Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Documents

Recto: the completed appeal bond, signed by Hiram Kimball and Amos Davis, approved by Warren Miller, 18 June 1849

Documents · Hancock County, Illinois · 17 June 1849

Appeal bond of Hiram Kimball and Amos Davis in Kelly v. Kimball, Hancock County, 1849

Hiram Kimball and Amos Davis, obligors; approved by Warren Miller, justice of the peace

A printed appeal bond completed by hand on 17 June 1849, in which Hiram Kimball and Amos Davis bound themselves for $168 so that Kimball could appeal an $82.40 debt judgment won by John Kelly, for the use of Robert Kelly, before justice Warren Miller. Kimball was a Commerce merchant, Nauvoo officer and Expositor negotiator; Davis was a merchant who repeatedly litigated against Joseph Smith. Both were reported among Nauvoo's defenders in 1846. The bond records their cooperation three years later.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
D-0017
Author / maker
Hiram Kimball and Amos Davis, obligors; approved by Warren Miller, justice of the peace
Place
Hancock County, Illinois
Date
17 June 1849
Format / binding
Single sheet, printed appeal bond form completed in manuscript. Signed by Hiram Kimball and Amos Davis beside printed seal devices; approval signed by Warren Miller, J.P. Reverse docketed "Appeal Bond," with case title and filing endorsement signed by the clerk, read as D. E. Head. No witness name entered.
Signed
Yes
Parties
John Kelly for the use of Robert Kelly v. Hiram Kimball
Obligors
Hiram Kimball and Amos Davis
Penal sum
$168
Judgment appealed
$82.40 debt and $1.81 costs, before Warren Miller, J.P., 9 June 1849
Court
Hancock County Circuit Court (appeal)

Condition

Photographs show the sheet folded in panels, with visible fold lines, light toning, scattered spotting, a small dark spot near the center of the recto, and offset of ink through the paper visible on the verso. Handwritten corrections in the costs clause.

The story behind this item

The document

This is a printed appeal bond form completed in manuscript. On 17 June 1849 Hiram Kimball and Amos Davis bound themselves to John Kelly, for the use of Robert Kelly, in the penal sum of $168. The condition recites that on 9 June 1849 Kelly recovered a judgment against Kimball before Warren Miller, a Hancock County justice of the peace, for $82.40 debt and $1.81 costs. Kimball had appealed to the Hancock County Circuit Court. The bond would be void if he prosecuted the appeal with effect and paid whatever judgment the court rendered. Miller approved it at his office on 18 June 1849. The reverse is docketed as an appeal bond and records filing on 6 August 1849 by D. E. Head, clerk.

Reading the obligation

Debt and costs total $84.21. Twice that is $168.42, but the bond states $168. The report preserves the discrepancy rather than repairing it. The costs clause carries handwritten corrections, and the superseded words have not been confidently recovered. Davis signed as a co-obligor standing behind Kimball's undertaking. He was not merely a witness. The paper is not a receipt for $168 paid, and it does not show that Davis was ever called upon to pay. The phrase "for the use of Robert Kelly" separates the named plaintiff from the beneficiary. It does not show how John and Robert were related or what transaction lay behind the debt.

Hiram Kimball

Hiram S. Kimball (1806 to 1863) moved to Commerce in 1833 and kept stores there before the Latter-day Saints arrived. He married Sarah Melissa Granger in 1840, served as a Nauvoo alderman and as assistant adjutant general in the Nauvoo Legion, and was baptized on 20 July 1843. Lodge minutes of 7 April 1842 record his petition to the Nauvoo Masonic lodge. John Taylor's later account names him among the friends who visited Joseph and Hyrum Smith in Carthage Jail. After the murders he negotiated over the destroyed Nauvoo Expositor press. According to a BYU Studies reconstruction, his chancery action in that litigation won a permanent injunction on 2 May 1849, weeks before this bond. No located evidence ties the Kelly debt to the Expositor matter. Kimball later settled in Utah and died in the Ada Hancock explosion at San Pedro on 27 April 1863.

Amos Davis

Amos Davis (about 1813 to 1872) arrived in Commerce in the fall of 1836. He bought two lots from Kimball in February 1837, and Kimball held a substantial account in Davis's 1839 ledger. Davis married Elvira Hibbard, joined the church in April 1840, and became a Nauvoo Legion captain. From 1842 he faced a series of Nauvoo prosecutions brought before or by Joseph Smith, with mixed results on appeal. In February 1844 he sued Smith and two city officers for trespass. On 9 December 1842 Davis himself had needed sureties: Lewis Robison and Robert D. Foster joined him in a $113 appeal bond. William Clayton recorded a report that both Davis and Kimball fought among Nauvoo's defenders in September 1846.

The other names

Warren Miller is securely identified by the bond as the justice who entered the judgment and approved the bond. A Warren Miller served as county surveyor from 1853 to 1859, but the two have not been linked. The clerk is identified as David E. Head, Hancock County circuit clerk from 1844 to 1856, who also wrote the 1844 entry dismissing Davis's suit against Smith. A Manx Kelly family that reached Nauvoo in April 1844 offers candidates for John and Robert Kelly. That identification remains provisional.

What remains open

The underlying transaction, the identities of the Kellys and the outcome of the appeal are unproved. Hancock County circuit case files for the period are held at the Western Illinois University IRAD depository, but the specific appeal file has not been examined. The bond records demonstrable cooperation between two long-acquainted Commerce merchants after the 1846 exodus. It does not reveal their motive.

Related items

More documents