Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Leaf A, first side: receipts of Samuel Gilpin, Chauncey Robison ($70.00) and G. W. Stigall for B. Avise, 13-14 June 1845.

Manuscripts · Hancock County, Illinois (office of the clerk of the County Commissioners' Court) · 8 March to 16 June 1845

Group of five Hancock County tax redemption documents: two manuscript leaves and three printed certificates, 1845

George W. Thatcher, clerk of the Hancock County Commissioners' Court (issuing officer); receipts signed by Chauncey Robison, Jacob B. Backenstos, George W. Stigall and others

A group of five related documents from the office of George W. Thatcher, clerk of the Hancock County Commissioners' Court, March to June 1845: two manuscript leaves of tax redemption receipts and three printed redemption certificates. The signers and named parties include Chauncey Robison, George W. Stigall, Jacob B. Backenstos, Artois Hamilton, Edward Kilbourne, Samuel Marshall, Harmon T. Wilson, Wilson Law and Robert D. Foster. The papers show county officers, Nauvoo allies, dissenters and critics using the same tax redemption system within a year of the Smith murders.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0004
Author / maker
George W. Thatcher, clerk of the Hancock County Commissioners' Court (issuing officer); receipts signed by Chauncey Robison, Jacob B. Backenstos, George W. Stigall and others
Place
Hancock County, Illinois (office of the clerk of the County Commissioners' Court)
Date
8 March to 16 June 1845
Format / binding
Group of five documents. (1-2) Two manuscript leaves, each written on both sides in ink, with fourteen signed receipt entries in all and pencil arithmetic and sheet totals. (3-4) Two printed redemption certificates completed in manuscript, both for Lot 1, Block 14, Hibbard's Addition, each signed by Geo. W. Thatcher, clerk. (5) One printed redemption certificate for Lot 3, Block 14, Hibbard's Addition, completed in manuscript and signed by Thatcher, with docketing and arithmetic on the reverse. The printed forms have ornamental borders and the imprint 'Signal Print, Warsaw, Ills.'
Signed
Yes
Number of pieces
5 (two manuscript leaves, three printed certificates)
Issuing officer
George W. Thatcher, clerk, Hancock County Commissioners' Court
Signers of receipts
Samuel Gilpin; C. Robison; G. W. Stigall; Edward Kilbourne; Samuel Marshall; J. B. Backenstos; J. L. Kimball; B. Avise; "Frew & Gallop" (provisional reading); A. Hamilton; James W. Brattle; H. T. Wilson
Named on certificates
William Critchlow; Thomas Morrison; Ebenezer Rand; Robert D. Foster
Parcels on certificates
Lots 1 and 3, Block 14, Hibbard's Addition to Nauvoo

Condition

From the photographs: all pieces toned, with horizontal folds. The manuscript leaves have edge chips and short tears, small losses along the left edge of the March-April leaf, an ink smear on the June leaf, and show-through from the other side. The Lot 3 certificate has a chipped right edge. Housed in plastic sleeves in a binder.

The story behind this item

A group of five documents

The lot consists of five physical documents, all from the office of George W. Thatcher, clerk of the Hancock County Commissioners' Court, dated between 8 March and 16 June 1845. Two are manuscript leaves written on both sides. They carry fourteen receipt entries in which named men acknowledge money "Received of Geo. W. Thatcher Clk." Three are printed clerk's certificates, all dated 19 April 1845 and signed by Thatcher, certifying that a named person "has paid into my hands" the redemption money on a Nauvoo lot.

What a redemption receipt records

Land sold for unpaid taxes could be redeemed within a statutory period. The redeemer paid the clerk, and the clerk paid the holder of the tax-sale certificate. The manuscript entries record the second step. The report stresses that the signer was the person receiving the money and was not necessarily the owner of the land. He could be a purchaser, an assignee, an agent or a deputy. Thatcher's role was ministerial. The printed certificates record the first step and name the person who paid.

The manuscript leaves

One leaf covers 13 to 16 June 1845. Samuel Gilpin signs for $2.42. Chauncey Robison, county recorder, signs for exactly $70.00 on a long list of rural tracts and town lots. George W. Stigall signs for $2.32 as deputy of B. Avise. On the other side are receipts signed by Edward Kilbourne, Samuel Marshall and Jacob B. Backenstos, the last for $38.15.

The other leaf covers 8 March to 3 April 1845. J. L. Kimball signs for $5.12, B. Avise for $2.12, a firm provisionally read as "Frew & Gallop" for $1.70 on Nauvoo lot 3, block 60, and Artois Hamilton for $3.76 on a rural tract and Nauvoo lot 4, block 15. A final entry of $24.65 is received for W. C. Cooke and J. S. Wells. On the other side James W. Brattle signs for $10.66, Backenstos signs for $43.52 "for himself & assignee of Wilson Law & R. D. Foster", and Harmon T. Wilson signs for $5.00.

The printed certificates

Two certificates name William Coe Critchlow, a Latter-day Saint who came to Nauvoo in 1844, as redeemer of Lot 1, Block 14, Hibbard's Addition to Nauvoo. One recites a sheriff's sale to Thomas Morrison in June 1843 for the 1842 taxes, with the notation "resold in 1844". The other recites a sale to Ebenezer Rand in June 1844 for the 1843 taxes and shows $2.33. The third certificate concerns Lot 3 in the same block, sold to Robert D. Foster in June 1843 for the 1842 taxes, also noted "resold in 1844". The report reads the payer on this certificate as "R. D. Foster", which would make Foster both tax-sale purchaser and redeemer. The operative amount is 62 1/2 cents.

The people named

The receipts fall nine to twelve months after the murders of Joseph and Hyrum Smith. Stigall was the Carthage jailer during the Smiths' final confinement and became sheriff in June 1845. Hamilton kept the Carthage hotel to which the bodies were taken. A Samuel Gilpin is named on the October 1844 coroner's jury verdict, and the report calls the correlation strong. Wilson took part in the 1843 arrest of Joseph Smith. Morrison issued the 11 June 1844 riot warrant after the destruction of the Nauvoo Expositor press. Foster and Wilson Law were former Church leaders excommunicated in April 1844. Backenstos was a nonmember ally of Nauvoo and later sheriff. Kilbourne was a Montrose merchant and public critic of Latter-day Saint land claims. Marshall was killed on 24 June 1845 in an altercation with Sheriff Minor R. Deming.

What is proved and what is open

The group documents a property market that crossed factional lines, and it shows assignment and agency in the signers' own words. The report finds no political motive established by any entry. Several points remain unresolved: the full identity of Samuel Gilpin; the reading "Frew & Gallop" and whether Gallop is Benjamin A. Gallop; the identities of B. Avise, W. C. Cooke and J. S. Wells; the transfer between John Outhouse and William Oaks for Nauvoo lot 4, block 15; who actually redeemed most parcels; and the purpose of the added 25-cent figures on the certificates. The report locates the answers in the county certificate, deed, plat and assessment records, which were not available online.

Related items

More manuscripts