Home › Collection › Documents
Face: receipt to Davidson Hibbard for $3.44, signed Melgar Couchman, collector, 23 April 1847
Hancock County personal-property tax receipt to Davidson Hibbard, signed by Melgar Couchman, collector, 1847
Melgar Couchman, collector of Hancock County
A printed Hancock County tax receipt, completed by hand at the Collector's Office in Carthage on 23 April 1847. It acknowledges $3.44 from Davidson Hibbard for state and county tax on personal property valued at $492, for the tax year 1845. Melgar Couchman signed as collector. Hibbard was an early Hancock County settler who joined the Latter-day Saints in 1839 and stayed in Nauvoo after the exodus. Couchman held county office after election on an Anti-Mormon ticket in 1846. The receipt records an ordinary transaction between them.
- Inventory no.
- D-0015
- Author / maker
- Melgar Couchman, collector of Hancock County
- Place
- Collector's Office, Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 23 April 1847
- Format / binding
- Single printed receipt form completed in manuscript, with decorative printed borders above and below. Signed "Melgar Couchman, Collector H. C. Ills." Amount repeated as $3.44 in a ruled oval at lower left. Only the face is photographed and discussed.
- Signed
- Yes
- Taxpayer
- Davidson Hibbard
- Collector
- Melgar Couchman, Hancock County
- Amount
- $3.44, state and county tax, paid in full
- Tax year
- 1845 (personal property)
- Assessed value
- $492
Condition
Worn and folded, per the report. The photograph shows irregular edges with small losses along the lower edge and a tear at the upper right, toning, a vertical fold line and scattered brown spots.
The story behind this item
The receipt
This is a printed Hancock County tax receipt, completed by hand. The heading reads "Collector's Office Carthage, Ills." and the written date is 23 April 1847. It acknowledges receipt from Mr. Davidson Hibbard of three dollars and forty-four cents "in full" for state and county tax on personal property for the year 1845. The property was valued at 492 dollars. Melgar Couchman signed as "Collector H. C. Ills." The amount is repeated as $3.44 in a ruled oval at lower left. Decorative printed borders run above and below the text.
Two dates on one form
The payment was made in spring 1847. The tax year printed on the form is 1845. Between those dates came the departure of most Latter-day Saints from Nauvoo and the armed conflict of 1846. The receipt gives no reason for the delay. It does not say whether a demand had been postponed or an earlier account corrected. The $492 is a taxable valuation of personal property only. It does not describe Hibbard's real estate and does not inventory his goods. The report notes that seven-tenths of one percent of $492 is $3.444, which agrees with the written amount. It treats this as a check on the readings and does not claim it proves the rate the collector used.
Davidson Hibbard
Hibbard was born in Vermont in 1788, reached Illinois by 1824 and moved to Hancock County in 1829. He served as coroner and justice of the peace before the Saints arrived. He was baptized at Commerce on 11 August 1839. He belonged to the Nauvoo Masonic lodge and was appointed assistant inspector general in the Nauvoo Legion. The additions bearing his name helped shape the growing city. Earlier project research traces a property gift to the temple valued at $400 in 1843, a separate matter from this personal-property tax. Joseph Smith III later recalled that Emma Smith bought a cow from Hibbard that kept escaping back to its old home. Hibbard stayed in Nauvoo after the exodus. A lease to C. E. Yates in 1849 and a power of attorney to his son-in-law Milton M. Morrill in 1850 show his continuing affairs. He died in Nauvoo on 11 September 1854.
Melgar Couchman
Couchman had served as postmaster at Sweet Home, Missouri, in 1836 and as a justice of the peace in Clark County, Missouri, in 1837. The 1874 Hancock County directory lists M. Couchman as a Kentucky-born farmer who came to the county in 1845. In 1846 Sheriff Jacob B. Backenstos resigned for an army appointment in the war with Mexico. On 25 July an Anti-Mormon convention at Carthage nominated a county ticket that included Couchman for sheriff, and Thomas Gregg records that the ticket won. On 5 May 1847 Couchman, named as sheriff, certified a $7.75 redemption payment in the Wilson Law litigation. Cemetery evidence cited in earlier research gives 1 March 1847 as the death of his first wife, Adelia Lodoska White Couchman, less than two months before this receipt. The report keeps that date qualified as a cemetery transcription.
What the receipt shows
The receipt places a Latter-day Saint who stayed in Nauvoo and a collector elected on an Anti-Mormon ticket on the same piece of county business. The report cautions against reading it as reconciliation. In 1860 Judge Couchman offered resolutions at Carthage protesting the proposed return of Mormon settlers. The receipt records only a name, an amount, a valuation and a signature. It does not show whether Hibbard paid in person or through someone else.
What remains open
The report discusses only the face of the receipt. It does not identify a town lot or a land sale. The reason for paying an 1845 tax in 1847 is not known. This receipt is a separate document from the 1845 tax-sale certificate to Hibbard, which bears a later redemption endorsement by M. Couchman, and from the February 1844 Hibbard tax receipt signed by Charles C. Main.
Related items
More documents


