Home › Collection › Manuscripts
Samuel Fleming's sworn complaint before George Rockwell, J.P., 11 October 1843
People v. Martin Kinney, horse-theft case file, Hancock County justice and circuit court, 1843
George Rockwell, justice of the peace; John H. Lawton, constable; William Elliott, state's attorney; Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk, by David E. Head, deputy
The complete surviving file of a horse-theft prosecution in Hancock County, Illinois, in October 1843. Samuel Fleming, keeper of the Warsaw House, swore the complaint. Justice George Rockwell examined Martin Kinney and sent him to jail for lack of security. Grand-jury foreman E. A. Bedell endorsed the indictment as a true bill. Two printed fee bills certified at Carthage preserve the guilty plea and conviction. Several of the officers and witnesses later appear in the history of the Carthage murders and the 1845 burnings.
- Inventory no.
- M-0040
- Author / maker
- George Rockwell, justice of the peace; John H. Lawton, constable; William Elliott, state's attorney; Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk, by David E. Head, deputy
- Place
- Warsaw and Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 11 October to 13 November 1843
- Format / binding
- Seven leaves, fourteen sides photographed. Five manuscript papers: sworn complaint, warrant with constable's return on the reverse, justice's certified hearing record with marginal fee abstract, witness recognizance, and indictment with grand-jury endorsement. Two printed Hancock County Circuit Court fee bills (defendant's and plaintiff's costs) completed in manuscript, with embossed court seals. Clerk's filing endorsements on the versos. Signatures of Fleming, Rockwell, Lawton, Houck, Stephens, Elliott, Bedell and Head for Backenstos; seal notations on the warrant, hearing record and recognizance.
- Signed
- Yes
- Parties
- People of the State of Illinois v. Martin Kinney
- Court
- Justice George Rockwell; Hancock County Circuit Court, October term 1843
- Case number
- 30
- Charge
- Larceny of a gelding valued at $60
- Contents
- Complaint, warrant and return, hearing record, witness recognizance, indictment, two fee bills
Condition
All leaves folded, with visible fold lines. Both fee bills have a torn and lost upper left corner and some toning. A red wafer or seal remnant is visible on the defendant's cost bill. Light ink spotting and show-through on several versos. Embossed seal lettering not fully legible in the photographs.
The story behind this item
The case file
This is the surviving file of a Hancock County horse-theft prosecution from the autumn of 1843. It holds seven leaves, fourteen photographed sides. Five are manuscript papers from the justice and the circuit court: Samuel Fleming's sworn complaint, the arrest warrant with the constable's return, the justice's certified record of the hearing, the witnesses' recognizance, and the grand-jury indictment. Two are printed fee bills completed by hand. Clerk Jacob B. Backenstos filed the papers as case number 30.
Complaint, arrest and hearing
On 11 October 1843 Samuel Fleming swore before George Rockwell, justice of the peace, that on or about 9 October a horse, saddle, bridle and overcoat had been stolen in Hancock County, and that Martin Kinney was guilty. Rockwell issued a warrant the same day. Constable John H. Lawton returned it, served "by bringing the defendant Martin Kinney forward," and charged for eighteen miles of travel and for committing Kinney to jail. At the hearing Fleming, William Houck and Simeon Stevens attended as witnesses. Rockwell required a recognizance of three hundred dollars with security. Kinney could not give it and was committed to jail. Each witness entered a ten-dollar recognizance to appear at the next circuit court. The report reads the surname as Stevens in the body and Stephens in the signature.
Indictment and outcome
William Elliott, state's attorney, signed the indictment at the October term. It charged the theft of one gelded horse worth sixty dollars, the property of Samuel Ramsey. The writer struck out "carry away" and wrote "Ride away." The saddle, bridle and overcoat are not in the charge, for a reason the papers do not explain. Foreman E. A. Bedell endorsed it "A True Bill," filed 16 October 1843. The outcome survives only in the fee bills. The defendant's costs include "Entry plea of Guilty." The plaintiff's costs include "Entry Judgt of conviction." Deputy clerk David E. Head certified both at Carthage on 13 November 1843 in Backenstos's name.
The people in the papers
Fleming kept the Warsaw House. At the 1845 trial for the murders of Joseph and Hyrum Smith, Eliza Graham, a Latter-day Saint living in the Fleming household, testified about what she heard there after the killings, and Ann Fleming disputed parts of her account. Lawton had been appointed Warsaw constable on 23 September 1843. His sister Sarah married the historian Thomas Gregg, and his sister Anne married Franklin Worrell, a member of the guard at Carthage Jail in June 1844. Bedell, a Warsaw merchant and official who was not a Latter-day Saint, was driven from Warsaw in September 1845 during the burning of Mormon homes and defended in signed letters the legal rights of all. Backenstos later served as sheriff during the 1845 conflict. Rockwell is a different man from Orrin Porter Rockwell. The report states that the Kinney prosecution had no demonstrated part in the Carthage killings.
What remains unresolved
The papers establish an arrest, a hearing, confinement for lack of security, an indictment, a guilty plea and a conviction. They do not record Kinney's sentence, age, family, religious affiliation or later life. A published reference points to an October 17 judgment in Circuit Court Record Book D, which has not been examined. The papers do not place the theft at the Warsaw House, and they do not explain why Fleming complained on Ramsey's behalf. Ramsey's reading on the indictment endorsement is less clear than in its body, and his identity beyond the case is open. Some small fractions in the justice's fee abstract remain uncertain readings.
Related items
More manuscripts


