Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Letters

Address panel with postmark and docket.

Letters · Newark, New Jersey (postmark); addressed to Alton, Illinois · October 1839; docketed 13 November 1839

William Garthwaite letter to George T. M. Davis, attorney at Alton, Illinois, October 1839

William Garthwaite, client of the addressee

A holographic business letter from William Garthwaite to George T. M. Davis, attorney at law at Alton, Illinois, written in October 1839 and sent as a stampless folded sheet with an integral address panel. Garthwaite asks about claims Davis was collecting for him and requests a full statement. Five years later Davis, by then a Whig editor, watched Joseph and Hyrum Smith at Carthage, predicted their deaths in writing, and published one of the earliest accounts of the murders.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
L-0001
Author / maker
William Garthwaite, client of the addressee
Place
Newark, New Jersey (postmark); addressed to Alton, Illinois
Date
October 1839; docketed 13 November 1839
Format / binding
Holographic letter on a single sheet of ruled paper, written on one side and signed "Wm Garthwaite." Integral address panel on the reverse with red circular postmark, manuscript "25", recipient's docket in two lines, and remains of a red wax seal. Stampless.
Signed
Yes
Addressee
George T. M. Davis, attorney at law, Alton, Illinois
Postmark
Red circular datestamp, read as Newark, N.J., October; manuscript "25"
Docket
"Wm Garthwaite, Nov 13th 1839"; "Answered Nov 15th 1839"
Subject
Request for a statement on claims in collection

Condition

Photographs show the usual letter folds, light toning and soiling on the address panel, and a small tear at the seal. Ink strong and legible. Faint pencil figures on the address panel.

The story behind this item

The letter

This is a single sheet, written on one side and folded to form its own cover. The research report identifies it as a holographic letter from William Garthwaite to George T. M. Davis with an integral address panel. The dateline reads Newark, October 1839, and the red circular postmark reads Newark, N.J. That difference is not resolved in the report.

Garthwaite writes that he was disappointed at missing Davis in New York and had called often at his hotel. He is anxious to know the prospect of collecting the claims Davis has in hand for him. He had hoped part would be paid by now. He asks Davis to write at once with a statement of the whole business.

The address panel and docket

The reverse is addressed to "George T. M. Davis Esqr., Attorney at Law, Alton, Illinois." It carries the red postmark and a manuscript "25". A docket at the top reads "Wm Garthwaite, Nov 13th 1839," with a second line, "Answered Nov 15th 1839." Remains of a red wax seal show at the lower edge.

Davis at Alton in 1839

George Turnbull Moore Davis was born at Malta on 24 May 1810. He entered the New York bar in July 1832 and moved to Alton that September. There he formed a partnership with John M. Krum. The practice handled debts, land, collections, bankruptcy and commercial disputes across southern Illinois. The report places the Garthwaite letter in that world. It shows Davis working in an interstate legal and financial network several years before the Carthage crisis.

Davis also became associated with the Alton Telegraph and made it an influential Whig paper. The Papers of Abraham Lincoln dates his editorship to 1841.

Davis and the deaths of Joseph and Hyrum Smith

On 26 June 1844 Davis was in the Carthage courthouse and saw the Smith brothers appear. That evening he wrote a dispatch warning that a desperate attempt would probably be made to punish them without trial. On 27 June he went with Governor Thomas Ford to Nauvoo, then traveled toward Warsaw and reached it around midnight, where he learned of the killings.

On 30 June he urged Ford to station 2,500 to 3,000 men from distant districts near Nauvoo to prevent what he called a "war of extermination." On 9 August he warned Ford that indictments and arrests would bring bloodshed. That summer he published An Authentic Account of the Massacre of Joseph Smith, a forty-seven-page pamphlet printed at St. Louis by Chambers and Knapp. In it he acknowledged knowing some of the participants and declined to name them.

The report concludes that Davis predicted violence, held confidential knowledge, withheld names and intervened politically afterward. It finds no proof that he planned, authorized or joined the attack on Carthage Jail. His attendance at any private meeting at Carthage on 26 June is treated as possible and unproven.

What the letter shows and what is unresolved

The letter documents Davis as a collecting attorney at Alton in 1839, pressed by an eastern client for an accounting. The docket shows that the letter was answered on 15 November 1839. The reply is not present.

The report states that the letter does not presently establish a Mormon connection. Garthwaite is not otherwise identified, and the claims are not specified. The report points to the George Turnbull Moore Davis Papers at the Missouri Historical Society, collection A0363, which include a Davis and Krum letterbook and an attorney's register running from 1839 through 1845. That register may connect the letter to a specific transaction. The place and day of writing should be checked against the original.

Related items

More letters