Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Documents

Front: sheriff's certificate of sale signed by William Backenstos, 9 May 1843

Documents · Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois · 9 May 1843, with endorsement of 12 April 1850

Sheriff's certificate of sale, Haggard and Barnes v. Welch, Carthage lot, 1843

William Backenstos, sheriff of Hancock County; reverse endorsed by C. Robison, recorder, and John Carlin, sheriff

A printed Hancock County sheriff's certificate, completed in ink and signed by William Backenstos on 9 May 1843. It records the courthouse-door sale of Andrew B. Welch's Lot 2, Block 14, in Carthage under an execution in favor of John P. Haggard and Michael Barnes, with Haggard the purchaser. The reverse carries Chauncey Robison's 1843 recording docket and John Carlin's 1850 note of a deed made to Lucius Parker, Haggard's assignee. Three of its officials figure in Nauvoo history.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
D-0019
Author / maker
William Backenstos, sheriff of Hancock County; reverse endorsed by C. Robison, recorder, and John Carlin, sheriff
Place
Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
9 May 1843, with endorsement of 12 April 1850
Format / binding
Single printed form completed in manuscript, with ornamental border at left. Signed by William Backenstos as sheriff, with printed seal box. Reverse carries a manuscript filing and recording docket signed C. Robison, Recorder (written at right angles), and a later deed endorsement signed John Carlin, Sheriff.
Signed
Yes
Parties
John P. Haggard and Michael Barnes v. Andrew B. Welch
Court
Hancock County Circuit Court (venditioni exponas execution)
Parcel
Lot 2, Block 14, Town of Carthage
Amount
$33.33 plus a fractional cent (provisionally one-third)
Signatories
William Backenstos, sheriff; C. Robison, recorder; John Carlin, sheriff

Condition

Photographs show the sheet folded in horizontal panels, with toning and water staining, heaviest along the right edge of the front and the left edge of the reverse. A pencil number 13 appears at the upper right of the front.

The story behind this item

The certificate

This is a printed Hancock County sheriff's certificate of sale, completed in manuscript and signed by Sheriff William Backenstos on 9 May 1843. It recites a venditioni exponas execution from the Hancock County Circuit Court, dated 8 April 1843, in favor of John P. Haggard and Michael Barnes and against Andrew B. Welch. Under that writ the sheriff exposed to public sale, at the door of the Court House in Carthage, Lot 2 in Block 14 in the Town of Carthage, with its appurtenances and improvements. Haggard alone became the purchaser for thirty-three dollars and thirty-three cents, with a further fractional-cent mark the report reads, provisionally, as one-third. The sheriff certified that Haggard would be entitled to a deed after fifteen months unless the lot was sooner redeemed.

The report stresses that this is an execution sale following a court judgment, not a tax sale. The price is the winning bid. It is not the judgment amount, Welch's total debt, or the lot's market value. The printed reference to improvements does not identify any building.

The reverse

The center panel, written at right angles, dockets the paper as a duplicate of the sale certificate, Sheriff of Hancock County to John P. Haggard, in Haggard and Barnes vs. Welch. It was filed 15 May 1843 by C. Robison, Recorder, and recorded in the Book of Old Certificates, page 103. A small notation beside the case caption is unclear and is not adopted as a case number. The report notes that "Duplicate" is the docket description and does not mean the paper is a modern copy.

At the top, a later endorsement reads that a deed was made to Lucius Parker, assignee of Haggard, for the lot on 12 April 1850, signed John Carlin, Sheriff. This notation is not the deed itself.

The men named

William Backenstos, the signing sheriff, is distinct from his brother Jacob B. Backenstos. Less than five months after this sale he married Clara M. Wasson, Emma Smith's niece, at Nauvoo on 3 October 1843, with Joseph Smith performing the ceremony. Chauncey Robison, county recorder from 1839 to 1847, was initiated an Entered Apprentice in the Nauvoo lodge in April 1842 and in 1845 was reported driven from office and home. He later served as mayor of Nauvoo in 1849 and 1850.

John Carlin, who signed the 1850 endorsement, had subscribed the September 1846 surrender articles at Nauvoo as special constable and civil head of the Hancock County posse. Michael Barnes is identified, strongly but not conclusively, as Michael Barnes Jr., the Carthage deputy sheriff and constable. A published 1844 affidavit under that name supports Joseph H. Jackson's hostile account of Joseph Smith, and two sworn declarations of September 1845, copied into John Taylor's journal, accuse Michael Barnes of arson. These remain allegations, not verdicts.

The purchaser and the defendant

John P. Haggard was a Carthage merchant and county assessor. In April 1845 he advertised assessment appointments in Commerce and Nauvoo. On 23 May 1845 he was summoned during jury selection in the murder trial of Levi Williams and others, but was not one of the final twelve. Family history dates his death to 26 June 1851, after the deed to Parker. Andrew B. Welch's identity beyond this paper remains a lead. A possible match is Andrew Byron Welch of Carthage, but the identity chain is unproved.

What remains unresolved

The complaint, judgment, original levy, April 1843 writ, Haggard's assignment to Parker, and the 1850 deed itself have not been recovered. The cause of the joint claim by Haggard and Barnes is unknown. Nothing on the paper explains the seven-year interval between sale and deed, and the report does not attribute it to the Mormon conflict. The lot's exact position in Carthage, its buildings, and Welch's use of it are not established. The report finds no evidence that the execution was religiously motivated. The connection to Nauvoo runs through the men named on the sheet.

Related items

More documents