Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Front: subpoena to four witnesses in People v. James Brooks, signed C Robison J P, 4 August 1849.

Manuscripts · Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois · 4 August 1849 (return dated 6 August 1849)

Subpoena for four witnesses in People of Illinois v. James Brooks, Nauvoo, 1849

C. Robison, justice of the peace (identified in the report as Chauncey Robison); return by B. Bartlett, marshal of the City of Nauvoo

A handwritten subpoena issued at Nauvoo on 4 August 1849 by justice of the peace C. Robison, identified in the report as Chauncey Robison. It commands four men to testify on Monday 6 August in a matter between the People of the State of Illinois and James Brooks. On the reverse, city marshal B. Bartlett records reading the summons to two of them and charges 35 cents. The accusation and the outcome of the case are unknown.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0012
Author / maker
C. Robison, justice of the peace (identified in the report as Chauncey Robison); return by B. Bartlett, marshal of the City of Nauvoo
Place
Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
4 August 1849 (return dated 6 August 1849)
Format / binding
One sheet of ruled paper, written on both sides, entirely in manuscript. Front: subpoena signed "C Robison J P" beside a drawn outline containing the word "Seal." Reverse: marshal's return and fee account signed "B. Bartlett Marshal of the City of Nauvoo." An embossed seal cannot be established from the photographs.
Signed
Yes
Parties
The People of the State of Illinois v. James Brooks
Witnesses summoned
Samuel Payne, Isaac Davis, Charles Scott, John Demming (surname uncertain)
Witnesses served
Samuel Payne and Isaac Davis, 6 August 1849
Marshal's fees
Service 25 cents, mileage 10 cents, total 35 cents
Signatories
C Robison, J.P.; B. Bartlett, Marshal of the City of Nauvoo

Condition

Horizontal folds. Toning and scattered brown stains, including a discolored area beside the drawn seal and an ink blot on the lower reverse. Ink show-through on both sides. Some rubbing to the ink at the year on the front.

The story behind this item

The summons

This is a single handwritten sheet issued in the City of Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois. It is addressed to Samuel Payne, Isaac Davis, Charles Scott and a fourth man whose name the report reads provisionally as John Demming. The four are commanded to appear before the justice at his office in Nauvoo "to testify the truth" in a matter in which the People of the State of Illinois is plaintiff and James Brooks is defendant. The order warns them not to omit this "under the penalty of the law." It is dated 4 August, in a year the report reads as 1849, and signed "C Robison J P" beside a drawn outline containing the word "Seal."

One alteration is visible. The word read as "forthwith" is crossed out, and above it the writer added "on Monday 6th inst at 10 o'clock." The paper does not say why the appointment was fixed or changed.

The marshal's return

The reverse carries the officer's return: "I have Served the within by reading the Same to the within Named Saml Paine & I Davis," dated 6 August 1849 and signed "B. Bartlett Marshal of the City of Nauvoo." Below it he itemized his fees: service 25 cents, mileage 10 cents, total 35 cents.

The return names two of the four witnesses. It does not record service on Charles Scott or the fourth man. The report notes that the others may have been unavailable, served separately, or dealt with in another way. Reported service does not prove that Payne or Davis attended, took an oath, or gave evidence.

The people named

The report identifies the issuing justice as Chauncey Robison, an inference from his compatible record in the Joseph Smith Papers. Robison was born on 27 March 1805 in Oneida County, New York, and moved to Hancock County in 1829. He served as county recorder from 1839 to 1847 and as Carthage postmaster, belonged to the Nauvoo Masonic Lodge, and was secretary of Hancock Lodge in 1843. He moved to Nauvoo in 1847, was mayor in 1849-1850, and died in Topeka, Kansas, on 4 November 1891.

James Brooks is unidentified. The paper gives no age, occupation, address or family connection, and the proceeding does not establish guilt. Two Latter-day Saint men of that name were considered in earlier research; neither has a demonstrated connection to this subpoena. The witnesses are also unidentified. An earlier report proposed an English immigrant named Samuel Payne and two Latter-day Saint men named Isaac Davis, but the reported deaths of all three precede August 1849. The marshal's first name, appointment and career remain unresolved. The paper does not call him a deputy.

Dating and context

An earlier report dated the paper to 1845. The current report prefers 1849. The final digit of both manuscript dates is read as 9, and the inserted appointment specifies Monday the sixth: 6 August 1849 was a Monday, while 6 August 1845 was a Wednesday. Robison's move to Nauvoo in 1847 and his mayoral term are compatible supporting context.

The corrected year places the proceeding after the main Latter-day Saint departure from Nauvoo in 1846. Andrew Jenson's 1889 history records renewed city incorporation in spring 1849 and the arrival of the French Icarian community that spring. These events locate the case in a changing town. They do not identify the witnesses as Icarians or as members of any other group.

What is established and what is open

The sheet establishes that a Nauvoo justice summoned four men to testify in a matter against James Brooks, and that the city marshal reported reading the summons to two of them for a fee of 35 cents. The earlier description of a printed form with an embossed county seal is not supported by the photographs, which show handwriting on ruled paper and a drawn seal label.

The accusation, the testimony and the outcome are unknown. The surname of the fourth witness is not secure; Deming and Downing are alternative readings. No companion complaint, testimony, judgment or disposition has been identified. The report did not inspect unindexed court dockets or all 1849 newspapers, and it points to Robison's docket and Hancock County case papers as the likeliest places for an answer.

Related items

More manuscripts