Home › Collection › Manuscripts
Recto: lease of Lot 4, Block 9, Hibbard's Second Addition, dated 1 May 1849
Lease with option to purchase, Davison Hibard to C. E. Yates, Nauvoo lot, 1849
Unidentified writer; agreement between Davison Hibard, lessor, and C. E. Yates, lessee
A handwritten indenture of lease dated 1 May 1849 in which Davison Hibard leases Lot 4, Block 9, Hibbard's Second Addition to Nauvoo to C. E. Yates at three dollars a month. A proviso lets Yates keep the lot and receive a deed if he pays $500 by 1 November 1849. Hibbard was an early Latter-day Saint convert and temple donor. Yates is probably Christopher E. Yates, captain of Governor Ford's posse in June 1844. The sheet bears no visible signatures.
- Inventory no.
- M-0026
- Author / maker
- Unidentified writer; agreement between Davison Hibard, lessor, and C. E. Yates, lessee
- Place
- Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois (property location; place of writing not stated)
- Date
- 1 May 1849
- Format / binding
- Single manuscript leaf written in ink on both sides; text continues from recto to reverse. Side docket on reverse. No visible signatures, seal, witness attestation, acknowledgment, or recording certificate.
- Parties
- Davison Hibard (lessor); C. E. Yates (lessee)
- Parcel
- Lot 4, Block 9, Hibbard's Second Addition to Nauvoo
- Rent
- $3 per month
- Purchase condition
- $500 on or before 1 November 1849, for a deed
- Signatures
- None visible
Condition
Folded into horizontal panels, with fold lines visible on both sides. Even toning. Small dark stain on the recto in the lower middle. Ink blots and spots on the reverse. Light wear and small chips along the edges.
The story behind this item
The document
This is a handwritten indenture of lease dated 1 May 1849. Davison Hibard, as lessor, leases to C. E. Yates "all that Messuage or parcel of Ground" described as Lot 4 in Block 9, Hibbard's Second Addition to Nauvoo. The term is "seven Months from date hereof," at a rent of three dollars per month. Yates covenants to pay the rent and to return the premises at the end of the term in as good condition as they were, allowing for reasonable use and wear, fire, and other casualty.
A proviso then changes the expected ending. If Yates pays Hibbard five hundred dollars on or before 1 November 1849, he may keep possession, and Hibbard agrees to make him "a good and sufficient deed" for the lot. The text runs from the recto onto the reverse and closes with "Given under our hands this first day of may A.D. 1849." A side docket on the reverse reads "Hibard To Yates Lease on Lot 4 Blk 9."
Reading the terms
The report describes the bargain as a lease with a conditional promise of sale. The text never says that the monthly rent was credited against the $500, and it does not require Yates to buy. The recto gives a term of seven months, while the reverse calls 1 November the expiration, six calendar months after 1 May. The report leaves this conflict unresolved. The reverse also contains a canceled passage that cannot be read confidently from the photograph, and the word "second" is inserted above the line. The term "Messuage" can suggest a dwelling, but the document describes no building.
Davidson Hibbard
Hibbard was born in Vermont in 1788 and had reached Hancock County by 1829. He served as a militia captain, justice of the peace, and county coroner. He was baptized at Commerce on 11 August 1839, belonged to the Nauvoo Masonic Lodge, and was appointed assistant inspector general of the Nauvoo Legion in March 1842. In January 1843 a deed from Hibbard for Lot 1, Block 9, in Hibbard's Addition entered the Book of the Law of the Lord at $400 "on consecration." That temple gift is a different lot from the one in this lease. Joseph Smith III later recalled Hibbard as a neighbor. Hibbard stayed in Nauvoo after the principal exodus and died there on 11 September 1854.
Christopher E. Yates
The report identifies C. E. Yates as probably Christopher E. Yates of Augusta, an early Hancock County settler. In June 1844 Governor Thomas Ford sent him to Nauvoo as captain of a posse carrying the governor's demand that Joseph Smith submit to proceedings at Carthage. He delivered Ford's letter of 22 June with John Taylor and John M. Bernhisel. Joseph and Hyrum Smith's letter of 23 June refers to an explanation from the captain of the posse. The report notes that this role does not by itself establish any part in the killings at Carthage Jail on 27 June. On 8 April 1851 a commissioner's deed conveyed four Nauvoo lots to Christopher E. Yates for $31.05 in the litigation over Joseph Smith's estate. None of those lots is the lease parcel.
The lot on the map
A marked map supplied with the report shows an orange highlight on Lot 4, Block 9, under the label for Hibbard's Second Addition. A handwritten note places the lot at the corner of Woodruff and Water Streets. The map extract carries no title, publisher, or date. The report cites the recorded plat of Hibard's Second Addition, dated 2 May 1842, in Hancock County Plat Book 1, page 52, as a lead for independent confirmation.
What remains open
No signature, seal, witness, acknowledgment, receipt, or recording certificate is visible on either side. The report states that the sheet may be a draft, an unsigned retained version, or a copy of terms used elsewhere. The identification of C. E. Yates with Christopher E. Yates rests on the initials, setting, period, and his later property activity, not on a verified autograph. Whether Yates paid the $500 and received a deed has not been established. County deed indexes, tax assessments, and the recorded plat have not been exhaustively examined.
Related items
More manuscripts


