Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Front: the assignment, Nauvoo, 13 March 1845, signed Geo. P. Stiles

Manuscripts · Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois · 13 March 1845 (filed 19 March 1845)

George P. Stiles assignment to William Backenstos of a ten-dollar judgment against Robert D. Foster, Nauvoo, 1845

George P. Stiles, attorney, assignor (signed "Geo. P. Stiles"); filing endorsement by D. E. Head, clerk

A short manuscript assignment signed at Nauvoo on 13 March 1845 by George P. Stiles, the attorney who served as Nauvoo city attorney in 1844 and argued in council that the Nauvoo Expositor was a nuisance. For value received, Stiles transferred to William Backenstos his interest in a ten-dollar judgment rendered before Justice Higbee in his favor against Robert D. Foster, one of the Expositor's publishers. The reverse carries a docket and a filing endorsement of 19 March 1845 by D. E. Head, clerk.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0031
Author / maker
George P. Stiles, attorney, assignor (signed "Geo. P. Stiles"); filing endorsement by D. E. Head, clerk
Place
Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
13 March 1845 (filed 19 March 1845)
Format / binding
Single manuscript sheet on ruled paper. Front: assignment in nine lines, dated Nauvoo, March 13th 1845, signed Geo. P. Stiles. Reverse: docket "Geo P Stiles vs Wm Backenstos, Assignment of Judgt" with filing endorsement "Filed March 19. 1845, D E Head clk".
Signed
Yes
Parties
George P. Stiles, assignor; William Backenstos, assignee
Judgment debtor
Robert D. Foster
Amount of judgment
Ten dollars
Court
Before Justice Higbee (first name not stated)
Filed
19 March 1845, D. E. Head, clerk

Condition

The photographs show fold lines, light toning, ink show-through from the front visible on the reverse, and an irregular lower edge.

The story behind this item

The document

The front of the sheet reads, in Stiles's assignment, that for value received he assigns all his right, title and interest in a judgment rendered before Justice Higbee in his favor and against "Robt. D. Foster," amount ten dollars, to William Backenstos, and that Backenstos "is to take the responsibility of the whole Judgment & cost." It is dated Nauvoo, March 13th 1845, and signed Geo. P. Stiles. The reverse is docketed "Geo P Stiles vs Wm Backenstos, Assignment of Judgt" and endorsed "Filed March 19. 1845, D E Head clk."

The words establish a transfer, not its price. "For Value Received" acknowledges consideration without stating the amount, and ten dollars describes the judgment, not necessarily what Backenstos paid. The "vs" heading on the reverse does not by itself establish a separate lawsuit between the two men.

George P. Stiles

The Joseph Smith Papers dates Stiles's birth to 18 July 1816 at Watertown, New York. He was an attorney at Carthage by February 1842, was initiated in the Nauvoo Masonic lodge in April 1842, and was married to Sophia J. Schofield by Joseph Smith on 4 February 1843. A Nauvoo Neighbor advertisement of 3 May 1843 placed his office at Knights and Wells streets, a short distance north of the temple. He was chosen city attorney on 13 April 1844, and around 8 June 1844 billed the city forty dollars for legal services that included proceedings against Robert D. Foster.

On 10 June 1844 Willard Richards's council minutes record Stiles arguing that the Expositor was a nuisance and that he "would go in for suppressing" further publications of the kind. The proposal to destroy the press came in the next speech, from Hyrum Smith. Stiles then defended Joseph Smith and the other defendants at the 17 June hearing before Daniel H. Wells. His recorded baptism, by Brigham Young, followed on 26 August 1844.

Foster, Backenstos and Head

Robert D. Foster, a physician and former Nauvoo justice and university regent, had been excommunicated by April 1844 and joined William Law's movement and the Expositor. Stiles had acted against him as city attorney that spring. Those cases establish direct legal contact between the two men, but they do not identify the cause of this judgment.

William Backenstos, born in Pennsylvania in 1813, served as Hancock County sheriff after his election in 1842 and lived in Nauvoo by late 1844. The report takes care to separate him from his brother Jacob B. Backenstos. The clerk's initials are read as those of David E. Head, Hancock County circuit clerk from 1844 to 1856.

Which Justice Higbee

The paper gives no first name. The report names Isaac Higbee, a Nauvoo bishop elected justice of the peace in 1843, as the leading candidate, and notes a parallel case, Niswanger v. Wight and Jett, in which a judgment passed through several assignments and reached William Backenstos in September 1845. That case is a lead, not a match. Elias, Francis M. and Chauncey L. Higbee are distinct men, and until a docket or the original judgment names the justice the reading stays "Justice Higbee."

What remains unresolved

The cause of the judgment, its date, the price paid for the assignment and whether it was ever collected are all unknown. The judgment may predate the assignment by some time. The report's suggested next records are Hancock circuit-court party indexes, case files, judgment and execution dockets, and any surviving justice-of-the-peace transcripts. The accompanying research report also follows Stiles to Kanesville, Iowa, to an 1854 federal appointment as associate justice in Utah Territory, his December 1856 excommunication, the raid on his law office, and his later life in Ohio and Texas.

Related items

More manuscripts