Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Documents

Front: printed subpoena completed and signed by Wm. N. Grover, J. P., 20 August 1845

Documents · Hancock County, Illinois (Grover's office; no location given on the document) · 20 August 1845

Subpoena in Spurgin v. Kimball, signed by William N. Grover as justice of the peace, 1845

William N. Grover, justice of the peace

A printed Hancock County subpoena, completed and signed by William N. Grover as justice of the peace on 20 August 1845. It commands Josiah Spurgin, Catharine Mathias, James Cross and a further witness to testify in Jesse Spurgin's suit against James L. Kimball. Less than three months earlier Grover had been tried for the murder of Joseph Smith and acquitted. A James L. Kimball had been summoned as a prospective juror in that trial. The reverse records service on 21 August and an apparent filing on 20 October 1845.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
D-0020
Author / maker
William N. Grover, justice of the peace
Place
Hancock County, Illinois (Grover's office; no location given on the document)
Date
20 August 1845
Format / binding
Single leaf. Printed subpoena form with decorative border and printed seal, completed in manuscript and signed "Wm. N. Grover J. P." on the front. Reverse carries a manuscript constable's service return, case caption, constable's fee notation and clerk's filing endorsement, written at different angles.
Signed
Yes
Parties
Jesse Spurgin, plaintiff; James L. Kimball, defendant
Witnesses
Josiah Spurgin, Catharine Mathias, James Cross, John A. French (provisional)
Issued by
William N. Grover, justice of the peace
Service
21 August 1845, by constable (name provisionally John Musselman)
Filed
Apparently 20 October 1845, D. E. Head, clerk

Condition

Folded; fold lines visible on both sides. Paper evenly toned with scattered small spots. Some writing on the front is altered. Printing from the front shows through on the reverse.

The story behind this item

The document

This is a printed subpoena form headed State of Illinois, Hancock County, completed in manuscript. It commands Josiah Spurgin, Catharine Mathias and James Cross to appear before the justice at "my office" on 25 August 1845 at 1 o'clock P.M. They were to testify in a suit in which Jesse Spurgin is plaintiff and James L Kimball defendant. An additional altered name is read provisionally as John A. French. The form is dated 20 August 1845 and signed Wm. N. Grover, J. P., beside a printed seal. No street or building is given for the office.

On the reverse the constable recorded serving the process by reading it to Josiah Spurgin, James Cross and Catharine Mathias on 21 August 1845. His signature is provisionally read as John Musselman, and the given name remains uncertain. The caption reads Spurgin vs Kimball, Subpoena, with a constable's fee of 30. A separate endorsement appears to record filing on 20 October 1845 by D. E. Head, clerk.

William N. Grover

Grover was a Warsaw lawyer, elected justice of the peace in 1843. He also served as captain of the Warsaw Cadets. A Warsaw Signal extra of 19 June 1844 reported that "Captain Grover" had obtained 59 muskets from Quincy. After the killing of Joseph and Hyrum Smith at Carthage on 27 June 1844, Grover was among those tried for Joseph Smith's murder. Witnesses Eliza Jane Graham and Benjamin Brackenbury attributed admissions to him. Ann Fleming and E. W. Gould gave testimony that conflicted with Graham's account. On 30 May 1845 the jury returned a verdict of not guilty. Grover married Cornelia Leonard in July 1845. This subpoena shows him back at the routine work of his office the following month. He later became United States attorney for the Eastern District of Missouri in 1863 and died at Warsaw in August 1899.

The defendant and the jury pool

James L. Kimball is strongly identified with J. L. Kimball, a Warsaw forwarding and commission merchant who advertised on the same newspaper page as Grover in September 1843. A Brigham Young University catalog records a J. L. Kimball receipt to Orson Hyde dated 5 February 1845. On 22 May 1845 a return in the murder case named "Jas. L. Kimball" among men summoned for jury selection. That list does not show he sat on the final jury. Within three months the paperwork reversed their positions, with Kimball as defendant before Grover.

The Spurgins and the witnesses

The plaintiff is probably the Jesse Spurgin named as a priest in an 18 October 1842 petition concerning a church branch in the Montebello area. The report also proposes, as probable, that he was the Montebello doctor Warren Foote called Spergen. Neither identification is proved by the case papers. A Jesse Spurgin was named to the Montebello land-sale committee in the Nauvoo Neighbor of 29 October 1845. Josiah Spurgin is a distinct entry, and his relationship to Jesse is unknown. Catharine Mathias is probably the Catharine Spurgin who married Abraham Mathias on 8 May 1845, though her kinship to the other Spurgins is not established. James Cross has not been securely identified.

What the paper proves and what remains open

The subpoena documents Grover acting as justice of the peace in August 1845, after his acquittal. It records issuance, service and a later filing as separate events. It also places David E. Head, who certified the May 1845 defendants' affidavit, in its filing endorsement. That shared clerk does not link the cases legally. The complaint and judgment in Spurgin v. Kimball have not been located. The cause of the suit, whether the hearing took place and who prevailed all remain unknown. The readings John A. French and John Musselman are provisional.

Related items

More documents