Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Custody receipt for John Eagle and a second prisoner, signed for Sheriff William Backenstos by G. W. Stigal, 2 March 1843

Manuscripts · Carthage and Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois · 1843-1845

Papers in Eagle v. Foster, false imprisonment suit, Hancock County Circuit Court, 1843-1845

Hancock County Circuit Court officers and counsel: George Bachman, attorney for plaintiff; O. C. Skinner, attorney for defendant; Jacob B. Backenstos, clerk; William Backenstos, sheriff

A group of original Hancock County Circuit Court papers from case 97, John Eagle v. Robert D. Foster. Eagle, a Nauvoo grocer, sued Foster, a physician and justice of the peace, for trespass and false imprisonment and claimed $1,000. The papers run from a sheriff's custody receipt for Eagle dated 2 March 1843, through summonses, pleas, subpoenas and witness certificates, to the signed jury verdict for Foster and a fee-bill request of November 1845. They document one disputed day in Nauvoo and a suit against a future Nauvoo Expositor publisher.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0019
Author / maker
Hancock County Circuit Court officers and counsel: George Bachman, attorney for plaintiff; O. C. Skinner, attorney for defendant; Jacob B. Backenstos, clerk; William Backenstos, sheriff
Place
Carthage and Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
1843-1845
Format / binding
Group of separate papers from one case file: manuscript requests, a custody receipt, pleas, the jury verdict and a fee-bill request, with printed summons, subpoena and witness-certificate forms completed in manuscript. Several bear clerks' filing endorsements on folded wrappers or reverses; printed forms carry embossed court seals. Original signatures of attorneys, court officers, witnesses and twelve jurors. The declaration face and the continuation of Foster's plea are not present among the photographs.
Signed
Yes
Parties
John Eagle, plaintiff; Robert D. Foster, defendant
Court
Hancock County Circuit Court, May Term 1843, case 97
Amount claimed
$1,000 damages
Counsel
George Bachman for Eagle; Onias C. Skinner for Foster
Outcome
Jury verdict for the defendant

Condition

Photographs show folding creases on most papers, general toning, deckled and ragged edges on several forms, a ragged right edge on the custody receipt, scattered ink spots on certificate reverses and a small edge notch on the fee-bill request. Papers are housed in plastic sleeves; modern adhesive research notes are attached to some, including the verdict.

The story behind this item

The papers and what they say

The packet opens with a small slip: "Received the body of John Eagle" and a second prisoner, whose name appears to read George G. Fidler. Constable James M. Flack delivered them on 2 March 1843. G. W. Stigal signed as deputy for Sheriff William Backenstos. The receipt records custody. It does not state where Eagle was held or under what authority.

On 1 March 1843 Eagle's attorney, George Bachman, had already asked the circuit clerk to issue a summons. The claim was trespass for false imprisonment, with damages of $1,000. The printed summons followed on 3 March under clerk Jacob B. Backenstos and was served on Foster on 14 April. The declaration was filed on 3 April. Only its wrapper survives in the photographs; the report carries its text forward from an earlier transcription.

The defense

Foster's pleas were filed on 16 May 1843. The first denies guilt and puts the case to a jury. The second states that Foster was a justice of the peace. It says a complainant, tentatively read as Henry Rhoads, swore that Horace Burgess kept a common gaming house. Foster issued a warrant and Burgess was brought before him. The photographed page ends there. The rest of the explanation has not been recovered.

The people

John Eagle was born in Pennsylvania in 1805 and worked in Nauvoo as a grocer and laborer. In 1841 he opposed the city's destruction of a grocery building in which he held an interest, and a prosecution followed. Robert D. Foster, born in England in 1811, was a physician, Nauvoo Legion surgeon general and justice of the peace. He had traveled with Joseph Smith to Washington. In 1844 he was excommunicated and joined the publishers of the Nauvoo Expositor.

Foster's counsel was Onias C. Skinner, later a justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Skinner requested a subpoena for Chauncey L. Higbee on 20 May. Witness certificates sworn on 26 May place Flack, J. A. McCall, Charles Warner, William Allen and Horace Burgess at court for Eagle. Burgess, the man named in the gaming-house complaint, thus appears as a witness for the plaintiff. George W. Stigall, apparently the deputy who signed the receipt, was also subpoenaed for Eagle.

Verdict and aftermath

The verdict reads: "We the Jury find for the defendant." Twelve jurors signed. Several signatures remain hard to read, and the report's juror identifications are offered with stated limits. The exact verdict date is not established. An earlier report gave 17 May, but the packet contains papers dated as late as 26 May.

In December 1843 Foster and Aaron Johnson heard a separate charge against Eagle arising from the Badham robbery. They discharged him for want of evidence. On 20 November 1845, according to the report, William Backenstos asked the clerk to issue a fee bill in the case for collection.

What remains unresolved

The papers prove that Eagle was in custody on 2 March 1843, that he sued Foster, and that the jury found for Foster. They do not show why Eagle was restrained, where, or whether the alleged beating occurred. The beating is part of Eagle's pleading only. The gaming-house charge against Burgess is an allegation in Foster's plea. The second prisoner's name and the complainant's name are tentative readings. The fee bill does not state an amount or show payment. The report lists the complete plea, the Burgess complaint and warrant, the court minutes and judgment, and the fee bill itself as the records most likely to answer these questions.

Related items

More manuscripts