Home › Collection › Documents
Front: the completed tax receipt, February 1844, signed twice by Charles C. Main as collector.
Hancock County tax receipt issued to Davidson Hibbard at Carthage, February 1844
Charles C. Main, signing as Collector, Hancock County
A printed Hancock County tax receipt, completed by hand at the Collector's Office in Carthage in February 1844. It records D. Hibbard's payment of 1843 state and county taxes: $25.49 on land and Nauvoo town lots and $5.29 on personal property, $30.78 in all. Charles C. Main signed both portions as collector. The payor is Davidson Hibbard, an early Hancock County settler who was baptized at Commerce in 1839 and laid out two additions to Nauvoo.
- Inventory no.
- D-0003
- Author / maker
- Charles C. Main, signing as Collector, Hancock County
- Place
- Collector's Office, Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- February 1844
- Format / binding
- One leaf. Preprinted Hancock County tax-receipt form completed in brown ink on the front. The upper half records real property in a ruled table; the lower half records personal property. Signed twice by Charles C. Main, each time before the printed words "COLLECTOR, H. C." Later calculations and acreage notes in dark ink on the reverse, in a different hand.
- Signed
- Yes
- Payor
- D. Hibbard (Davidson Hibbard)
- Amount
- $25.49 real estate and $5.29 personal property; total $30.78
- Tax year
- 1843 state and county taxes
- Signatory
- Charles C. Main (also Maine), Collector, H. C., signed twice
- Property assessed
- Land in T6 R9 and T7 R6; town lots in Nauvoo
Condition
Horizontal and vertical folds, edge wear and staining, as the report describes. The photographs show toning along the folds and small chips at the edges and upper right corner.
The story behind this item
The document
The receipt is a preprinted form headed "State of Illinois, Hancock County" and "Collector's Office, Carthage." It is completed in brown ink and dated February 1844. The report reads the day as the 7th and marks that reading as uncertain. The upper half acknowledges $25.49 from D. Hibbard for state and county tax on land and town lots for 1843. The lower half acknowledges $5.29 in state and county tax on personal property for 1843, valued at $917.50. A manuscript total of $30.78 stands at the right.
The table lists four rural tracts: 65 acres in Section 1 and 37 acres in Section 12, Township 6, Range 9, valued at $1,950 and $810, and two 160-acre entries in Section 18, Township 7, Range 6, valued at $640 and $480. Those four valuations total $3,880. Grouped Nauvoo town lots follow, in blocks 1, 5, 9, 11, 12, 13, 19 and 20. Several lot numerals are overwritten and the report does not treat them as secure.
Davidson Hibbard
Hibbard was born at Brookfield, Vermont, on 20 August 1788. He was in Illinois by 1824 and in Hancock County by 1829. He was commissioned a militia captain in 1826, served as justice of the peace in 1827 and 1835, and was elected county coroner in 1832. He was baptized at Commerce on 11 August 1839. In October 1839 the Nauvoo High Council named him a trustee for a proposed stone schoolhouse at Upper Commerce.
In Nauvoo he created Hibbard's Addition and Hibbard's Second Addition on the southeast side of the city. He joined the Nauvoo Masonic Lodge and was appointed assistant inspector general of the Nauvoo Legion on 12 March 1842. His daughters married Amos Davis, Milton M. Morrill, Hugh White and Dr. John Fuller Weld. Hibbard stayed in the area after 1846 and died at Nauvoo on 11 September 1854.
Charles C. Main, collector
Main's autograph appears twice, each time before the printed title "COLLECTOR, H. C." The report prefers the spelling Main and records Maine as a contemporary variant. He was an early Carthage resident and an unsuccessful Democratic candidate for county commissioner in 1843 and 1844. An 1845 notice by county assessor John P. Haggard told taxpayers they could leave property lists with C. C. Main. The receipt shows Main acting as collector in February 1844. The appointment, bond or statute under which he acted has not been confirmed.
County tax and city tax
The receipt belongs to the state and county tax system administered from Carthage. Nauvoo assessed and collected its own city taxes under separate records. The report insists that the two systems be kept apart. It also cautions that the receipt is a snapshot of assessed property and cannot be read as a list of land Hibbard still owned in fee.
Lot 4, Block 12 of Hibbard's Addition shows why. Hibbard and his wife Sarah conveyed it to Benjamin Riter on 6 July 1842 for $200. Nauvoo later charged the lot to "Benjamin Writer" for 1842 city taxes, and the Municipal Court entered a tax judgment in February 1844. A notice of May 1845 states that the same lot had been sold for taxes at Carthage in 1843 and that the redemption period was about to expire.
What remains unresolved
The May 1845 notice does not name the taxpayer assessed, the purchaser, the sale price or any redeemer. The report identifies the Hancock County Tax Sale Record, 1834-1848, held at the Western Illinois University IRAD depository, as the decisive source. Whether the February 1844 municipal judgment against Riter led to a completed sale is also unproved. Thomas Bullock's journal records Hibbard redeeming tax-sold land on 17 and 18 February 1845, but names no parcels.
The relationship between the grouped Block 12 and Block 5 entries on the receipt and the disputed parcels needs reading from the original. The reverse carries later notes on a "First Addition," apparently a second addition, and section acreage. The report treats them as a lead and does not transcribe them definitively.
Related items
More documents


