9 November and that both parties appeared.

The missing witness and the judgment

Dixon asked for more time because a material witness was absent. Graham adjourned the hearing to 19 November and issued a subpoena for a witness named David. Damage to the paper obscures his surname, and the report does not reconstruct it. On the day set for trial the plaintiff appeared, and Graham entered judgment against Dixon by default: $12.61 in debt and interest, $1.55 in justice's fees and 78 cents in constable's fees. The record does not explain the default or preserve the testimony Dixon had sought.

The appeal

On 3 December 1842 Dixon executed a fifty-dollar appeal bond with John Wilson as surety. The bond secured the obligations of the appeal; it did not make the debt a fifty-dollar debt. Matthias Avise witnessed the bond and acted for circuit clerk J. C. Davis. The report compares Wilson's signature with one in the October 1842 Mackemer recognizance, also in this collection, and supports David Larsen's judgment that the same man wrote both. It does not identify Wilson securely with a particular household.

On 17 January 1843 deputy sheriff George W. Stigall served an injunction on Graham and Welch, intended to restrain enforcement while the appeal proceeded. On 13 March 1843 Graham certified a fuller transcript of his docket, filed the next day by circuit clerk J. B. Backenstos. For the May 1843 term, Stigall returned the appeal summons with the note that he could not find Caffee in the county.

The officers

Matthias Avise, born in New Jersey in 1807, was a watchmaker and jeweler as well as a deputy clerk in the Hancock circuit clerk's office through much of the Nauvoo period. Jacob Cunningham Davis, the clerk he represented, was twenty-two in December 1842. In May 1845 Davis was among the defendants tried and acquitted in the prosecution for Joseph Smith's murder. The report draws no inference about his conduct in this case from that later trial.

Jacob B. Backenstos had received a commission in the Nauvoo Legion in March 1842 and belonged to the Nauvoo Masonic Lodge; he became sheriff in 1845. His brother William, sheriff when these papers were served, married Clara M. Wasson at the Nauvoo Mansion on 3 October 1843, with Joseph Smith officiating. Clara was the daughter of Emma Smith's sister Elizabeth Hale Wasson.

What remains unresolved

The packet supplies no final judgment or settlement. The reverse of the note carries the figure $13.06 with a March 1843 filing endorsement; the report does not treat this as proof of payment or of a circuit court judgment. Caffee's absence is unexplained, and the return does not establish that he had moved away. The witness's surname, the households of Graham and Welch, and the identities of Dixon and Wilson beyond these papers remain open questions.

Related items

More manuscripts