Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Face: the complaint and arrest command naming six members of the Brooks and Hendrix families.

Manuscripts · Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois · 27 September 1849

Arrest warrant for the alleged forcible seizure of Benjamin H. Brooks's stone house, Nauvoo, 1849

Chauncey Robison, justice of the peace; return signed by Jonathan Calkins Wright, marshal of Nauvoo

A manuscript arrest warrant issued at Nauvoo on 27 September 1849 by justice of the peace Chauncey Robison. A sworn complaint alleged that six members of the Brooks and Hendrix families had violently taken the stone house occupied by Benjamin H. Brooks, imprisoned his wife Deborah, and attempted to kill John Hines and James Brooks. The return on the reverse is signed by Jonathan Calkins Wright, a Latter-day Saint convert of 1843, acting as marshal of Nauvoo three years after the principal exodus.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0003
Author / maker
Chauncey Robison, justice of the peace; return signed by Jonathan Calkins Wright, marshal of Nauvoo
Place
Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
27 September 1849
Format / binding
Single sheet, manuscript, written on both sides. Face: complaint and arrest command. Reverse: date, signature and seal of C. Robison, J.P., with the docket "People vs William Brooks" and the service return signed by J. C. Wright, marshal. Accompanied by a later typed transcription headed "Nauvoo Document #24".
Signed
Yes
Docket
People vs William Brooks
Issued by
Chauncey Robison, justice of the peace, Nauvoo
Executed by
Jonathan Calkins Wright, marshal of Nauvoo
Accused
William Brooks, Elizabeth Brooks, Nancy Hendrix, Margaret Hendrix, Claudius T. Hendrix, Claudius Hendrix
Outcome
Not located; no hearing record or disposition found

Condition

Folds, staining, edge losses, ink variation and show-through, as described in the report and visible in the photographs.

The story behind this item

The document

This is a single sheet written on both sides, issued at Nauvoo on 27 September 1849. The face carries the complaint and the command to arrest. The reverse carries the date, the signature and seal of justice of the peace Chauncey Robison, and the marshal's return. The report classes it as a criminal arrest warrant based on allegations made under oath, followed by a partial return. It is not a judgment.

What the warrant alleges

The warrant recites a written complaint on oath against William Brooks, Elizabeth Brooks, Nancy Hendrix, Margaret Hendrix, Claudius T. Hendrix and Claudius Hendrix. It alleges that on or about 26 September 1849 they riotously assembled in Nauvoo and violently took possession of "the Stone house occupied by Benjamin H Brooks and family". It further alleges that they removed Brooks's furniture, imprisoned his wife Deborah Brooks, beat and bruised John Hines and attempted to kill him, and attempted to kill James Brooks by shooting at him with a pistol. The accused were alleged still to hold the house by force. All of this is allegation. The warrant proves that the charges were sworn and that process issued. It does not prove guilt or identify the legal owner of the house.

The marshal's return

On the reverse, under the docket "People vs William Brooks", J. C. Wright signs as marshal: "Served on the within Named persons & They are now at court house". Four names follow: Wm Brooks, Claudius Hendrix, Nancy Hendrix and Elizabeth Brooks. Margaret Hendrix and the second Claudius are not listed. The report offers three explanations: they may not have been found, they may have departed, or the return may simply be abbreviated.

Jonathan Calkins Wright and Chauncey Robison

Wright was born on 29 November 1808 in Rome, New York, and was baptized at Nauvoo on 29 March 1843. The Nauvoo City Council elected him city marshal and Fourth Ward assessor and collector on 14 September 1844. After the 1846 exodus he stayed in the Nauvoo and western Iowa region. He was assigned to protect Church livestock in Missouri in February 1847 and served as acting bishop at Harris Grove from about July 1848 to about May 1849. He left Kanesville with the Edward Hunter Company in June 1850 and died at Brigham City on 8 November 1880. The warrant shows him acting as marshal in 1849. His later election or commission to that office has not been found. Robison was closely associated with Nauvoo's Latter-day Saint civic and property network. The report located no definitive evidence of his baptism.

The Brooks and Hendrix parties

Benjamin H. Brooks was born about 1810 and married Deborah M. Hatfield in Morgan County, Illinois, on 21 December 1842. The couple were enumerated in Nauvoo in 1850. William and Elizabeth Brooks were probably his parents, and James Brooks probably his brother. These relationships are not finally proved. The Hendrix defendants are probably one household: Claudius Townsend Hendrix Sr., his wife Margaret, daughter Nancy M., and son Claudius T. They came from Washington County, Iowa, and were in Pulaski County, Arkansas, by the 1850 census. John Hines remains unidentified. No secure evidence of Latter-day Saint membership was found for any Brooks or Hendrix party, and no evidence that the quarrel was religious.

What remains unresolved

The report proposes the Captain James White Upper Stone House, on Block 10, Lot 4 of the Joseph Smith Addition, as a plausible candidate for the disputed residence. The identification is unconfirmed. No deed, tax entry, lease or census correlation places Benjamin Brooks in that building in 1849, and Nauvoo had other stone dwellings. The defendants' claimed right to the house is not disclosed. No hearing record, dismissal, bond, indictment, conviction, acquittal or settlement has been located, and the ultimate possession of the house is unknown.

Related items

More manuscripts