Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Recto: appraisers' certificate for Lot 2, Block 16, Commerce, and sheriff's return, 11 June 1838

Manuscripts · City of Commerce (later Nauvoo), Hancock County, Illinois · 11 June 1838; filed 15 June 1838

Certificate of appraisement and sheriff's return for Lot 2, Block 16, Commerce, Illinois, 1838

C. A. Carter, F. Wilcox and William Wilson, appraisers; Edson Whitney, sheriff, by D. A. Fullerton, deputy; W. Williams, clerk, by S. O. Williams, deputy

A manuscript certificate of appraisement for Lot 2, Block 16, in the City of Commerce, Hancock County, Illinois, dated 11 June 1838. Three appraisers, C. A. Carter, F. Wilcox and William Wilson, value the lot. The sheriff's return is executed in Edson Whitney's name by his deputy, Daniel A. Fullerton, and the verso is filed in Wesley Williams's clerk's office on 15 June 1838. The sheet records county business at Commerce less than a year before the Latter-day Saint gathering began there.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0030
Author / maker
C. A. Carter, F. Wilcox and William Wilson, appraisers; Edson Whitney, sheriff, by D. A. Fullerton, deputy; W. Williams, clerk, by S. O. Williams, deputy
Place
City of Commerce (later Nauvoo), Hancock County, Illinois
Date
11 June 1838; filed 15 June 1838
Format / binding
Single manuscript sheet in ink, written on the recto and endorsed on the verso. Recto: appraisers' certificate of valuation signed by C. A. Carter, F. Wilcox and Wm Wilson, followed by the sheriff's return signed 'Edson Whitney Shff, By D A Fullerton Dpt'. Verso: ink filing endorsement of 15 June 1838 signed for W. Williams, clerk, by a deputy read as S. O. Williams, and a pencil notation 'Lot 2 Block 16 Commerce'. Folded in panels for filing. No seal.
Signed
Yes
Parcel
Lot 2, Block 16, City of Commerce (pre-Nauvoo plat)
Appraisers
C. A. Carter; F. Wilcox; William Wilson
Officers
Edson Whitney, sheriff, by D. A. Fullerton, deputy; W. Williams, clerk, by S. O. Williams, deputy
Filed
15 June 1838

Condition

From the photographs: folded in panels, with fold lines across the recto. Even toning, with darker soiling on the outer docket panel. Chipping and small losses along the left and right edges, including a notch at the lower left of the recto. Ink show-through visible on the verso. Text complete and legible.

The story behind this item

The document

This is a certificate of appraisement with a sheriff's return and a filing endorsement. On 11 June 1838 C. A. Carter, F. Wilcox and William Wilson certified that after due examination of Lot Number two, in Block Number Sixteen, in the City of Commerce, they put a dollar value on it. Below, the sheriff's return states that the appraisers were summoned and sworn to appraise according to the best of their judgment. It is signed 'Edson Whitney Shff, By D A Fullerton Dpt'. The verso records filing on 15 June 1838 under W. Williams, clerk, by a deputy whose compressed signature is read as S. O. Williams. A pencil note identifies Lot 2, Block 16, Commerce.

The sheet names no owner, litigants, writ or reason for the valuation. A court-related property proceeding is a reasonable inference from the sheriff's return and the filing. Neither a foreclosure nor a completed sale can be asserted. The figure is an appraisal. No purchase at that price is documented.

The county officers

Edson Whitney won Hancock County's first sheriff's election in 1829 and came from a family already active in county government. The return on this sheet was executed by his deputy. Later in 1838 Daniel A. Fullerton won the sheriff's election with 393 votes, against Harmon T. Wilson's 290 and Whitney's 120. The deputy who signed for Whitney in June defeated him that year. The returns show an electoral contest. They do not show a personal quarrel.

Wesley Williams was clerk of the county commissioners' and circuit courts. His son Samuel Otho Williams assisted him and is the working identification for the deputy on the verso. On 5 September 1839 Wesley Williams issued a receipt for recording the Nauvoo plat of 590 lots. In 1842 Whitney and Williams both ran for the legislature on the anti-Mormon ticket and lost. In September 1843 Whitney chaired an anti-Mormon meeting at Carthage. In June 1844 Wesley Williams is named in trial testimony as commanding a rifle corps, and Otho served with the Carthage Greys. Otho's letter of 10 July 1844 describes the killing of Joseph and Hyrum Smith at Carthage Jail.

The appraisers

C. A. Carter and William Wilson remain unidentified beyond this document. Nothing connects this William Wilson with Harmon T. Wilson. The initial of F. Wilcox is provisionally read as F. Franklin Wilcox is a plausible candidate. A later biography places him at Commerce in 1838, and a property list of about 1841 records land there under his full name. His sister Elizabeth married Isaac Galland, from whom Church representatives bought land in 1839. The signature has not been matched, and the kinship does not show that Galland owned this lot.

Commerce before Nauvoo

Commerce had a town plat dated May 1834, and the neighboring Commerce City was surveyed in April 1837. Latter-day Saint refugees from Missouri began arriving in early 1839. Church representatives made their first land purchases in the area on 30 April 1839, and Joseph Smith's family moved there on 10 May. The appraisal precedes those purchases by almost eleven months. The older Commerce grid stood at an angle to the later Nauvoo survey, so the lot cannot be located by matching numbers on a Nauvoo plat.

What remains unresolved

A Nauvoo property list compiled about November 1841 to January 1842 lists Lot 2, Block 16, Town of Commerce, under Ethan Kimball, assessed at $12. This is the best later lead for the parcel. An appraisal and a tax assessment are different measures, and neither is a sale price. The owner in June 1838, the court proceeding behind the valuation, the original plat location and the chain of title are all unestablished. The identities of Carter, Wilson and F. Wilcox remain open. No evidence presently ties Fullerton, Carter, Wilson or F. Wilcox to the events at Carthage in 1844.

Related items

More manuscripts