Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Documents

Face: printed tax-sale certificate completed for Davidson Hibbard, sale of 12 May 1845, signed by George W. Thatcher, clerk.

Documents · Hancock County, Illinois · 12 May 1845; endorsed 1848

Tax-sale certificate to Davidson Hibbard for Nauvoo lots, Hancock County, 1845, with 1848 redemption endorsement

George W. Thatcher, clerk of the Hancock County Commissioners' Court; endorsed by M. Couchman, collector (identified in the report as William Melgar Couchman, Hancock County sheriff)

A printed Hancock County Commissioners' Court tax-sale certificate, completed by hand. It records that Davidson Hibbard bought the listed Nauvoo town lots at public sale on 12 May 1845 for state and county taxes and costs. George W. Thatcher signed as clerk. The reverse carries a redemption acknowledgment of 1848 signed by M. Couchman as collector, identified in the report as Hancock County sheriff William Melgar Couchman. The paper places Hibbard's own additions to Nauvoo inside the county's tax and title system after the Latter-day Saint departure.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
D-0007
Author / maker
George W. Thatcher, clerk of the Hancock County Commissioners' Court; endorsed by M. Couchman, collector (identified in the report as William Melgar Couchman, Hancock County sheriff)
Place
Hancock County, Illinois
Date
12 May 1845; endorsed 1848
Format / binding
Printed Hancock County Commissioners' Court tax-sale certificate completed in manuscript, signed by George W. Thatcher as clerk. Reverse carries a manuscript redemption acknowledgment signed "M. Couchman, Collector." The report gives no dimensions or leaf count.
Signed
Yes
Purchaser
Davidson Hibbard
Clerk
George W. Thatcher, Hancock County Commissioners' Court
Endorsement
Redemption acknowledgment, 1848, signed M. Couchman, Collector
Amount
Visible total appears to be $3.42 (tax and costs)
Parcels
Lots in Hibbard's Addition and Hibbard's Second Addition, Nauvoo

Condition

Irregular loss at the upper right corner of the face, with small edge chips. Fold lines, toning and scattered brown spotting. Some rows on the face are pale or overwritten, and the reverse shows faint show-through of the printed face.

The story behind this item

The certificate

The face is a printed tax-sale certificate of the Hancock County Commissioners' Court, completed in manuscript. It records that Davidson Hibbard purchased the listed property at public sale on 12 May 1845 for state and county taxes and costs. George W. Thatcher signed in his capacity as clerk. The amounts written on the certificate include tax and sale costs. The visible total appears to be $3.42. Several individual rows are pale or overwritten, and the report recommends transcribing them conservatively from the original, with uncertain characters bracketed.

The reverse endorsement

The reverse contains a later redemption acknowledgment signed by M. Couchman. The report dates this endorsement to 1848 and does not give a day or month. The signature reads "M Couchman" with the title "Collector," a reading the owner has confirmed from the original. The notation records payment or collection. The handwriting can resemble Conchman or Kochman. The report identifies the signer as William Melgar Couchman from his county office, comparison signatures and the formula used. The paper therefore records two stages: Hibbard's tax purchase in 1845 and a subsequent redemption handled by Couchman.

The parcels

The Nauvoo Neighbor of 7 April 1845 published the delinquent real-estate list that preceded the May sale. It names Davidson Hibbard as assessed owner of numerous lots in Hibbard's Addition and eight lots in Hibbard's Second Addition, taxed at $0.15 to $0.60 each in the first and $0.30 each in the second. The report states that these entries closely parallel the certificate. The newspaper figures are tax only and should not be equated mechanically with the certificate amounts.

The 1874 county atlas places Hibbard's additions beside the older Nauvoo grid, with the Second Addition farther south near the river-facing edge of the plat. The certificate concerns town lots scattered through Hibbard's own additions. It does not concern a single farm tract or one contiguous holding.

The people named

Davidson Hibbard was the proprietor of the two Nauvoo additions that bear his name. His wife was Sarah Tilton Hibbard, and his daughter Emeline Frances Hibbard married Hugh Henry White.

George W. Thatcher is called the county commissioners' clerk in contemporary narrative evidence, and the printed heading and his signature are consistent with that office.

Couchman was born in Kentucky, probably on 22 August 1814. He was a postmaster and justice of the peace in Clark County, Missouri, in 1836 and 1837. The 1874 Hancock County directory states that he came to the county in 1845. A convention at Carthage on 25 July 1846 nominated an Anti-Mormon county ticket with Couchman for sheriff, and he won. Court records place him in that office from October 1846 through September 1849. He later served as county judge. No record located for the report identifies him as a Latter-day Saint, a member of the Nauvoo Legion or a Freemason. No evidence was found that he took part in the 1844 killings.

Context

As sheriff, Couchman handled legal business left behind when most Latter-day Saints departed. On 5 May 1847 he certified a redemption payment of $7.75 by Wilson Law through attorney Almon W. Babbitt. He levied on the property of Hiram Kimball in January 1847, and an 1849 order directed him to summon Emma Hale Smith Bidamon and others. The report places the Hibbard certificate in the same administrative pattern. Couchman's name on the reverse reflects his county authority. It is not evidence that he owned the Hibbard parcels, and the endorsement is not a private conveyance.

What remains unresolved

The identity of the signer is treated as strong. His title on the reverse reads "Collector." The full wording of the payment notation still needs closer review of the original. Individual parcel rows on the face are not fully read. A proposed reading that would connect a Sarah McFarland to the parcels was tested against Nauvoo and Hancock sources and is retained only as a rejected or dormant hypothesis. The report names the Hancock County Tax Sale Record 1834-1848 and the Old Certificates of Purchase, Levy, and Redemption as the records that could complete the title chain. Those have not been examined.

Related items

More documents