Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Bill of sale, Warsaw, 29 October 1838: first page listing the pledged goods.

Manuscripts · Warsaw and Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois · 1838-1841

Case papers in Browning and Ellis v. Ayers, Hancock County Circuit Court, Warsaw and Carthage, 1838-1841

John Browning and Richard Ellis, builders; William Ayers, hotel owner; Sampson & Perkins and Williams & Sherman, attorneys

Five original case papers from a Hancock County lawsuit over a wall at William Ayers's Steam Boat Hotel lot in Warsaw, Illinois. Builders John Browning and Richard Ellis pledged oxen, a cow, a mule, bedding and a chest of carpenters' tools in 1838. The wall fell in April 1841. The papers run from the security instrument and work accounts through the pleas to the receipt for a $94.29 judgment paid at Carthage. The lawyers named on them include Archibald Williams and Jason H. Sherman, both later tied to Joseph Smith's affairs.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0036
Author / maker
John Browning and Richard Ellis, builders; William Ayers, hotel owner; Sampson & Perkins and Williams & Sherman, attorneys
Place
Warsaw and Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
1838-1841
Format / binding
Five manuscript papers from one lawsuit, photographed in thirteen views: a bill of sale with conditions (29 October 1838), signed and sealed by John Browning, Richard Ellis and William Ayers and witnessed by John Hill; John Browning's account against William Ayers (May 1838); Ayers's account of claimed losses (April 1841); pleas 3 and 4 with the plaintiffs' answer, signed Williams & Sherman and Sampson, endorsed filed 8 October 1841 by S. Otho Williams, clerk pro tem; and a receipt signed Sampson & Perkins, Carthage, 14 October 1841. Handwritten in ink, with docketing and arithmetic on the reverses.
Signed
Yes
Parties
John Browning and Richard Ellis (later his administrators Mary Ann Ellis and Rhodolphus Weston) v. William Ayers
Court
Hancock County Circuit Court, Carthage, Illinois
Judgment paid
$94.29, costs excepted, 14 October 1841
Parcel
Lot 3, Block 5, Warsaw (Steam Boat Hotel lot)
Pieces
Five papers: bill of sale, two accounts, pleas, receipt

Condition

Folded papers with toning, scattered spots and soft creases. The bill of sale and Browning's account show splits and small losses along the folds; the account has a loss at its lower fold that obscures part of the stable-door entry. The receipt has chipped and creased edges.

The story behind this item

The papers

This group holds five manuscript papers from one civil dispute in Hancock County, Illinois. The first is a bill of sale dated at Warsaw on 29 October 1838. In it John Browning and Richard Ellis assign to William Ayers a pair of oxen, a cow, a mule, two bedsteads with bedding and a chest of carpenters' tools, in consideration of $180. A condition makes the instrument void if a certain wall is built and completed by 1 December, thirty dollars is paid, and Ayers receives possession of the house the builders occupied. On default, Ayers could dispose of the goods at public sale. Browning, Ellis and Ayers signed with seals, and John Hill witnessed.

The second paper is Browning's account against Ayers for May 1838 carpentry: a floor frame and casings, chimney work, a counter, sundry jobs about the house, a stable door and a lid for a butter churn. The written total is $34.62½. Its reverse carries unlabelled arithmetic ending in $94.29.

The fallen wall

The third paper is Ayers's account of April 1841. It charges the builders for clearing rubble from the fallen wall, replacing two windows, repairing weatherboarding and plaster, and rebuilding the wall, a subtotal of $128. Six months' rent at the Steam Boat Hotel at $25 a month and a $30 tenant-related charge bring the total to $308.

The fourth paper holds pleas 3 and 4, filed 8 October 1841. Ayers's plea recites a writing obligatory of 1 July 1838. Under it Browning and Ellis bound themselves to build a lime-mortar wall sixty feet long and eight feet high on Lot 3, Block 5, with a vault and arch, warranted to stand three years. Ayers says he paid $300 on 25 July 1839, that the wall fell in April 1841 through careless and unskilful work, and that he was damaged $500. The plaintiffs deny the wall fell for that reason. Both sides put themselves on the country.

Judgment and the Ellis estate

The fifth paper is a receipt dated at Carthage on 14 October 1841. Sampson & Perkins, attorneys for the plaintiffs, acknowledge $94.29 from William Ayres in full for a judgment rendered that day in the Hancock Circuit Court, costs excepted. The plaintiffs are now Mary Ann Ellis and Rhodolphus Weston, administrators of the estate of Richard Ellis, deceased, with John Browning. Ellis had died by that date. The report finds that his estate was still advertising land for sale in 1844.

The lawyers

Archibald Williams of Quincy, of Williams & Sherman, had sheltered members of the Smith family in 1839 and defended Joseph Smith in the 1841 extradition proceedings. In May 1845 he helped defend men charged with the Carthage murders. His partner Jason H. Sherman was named to the Carthage central corresponding committee on 13 June 1844, and later scholarship identifies him with the attacking force at Carthage Jail. Guy C. Sampson's firm advertised in the Times and Seasons. S. Otho Williams, who filed the pleas, also handled process in cases involving Joseph Smith and Sidney Rigdon.

The hotel

A Warsaw Message advertisement of 1844 places the Steam Boat Hotel on Lot 3, Block 5, opposite the ferry landing. That is the lot named in the plea. The report does not settle whether the wall was part of the hotel building, a retaining wall or another feature of the lot.

What remains open

The pleadings record allegations and a denial. No finding of faulty workmanship survives, and the request for a jury does not prove a verdict. The arithmetic on Browning's account agrees with the $94.29 receipt but does not show how the court reached its judgment. The original construction contract is not among these papers. The report finds no securely identified participant to be a Latter-day Saint. Identifications of Browning with the brother of Jonathan Browning, and of Mary Ann Ellis as Richard's widow, remain unproved.

Related items

More manuscripts