Home › Collection › Documents
The receipt signed by James Porter for one copy of the Revised Statutes of 1845
James Porter receipt to W. W. Steele, clerk, for the Revised Statutes of 1845, Hancock County, 1857
James Porter, signer; receipt addressed to W. W. Steele, clerk
Manuscript receipt in which James Porter acknowledges receiving from W. W. Steele, clerk, one copy of the Revised Statutes of Illinois of 1845, dated 10 September 1857 (the final digit is uncertain, and 1851 is possible). A James Porter held township and county offices in Hancock County in the 1850s. The accompanying research explores, without proving, whether the signer was the James Porter whom the Bigelow family, future in-laws of Brigham Young, accused of poisoning Nahum Bigelow near Nauvoo in 1845.
- Inventory no.
- D-0014
- Author / maker
- James Porter, signer; receipt addressed to W. W. Steele, clerk
- Place
- Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 10 September 1857 (final digit uncertain; 1851 possible)
- Format / binding
- Single slip of ruled paper, written in ink on one side in one hand, signed by James Porter. A blind-embossed stamp is visible at the upper left corner.
- Signed
- Yes
- Signer
- James Porter
- Clerk
- W. W. Steele
- Book received
- Revised Statutes of Illinois, 1845 (1 copy)
- Date reading
- 10 September 1857 provisional; 1851 possible
Condition
Photograph shows light toning, scattered foxing and spotting, a small ink blot below the second line, and a small tear at the lower right corner.
The story behind this item
The receipt
This small slip reads: "Received of W. W. Steele clerk 1 Copy Revised Statutes of 1845 Sept 10 1857." It is signed "James Porter." The book named is the Revised Statutes of the State of Illinois, prepared by Mason Brayman and printed at Springfield by William Walters for Walters & Weber in 1845. Copies of the statutes were distributed through public channels, and the receipt records one such delivery. It does not itself establish that Porter held an office.
The final digit of the year is uncertain. Its appearance suggests 1857, which the transcription keeps as a provisional reading. W. W. Steele is documented as county clerk in 1849 and 1850, while Claiborne Winston won that office in 1853 and appears as clerk in 1854. The clerk's tenure therefore makes 1851 a possible alternative reading.
James Porter in Hancock County records
A James Porter appears in Hancock County records as a defeated candidate for county commissioner in 1842, Durham supervisor in 1850, supervisor in 1854, Durham assessor in 1855, and recipient of a payment for election service in 1856. These entries give a plausible civic setting for a man receiving a copy of the state's laws from the clerk. The report is careful to say that the receipt signer, the officeholder, and the man in the Bigelow family accounts have not been conclusively shown to be the same person. No securely identified Hancock County comparison signature has yet been found.
The Bigelow family
Nahum Bigelow (1785-1851) and Mary Gibbs Bigelow (1809-1888) joined the Latter-day Saints and, by their granddaughter's account, bought a Hancock County farm in 1843. In 1845 the Nauvoo Neighbor advertised Nahum's farm on Camp Creek near the La Harpe road. During the violence of autumn 1845 the family was threatened at home. On 23 October 1845 armed men who had come to protect the household were mistaken for attackers and a lieutenant was shot, an incident reported in the Quincy Whig and the Warsaw Signal. On 20 March 1847, at Winter Quarters, the Bigelows' daughters Mary Jane and Lucy both married Brigham Young.
The poisoning allegation
Mary Bigelow remembered a James Porter living on her husband's farm and bringing a warning of approaching violence. Later, according to Susa Young Gates, Nahum's granddaughter, writing in the Juvenile Instructor in 1891, Nahum accepted an invitation to breakfast at Porter's house, found the coffee bitter, and fell violently ill. An editorial summary in Maurine Carr Ward's publication of Mary's recollections says Porter later admitted he had been bribed to poison Nahum. The report treats the poisoning as a family allegation. It rests on retrospective accounts, and no independent confession, payer, or medical finding has been recovered. Contemporary newspapers corroborate the October 1845 shooting, not the poisoning. Gates's printed text names the man "Sim Porter," while Mary's account uses James.
What the document shows and what remains open
The receipt securely documents a James Porter receiving a copy of the 1845 Illinois statutes from the Hancock County clerk W. W. Steele. Its link to the Bigelow story is a proposed identification that remains unproved. The report suggests that November 1856 election certifications and the Durham assessor's certification of 1855, if they survive, are the best places to look for a comparison signature. The Bigelows reached Utah in 1850 and went to Farmington, and Nahum died on 28 January 1851.
Related items
More documents


