Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Green case wrapper lettered "People vs H. Leavitt", numbered 39.

Manuscripts · Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois · 20-22 May 1843 (May term 1843)

People v. Hezekiah Leavitt: group of court papers, Hancock County Circuit Court, May 1843

James H. Ralston, state's attorney pro tem (indictment); office of Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk (writ and cost bills)

A group of papers from a liquor-licensing prosecution heard at Carthage in May 1843. The three-page indictment is in the hand of James H. Ralston, a lawyer who also acted in Joseph Smith's legal affairs. With it are the grand jury's true bill signed by Wesley Williams, an arrest writ issued from Jacob B. Backenstos's clerk's office, the deputy sheriff's return, and two cost bills. One cost bill carries a handwritten charge for entering a plea of guilty. The judgment and fine are not recorded in these papers.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0010
Author / maker
James H. Ralston, state's attorney pro tem (indictment); office of Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk (writ and cost bills)
Place
Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
20-22 May 1843 (May term 1843)
Format / binding
Group of papers from one case file. (1) Manuscript indictment, three written pages in brown ink with pencil additions, signed by J. H. Ralston, with a true bill and witness endorsement on the outer panel signed by Wesley Williams as foreman and a filing notation of J. B. Backenstos, clerk. (2) Printed capias form completed by hand, with embossed court seal, signed for the clerk by M. Avise, deputy; the sheriff's return on the reverse is signed by E. B. Rose, deputy. (3) Printed plaintiff's cost bill completed by hand. (4) Printed defendant's cost bill completed by hand; one of the two cost bills is docketed "Fee Bill" and "Paid" on its reverse. (5) Green paper case wrapper lettered in ink.
Signed
Yes
Parties
The People of the State of Illinois v. Hezekiah Leavitt
Court
Hancock County Circuit Court, criminal no. 39, May term 1843
Charge
Selling liquors without a license, five counts
Signatories
J. H. Ralston; Wesley Williams; E. B. Rose; Matthias Avise for J. B. Backenstos
Costs
Plaintiff's $8.31 1/4; defendant's $2.62 1/2; sheriff's return $1.56 1/4

Condition

Folded for filing, with fold lines throughout. Light toning. Ink stains on both cost bills and at the lower right of the third indictment page; ink damage crosses part of the written total on the defendant's cost bill. The writ has a rough left edge. Photographed in protective sleeves.

The story behind this item

The group

These papers come from the file of People v. Hezekiah Leavitt, criminal case no. 39 in the Hancock County Circuit Court, May term 1843. They are a three-page manuscript indictment with its endorsement, a printed arrest writ with the officer's return on the reverse, two printed cost bills completed by hand, and a green paper wrapper lettered "People vs H. Leavitt". The reverse of one cost bill is docketed "Fee Bill" and marked "Paid". The wrapper is a later filing aid.

The charge

The indictment is written throughout by James H. Ralston, who signs as state's attorney pro tem. It has five charging paragraphs. Each alleges that Leavitt, having no legal license to keep a grocery, sold spirituous liquors in a quantity less than one quart in January 1843. The drinks named are whiskey, brandy, rum and wine, measured in gills and half gills. Under the Illinois licensing act approved 17 February 1841, a grocery included a place selling liquor in quantities smaller than a quart, and the penalty on conviction was ten dollars for each offense. The indictment gives no address or description of Leavitt's premises.

Some purchasers' names were left blank in the ink text and one purchaser is called unknown. Lighter pencil writing supplies the name Sherman Redfield in two counts and a Dame in another. The date of the pencil additions is not established. Five counts do not necessarily prove five separate transactions.

The true bill and the witnesses

The outer panel of the indictment is endorsed "A True Bill" and signed by Wesley Williams as foreman of the grand jury. A true bill records the grand jury's approval of the accusation. It is no trial verdict. Below it are eight witness names: Sherman Redfield, a witness whose name is read as Jerom H. Dame, John Curtis, John Gardner, Wm Smith, Abram Harper, John Huckins and Miles Wilcox. A filing notation reads "Filed May 20th 1843, J B Backenstos Clk". The list ties these names to the case. It does not show that each man testified.

Arrest and costs

The writ is a printed civil form altered by hand to command the sheriff to bring Leavitt "forthwith" before the court at Carthage to answer the indictment. It is dated 22 May 1843, bears the court seal, and carries the name of J. B. Backenstos, clerk, signed for him by Matthias Avise as deputy. On the reverse, E. B. Rose signs as deputy for Sheriff William Backenstos and reports that he took Leavitt on 22 May and had him in court. The return charges 15 miles of travel and a total of $1.56 1/4.

The plaintiff's cost bill itemizes clerk's fees, the sheriff's charges and a $5 state's attorney fee, for a total of $8.31 1/4. The defendant's cost bill has a handwritten line, "Entry plea of Guilty", charged at 25 cents, with $1.37 1/2 in clerk's charges and a $1.25 docket fee, together $2.62 1/2. These are court costs. They do not state a fine.

The people named

Ralston, born in Kentucky in 1807, practiced at Quincy and served in the Illinois legislature and on the circuit bench. He assisted Joseph Smith in extradition and financial matters and later served among the prosecutors at the 1845 trial of the men accused of killing Joseph and Hyrum Smith. Jacob B. Backenstos, the clerk, became sheriff of Hancock County during the violence of 1845. William Backenstos, the sheriff named here, is a different man. Wesley Williams was later a figure in the Anti-Mormon Party. E. B. Rose swore in September 1845 that he had been threatened and ordered to leave the county. John Huckins is associated with the group called the Brick-Batters.

Several witness identifications are probable only. Sherman Redfield is probably Orrin Sherman Redfield. John Curtis may be John Curts of Shokokon, and Abram Harper is probably Abraham Harper Jr. The Wm Smith named here is not identified as Joseph Smith's brother. Dame, John Gardner and Miles Wilcox remain unresolved.

What remains open

The papers establish an indictment, an arrest return, a recorded fee for a guilty plea and a fee bill marked paid. They do not show which counts the plea covered, the fine imposed, or whether a fine was paid. The court's judgment or docket entry has not been located. Leavitt is a possible Latter-day Saint associate, but no membership record has been found, and no religious motive for the prosecution has been established. The charge followed a general licensing law.

Related items

More manuscripts