Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Case wrapper: Timothy Griffin & wife vs Thomas Culkin, Slander, with docket numbers and note Costs made out

Manuscripts · Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois · 8 July to 26 October 1843

Case papers in Griffin and wife v. Culkin, slander suit, Hancock County Circuit Court, 1843

Bachman & Skinner, attorneys for the plaintiffs; Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk (by David E. Head, deputy); William Backenstos, sheriff; Timothy Griffin, plaintiff

The surviving court papers of a slander suit brought in Hancock County in the summer of 1843. Timothy Griffin and his wife Ann claimed five hundred dollars in damages for words Thomas Culkin was alleged to have spoken of Ann. The packet holds the attorneys' praecipe, the summons, a witness subpoena, the sheriff's returns, and Timothy Griffin's signed instruction to discontinue the suit. The papers carry the hands or names of George Bachman, Onias C. Skinner, and the Backenstos brothers, men who later figured in the conflicts surrounding the Latter-day Saints.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0038
Author / maker
Bachman & Skinner, attorneys for the plaintiffs; Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk (by David E. Head, deputy); William Backenstos, sheriff; Timothy Griffin, plaintiff
Place
Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
8 July to 26 October 1843
Format / binding
Court packet of related papers shown in nine photographs: a manuscript case wrapper; the attorneys' handwritten praecipe for summons and subpoena, with filing endorsement on the reverse; a printed summons form completed by hand, with sheriff's return and fees on the reverse; a printed subpoena form completed by hand, with service return and fees on the reverse; and Timothy Griffin's handwritten authorization to discontinue, with filing endorsement on the reverse. Summons and subpoena bear embossed court seals. Signatures of Timothy Griffin, J. B. Backenstos (by deputy David E. Head) and William Backenstos; the praecipe is signed in the firm name Bachman & Skinner.
Signed
Yes
Parties
Timothy Griffin and Ann his wife v. Thomas Culkin
Court
Hancock County Circuit Court, October term 1843
Action
Slander (action on the case)
Damages claimed
$500
Signatories
Bachman & Skinner (firm name); J. B. Backenstos by David E. Head; Wm Backenstos; Timothy Griffin

Condition

The photographs show fold lines on all pieces and light toning. The wrapper has a brown stain at center and a dark ink blot at the right edge. The praecipe has an irregular cut along its lower edge. The authorization has a rough lower edge. The summons has a small split at the upper fold.

The story behind this item

The suit and its papers

On 8 July 1843, the Carthage firm of Bachman & Skinner asked the clerk of the Hancock County Circuit Court to issue a summons against Thomas Culkin. The case was for slanderous words spoken of Ann, wife of the plaintiff Timothy Griffin. Damages were laid at five hundred dollars. That figure is the amount claimed. No award is recorded. The same request asked for a subpoena for Ann Middleton as a witness for the plaintiffs.

The packet preserves that request together with the case wrapper, the summons, the subpoena, and their returns. None of the papers records the words Culkin was alleged to have said. No testimony or statement of the alleged slander survives in the packet, and what Middleton knew remains uncertain.

Process and service

The summons and subpoena were issued on 10 July 1843 in the name of Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk, and signed for him by his deputy, David E. Head. The summons ordered Culkin to appear on the first day of the October term at the court house in Carthage. The printed form was altered by hand: the clerk's name J. C. Davis was struck and replaced, and the printed plea was corrected to an action on the case.

William Backenstos, the clerk's brother, was sheriff. His return on the summons states that he could not find Culkin in the county. His return on the subpoena states that he served Ann Middleton by reading the writ to her on 31 July 1843. His fees on the subpoena came to one dollar and fifty cents, including eighteen miles of travel. The report notes that the mileage does not establish where Middleton lived.

A decision to stop

On 15 August 1843, Timothy Griffin signed a short instruction: he authorized and wished his attorneys Bachman & Skinner to discontinue the suit. The caption first named him Timothy Culkin, and the surname was corrected to Griffin above the line. The reverse is endorsed as filed on 26 October 1843 by J. B. Backenstos, clerk.

The reason for stopping was not recorded. The report raises the possibilities of an understanding between the parties or second thoughts about expense or difficulty, and states that the documents do not choose among them. There is no surviving apology, payment agreement, or explanation from Ann. The packet preserves the instruction to discontinue. It does not contain a separate judicial order explaining a final disposition.

The attorneys and officials

George Bachman had written to Joseph Smith on 21 January 1843 offering friendship and assistance. That letter is held by the Church History Library and is reproduced in the report for context. In November 1845, after the killing of Edmund Durfee, the church history records the arrest of George Backman with others and their discharge without examination. Jacob Backenstos, in a report the Church History Library catalog dates circa March 1846, named George Backman as one of the Durfee murderers. Governor Thomas Ford also described the attackers as acting under Backman. The report states that these accusations do not prove Bachman fired the fatal shot, and that his release does not establish his innocence.

Onias C. Skinner gave a closing argument for the defense in May 1845 in the trial of men accused of Joseph Smith's murder. Backenstos separately listed Skinner among those he held responsible for the deaths of Joseph and Hyrum Smith. The report treats that as an accusation. No court made such a finding. Jacob Backenstos later became sheriff and was closely involved in efforts to protect the Saints.

What the papers establish

The packet documents the steps of a short-lived civil action in the Hancock County Circuit Court: the request for process, the writs, the sheriff's returns and fees, and the plaintiff's instruction to discontinue. It shows Bachman, Skinner, and the Backenstos brothers at ordinary legal work in 1843. The slanderous words, the reason for discontinuing, and the final disposition remain unknown. Two dates are uncertain: the filing day on the praecipe and the overwritten appearance day on the subpoena.

Related items

More manuscripts