Home › Collection › Manuscripts
Front: caption, fee column, docket entries from 13 March 1841, and Samuel Marshall's certificate of 18 January 1842.
Certified justice-court transcript, Samuel Jonas v. Samuel H. Smith and William Smith, Carthage, 1842
Samuel Marshall, justice of the peace; filing endorsement by J. C. Davis, circuit clerk
A certified transcript of a Carthage justice's docket in a debt suit against two brothers of Joseph Smith. Samuel Jonas sued Samuel H. Smith and William Smith on a promissory note in March 1841. Samuel was served and William was not found. Judgment for $62.68 and $1.61 costs was entered against Samuel alone, and an execution came back "no property found". Justice Samuel Marshall certified the copy on 18 January 1842, and circuit clerk J. C. Davis filed it the same morning.
- Inventory no.
- M-0011
- Author / maker
- Samuel Marshall, justice of the peace; filing endorsement by J. C. Davis, circuit clerk
- Place
- Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 18 January 1842
- Format / binding
- Single sheet of ruled paper, manuscript, written on the front with case caption, fee column, docket entries and certificate. Signed "Saml. Marshall J.P." with a hand-drawn seal enclosing the word "Seal". Reverse docketed with the case title, "Copy of Judgment", and a filing note signed "J C Davis Clerk".
- Signed
- Yes
- Parties
- Samuel Jonas, plaintiff; Samuel H. Smith and William Smith, defendants
- Amount
- $62.68 debt and interest, plus $1.61 costs
- Court
- Justice court of Samuel Marshall, Carthage; copy filed with the Hancock County circuit clerk
- Signatories
- Samuel Marshall, justice of the peace; J. C. Davis, circuit clerk
- Officers named
- H. T. Wilson and Lewis Robison, constables
Condition
Folded into panels, with toning and soiling along the folds and on the docketed panel of the reverse. A small loss at one edge at a fold. Photographed inside a clear sleeve.
The story behind this item
The document
This is a certified transcript of the justice-court docket of Samuel Marshall, justice of the peace at Carthage, in the case of Samuel Jonas v. Samuel H. Smith and William Smith. It is a single sheet written by hand on the front, with a case caption and fee column at the left, the docket entries at the right, and Marshall's certificate across the foot. Marshall signed it at Carthage on 18 January 1842 and drew a seal beside his name. The reverse carries the case title, the words "Copy of Judgment", and the filing note of circuit clerk J. C. Davis, who recorded that he filed it in his office on 18 January 1842 at ten o'clock in the morning.
What the docket records
The demand was for $62.68 on a promissory note. On 13 March 1841 Marshall issued a summons to constable H. T. Wilson, returnable on 27 March at noon. The summons was returned on 25 March, served by constable Lewis Robison on 22 March on Samuel H. Smith. The entry for his brother reads "William Smith not found".
On 27 March 1841, no appearance or defense having been made, Marshall entered judgment that the plaintiff recover of defendant Samuel H. Smith $62.68 "debt & interest" and costs of $1.61. The caption names both brothers. The judgment names Samuel alone. On 31 July 1841 an execution issued to H. T. Wilson. On 6 October it was returned "no property found".
The Smith brothers
Samuel Harrison Smith and William Smith were younger brothers of Joseph Smith Jr. and Hyrum Smith. Samuel was one of the Eight Witnesses to the Book of Mormon and an early missionary. His first wife, Mary Bailey Smith, died in January 1841, two months before the suit began. He moved to Plymouth in January 1842, about the time this copy was filed, and died at Nauvoo on 30 July 1844.
William was ordained one of the original Twelve Apostles in 1835. By about 1839 he had settled at Plymouth in Hancock County, where he kept a tavern. In a letter to Joseph Smith dated 5 August 1841 he discussed property that might be sold "to Pay depts". That letter does not name Samuel Jonas or this obligation. The summons was issued on 13 March 1841, the day Samuel turned thirty-three and William turned thirty.
The creditor and the officers
The report identifies the plaintiff as very likely Samuel Jonas of Quincy, a member of a family with commercial and civic ties in the region and a brother of Abraham Jonas, who granted the dispensation for Nauvoo Lodge on 15 October 1841. The transcript gives no address or occupation for the plaintiff, and the report treats the identification as probable, without a direct documentary link.
Samuel Marshall held several Carthage offices and was killed on 24 June 1845 in an altercation with Hancock County sheriff Miner R. Deming. Jacob Cunningham Davis, circuit clerk from 1841 to 1843, was twenty-one when he filed this paper. He was later indicted and tried in connection with the murders of Joseph and Hyrum Smith and was acquitted with the other trial defendants. Lewis Robison later appears as Nauvoo's assessor and collector. The given names of H. T. Wilson have not been established.
What it proves and what remains open
The paper documents a note-based demand, service on one brother, a default judgment against Samuel H. Smith, a failed execution, and the certification and filing of a copy with the circuit clerk. The report reads the filing as fitting an effort to pursue further enforcement through the circuit court. It does not establish that a second trial, a levy, or a sale followed.
The promissory note has not been recovered. Its date, original principal, interest terms, and purpose are unknown, as are the brothers' respective roles in signing it. The report considers ordinary commercial credit a reasonable explanation, possibly connected with William's Plymouth business, and states that this is one workable reconstruction that the judgment does not establish. No record shows whether Jonas was ever paid. The return of "no property found" does not prove that Samuel owned nothing, and the "not found" return does not show that William was avoiding service.
Related items
More manuscripts


