Home › Collection › Documents
Wrapper: docket for case 73, Marsh v. Abernathy, trespass, October term 1841, with red pencil numbers and a large cross.
Group of court papers in Marsh v. Abernathy, Hancock County Circuit Court, 1841
S. Otho Williams and Jacob C. Davis, clerks of the circuit court; Harmon T. Wilson, coroner; Ralston & Warren, attorneys for the plaintiff
A group of papers from case 73 in the Hancock County Circuit Court, 1841. Benjamin F. Marsh, the county school commissioner, sued Sheriff William D. Abernathy in trespass for ten thousand dollars. Because the defendant was the sheriff, the coroner, Harmon T. Wilson, served the process, and the printed forms are altered by hand from "Sheriff" to "Coroner". The defense witnesses summoned include Marsh's daughter and son-in-law, and David Bettisworth, who served process on Joseph Smith in June 1844. The complaint and the outcome are not present.
- Inventory no.
- D-0006
- Author / maker
- S. Otho Williams and Jacob C. Davis, clerks of the circuit court; Harmon T. Wilson, coroner; Ralston & Warren, attorneys for the plaintiff
- Place
- Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 7 May to 28 October 1841
- Format / binding
- A group of court papers from one case file. A folded wrapper with manuscript docket. A printed summons completed in manuscript, with embossed court seal, and the coroner's signed return on the reverse. A fully handwritten attorneys' request for process, with the clerk's filing endorsement on the reverse. Two printed witness subpoenas completed in manuscript, each with the coroner's signed return on the reverse. Two printed witness-attendance certificates completed in manuscript, each signed by the witness and a clerk, with filing endorsements on the reverse. Summons printed by C. M. Woods, Quincy; subpoenas printed by Sharp & Gamble, Warsaw.
- Signed
- Yes
- Parties
- Benjamin F. Marsh, plaintiff; William D. Abernathy, defendant
- Court
- Hancock County Circuit Court, case 73, October Term 1841
- Action and amount
- Trespass; damages demanded, ten thousand dollars
- Signatories
- S. Otho Williams, clerk; Jacob C. Davis, clerk; Harmon T. Wilson, coroner; Ralston & Warren; John Tremain; David Bettisworth
- Witnesses named
- John Tremain, Samuel Marshall, Cyrus Felt, Martha S. Felt, William Ayres, David Bettisworth, all for the defendant
Condition
All pieces show old folds and light to moderate toning. The summons has short tears at the ends of the horizontal fold. The subpoena naming the Felts has small chips along the lower edge and brown stains visible on the reverse. The attorneys' request has a small ink spot near the upper right. The wrapper is creased, with a short tear at the upper right edge and red pencil numbers at the top. Show-through from the opposite side is visible on several pieces.
The story behind this item
The papers
These papers come from case 73 in the Hancock County Circuit Court, Benjamin F. Marsh against William D. Abernathy, an action of trespass. Marsh was the county school commissioner. Abernathy was the county sheriff. The group includes a wrapper docketed for the October term 1841, the summons with its return, the handwritten request for process from Marsh's attorneys, two witness subpoenas with their returns, and two sworn certificates of witness attendance. The summons states Marsh's damage at ten thousand dollars. That figure is the amount demanded. The complaint itself is absent, and the group contains no verdict, judgment, or settlement.
A sheriff as defendant
Because the sheriff was a party, another officer had to serve the process. The attorneys' memorandum, signed Ralston & Warren, asks the clerk to issue a summons in an action of trespass for ten thousand dollars. The word "Sheriff" is struck through and "Coroner" written after it. It is headed September Term 1841 and endorsed on the reverse "Filed May Seventh 1841" by S. Otho Williams, clerk.
The summons is a printed form headed "Summons in Assumpsit", printed by C. M. Woods of Quincy. The clerk struck out the printed words that follow "Trespass", replaced "Sheriff" with "Coroner", and wrote his own name above the cancelled printed name of Wesley Williams. It is dated 7 May 1841, carries an embossed seal, and calls Abernathy to appear on the first Monday of October 1841. On the reverse Harmon T. Wilson, coroner, records that he served the summons by reading it to Abernathy on 9 May 1841.
The witnesses
Both subpoenas were issued at the instance of the defendant, on forms printed by Sharp & Gamble of Warsaw, and call the witnesses to the courthouse in Carthage on 6 October 1841. One, dated 20 September, names John Tremain and Samuel Marshall. Wilson's return records service on both men on 23 September.
The other names Cyrus Felt, Martha S. Felt, William Ayres, and David Bettisworth. Martha Sophia Felt was Marsh's daughter. Cyrus Felt, a Montebello merchant and farmer, was his son-in-law. Wilson's return places the Felts' service at 24 September and Bettisworth's at 30 September, and states that he could not find Ayres in the county. He charged for three services and forty miles of travel, $3.37½ in all. The issue date on this subpoena reads as 20 October, with some uncertainty, which conflicts with the September service dates. That inconsistency is unresolved. The subpoena does not show what the Felts knew, whose account their evidence would have helped, or whether they testified.
Two witnesses left sworn attendance certificates. John Tremain swore on 22 October 1841, before Jacob C. Davis, that he attended court eight days at the instance of the defendant. David Bettisworth swore to the same eight days before S. Otho Williams. The day of his oath is read as 15 October, with some uncertainty. Davis filed both certificates on 28 October 1841. The certificates record attendance. They do not record testimony, and they do not establish an eight-day trial.
The people in later Hancock County history
Several signers and witnesses appear again in the Nauvoo conflicts. In June 1843 Wilson and the Missouri agent Joseph H. Reynolds arrested Joseph Smith in Illinois. On 12 June 1844, after the destruction of the Nauvoo Expositor, Bettisworth served Joseph Smith with process, and later that month he helped carry news of Joseph and Hyrum Smith's deaths to Nauvoo. Davis was indicted in connection with the Smith murders and was tried and acquitted in 1845. Calvin A. Warren handled bankruptcy petitions for Joseph and Hyrum Smith in 1842, and his partner James H. Ralston was among the lawyers at Smith's 1841 extradition hearing. These later events do not establish anyone's motive in 1841. Church membership has not been established for Marsh, Abernathy, the Felts, the other witnesses, or the officers.
What is established and what remains open
The papers establish the parties, the form of action, the sum demanded, service on the sheriff by the coroner in May 1841, two defense subpoenas, and two defense attendance claims in October. The act complained of is unknown. A dispute over property or official action is a possibility and remains unproved. The disposition of the case is unknown. The September and October term entries have not been reconciled with the May dates. The purpose of the red pencil numbers and the large cross on the wrapper is not established.
Related items
More documents


