Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Documents

Front: the completed appeal bond, Durfee v. Hibbard, with Hibbard and Robison signatures and Davis approval, December 1841

Documents · Hancock County, Illinois (appeal from Nauvoo; filed in the Hancock County Circuit Court) · December 1841 (executed 4 December, reading uncertain; filed 6 December 1841)

Appeal bond in Durfee v. Hibbard, from John C. Bennett's mayoral judgment, Hancock County, 1841

Davison Hibbard, principal, and Lewis Robison, surety; witnessed, approved and filed by J. C. Davis, clerk of the Hancock County Circuit Court

A printed appeal bond, completed in manuscript, from Jabez Durfee v. Davison Hibbard, Hancock County, Illinois, December 1841. It records an appeal from a judgment of $63.51 debt plus costs rendered on 1 December 1841 by John C. Bennett, then mayor of Nauvoo. Hibbard and his surety Lewis Robison signed; circuit clerk Jacob C. Davis witnessed, approved, and filed it on 6 December. The bond preserves Bennett acting as a magistrate five months before his break with Joseph Smith.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
D-0009
Author / maker
Davison Hibbard, principal, and Lewis Robison, surety; witnessed, approved and filed by J. C. Davis, clerk of the Hancock County Circuit Court
Place
Hancock County, Illinois (appeal from Nauvoo; filed in the Hancock County Circuit Court)
Date
December 1841 (executed 4 December, reading uncertain; filed 6 December 1841)
Format / binding
Single leaf, printed appeal bond form completed in manuscript on the front; printed and manuscript filing endorsement on the reverse, folded into panels. Signed by Davison Hibbard and Lewis Robison beside printed [SEAL.] marks; signed by J. C. Davis as witness and again as clerk under "Approved." Endorsement signed J. C. Davis, clerk.
Signed
Yes
Parties
Jabez Durfee (Durphy), plaintiff; Davison Hibbard (Hibard), defendant and appellant
Lower-court judge
John C. Bennett, mayor of Nauvoo
Judgment
$63.51 debt, plus costs (about $1.56, uncertain)
Bond amount
$135
Signatories
Davison Hibbard; Lewis Robison, surety; J. C. Davis, witness and clerk

Condition

Photographs show horizontal and vertical fold lines, overall toning heavier at the edges, small chips and losses along the right edge near the foot, and show-through of the front text on the reverse. Several words after "wherein" on the front are canceled with heavy ink. A pale rectangular area appears near the lower seals on the front and on one reverse panel.

The story behind this item

The document

This is a printed appeal bond form completed in manuscript, with a filing endorsement on the reverse. It records that Davison Hibbard and Lewis Robison were bound to Jabez Durfee (written "Jabez Durphy") in the sum of $135. The condition was that Hibbard pay whatever judgment the Hancock County Circuit Court might render on dismissal or trial of his appeal. The judgment appealed from was rendered by "John C Bennett Mayor" on 1 December 1841, for $63.51 debt and costs of suit. The cost entry appears to read $1.56, but the final word is uncertain.

The execution day on the front is tentatively read as 4 December; the report treats that reading as ambiguous. The reverse is endorsed as an appeal bond, filed 6 December 1841 in the Hancock Circuit Court by J. C. Davis, clerk. The report stresses that the $135 was a conditional penal sum, not a second debt already paid.

John C. Bennett as magistrate

Bennett is named in the bond as the judicial officer whose judgment was appealed. He did not sign it. In December 1841 he was mayor of Nauvoo, major general of the Nauvoo Legion, chancellor of the University of Nauvoo, and temporary assistant president in the First Presidency. The printed form refers to a justice of the peace; the manuscript entry adds his title of mayor. The report describes the case as a civil promissory-note matter, heard under the justice-of-the-peace powers associated with his office, and distinguishes it from the later habeas corpus controversies.

Within months his standing collapsed. A notice of 11 May 1842 withdrew fellowship from him, and he resigned as mayor on 17 May 1842. Later that year he published The History of the Saints, an attack on Joseph Smith and Nauvoo. The bond records him before that break.

The other people on the paper

Jabez Durfee was a carpenter and millwright born in Rhode Island in 1791, a Missouri refugee, and later one of the steady carpenters in the Nauvoo Temple shop. Davison Hibbard was a longtime Illinois militia officer and justice of the peace who joined the Church at Commerce in 1839. In October 1839 the two men were named to the same proposed stone schoolhouse project, Hibbard as trustee and Durfee as architect and building committee member.

Lewis Robison, Hibbard's surety, served in 1841 as Nauvoo city assessor and collector. Jacob Cunningham Davis witnessed, approved, and filed the bond as Hancock County circuit clerk. He was later among the defendants tried and acquitted in 1845 in connection with the killing of Joseph Smith. The report cautions that the bond supplies no evidence of his later conduct.

The appeal after the bond

Related papers survive elsewhere. BYU's L. Tom Perry Special Collections holds a writ of certiorari (MSS SC 712) ordering the mayor of Nauvoo to send the promissory note for use in the case, and a subpoena dated 18 April 1842. The report's chronology also lists a summons, a praecipe, an affidavit, and a further praecipe through 4 April 1843; those dates come from earlier finding-aid research and were not re-read from the manuscripts.

What remains unresolved

The original promissory note has not been located, so the transaction behind the debt is unknown. The report treats the schoolhouse connection as a hypothesis, not a finding. Hibbard's grounds of appeal, the testimony, and the final circuit-court disposition have not been found. The report makes no claim that Bennett's judgment was affirmed or reversed.

Related items

More documents