Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Folded case wrapper docketed People vs James Porter, Appeal, October term 1845

Manuscripts · Nauvoo and Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois · 14 February to December 1845

People v. James Porter: assault and battery case papers, Nauvoo and Hancock County Circuit Court, 1845

Aaron Johnson, justice of the peace; David E. Head, circuit clerk; George P. Stiles, attorney; Russell Rogers, complainant; Samuel Gully, special constable

A file of court papers in People v. James Porter, an assault and battery prosecution begun at Nauvoo in February 1845. Russell Rogers swore the complaint before Aaron Johnson, justice of the peace. Samuel Gully, deputized as a special constable, made the arrest. Johnson fined Porter three dollars, and the appeal went to the Hancock County Circuit Court with George P. Stiles as defense counsel. The papers tie a minor case to men close to Joseph and Hyrum Smith in the year before the exodus.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0039
Author / maker
Aaron Johnson, justice of the peace; David E. Head, circuit clerk; George P. Stiles, attorney; Russell Rogers, complainant; Samuel Gully, special constable
Place
Nauvoo and Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
14 February to December 1845
Format / binding
Group of court papers, photographed in 16 images: folded case wrapper; manuscript complaint signed by Russell Rogers; manuscript subpoena signed by Aaron Johnson, J.P., with Samuel Gully's return; manuscript subpoena request signed by Geo. P. Stiles, Atty.; two printed circuit court subpoena forms completed by hand and signed by D. E. Head, clerk; printed procedendo form signed by Head; Johnson's manuscript certified docket transcript with cost account, signed. The printed forms bear the embossed seal of the Hancock County Circuit Court. Several reverses carry filing endorsements and sheriff's returns.
Signed
Yes
Parties
People of the State of Illinois v. James Porter
Charge
Assault and battery
Courts
Aaron Johnson, J.P., Nauvoo; Hancock County Circuit Court, Carthage
Judgment
Fine $3.00, costs $1.68; appealed
Appeal surety
Joel Sands

Condition

Photographs show the papers folded for filing, with fold lines throughout. Uneven or torn edges on several leaves, including the lower edge of the complaint and the edge of the Stiles request. Small brown stains, including one on the case caption of the May subpoena reverse. Light toning.

The story behind this item

The case papers

These papers record a small criminal prosecution at Nauvoo in 1845. On 14 February 1845 Russell Rogers swore before Aaron Johnson, justice of the peace, that on or about 12 February James Porter did "assault and unlawfully beat him." Johnson issued a warrant. The regular constable was absent, so Johnson deputized Samuel Gully to serve it. Gully brought Porter before the court. Porter pleaded not guilty, waived a jury and asked for trial by the justice. Johnson assessed a fine of $3.00 and costs taxed at $1.68. Porter appealed to the Hancock County Circuit Court, with Joel Sands as security on his appeal bond.

The file includes Rogers's sworn complaint, Johnson's subpoena for John Hamer and a witness named Carter, and Johnson's certified docket transcript with its cost account. It also holds George P. Stiles's signed request for a defense subpoena, printed circuit court subpoenas for May and October, a December procedendo, and the folded case wrapper.

The justice and the special constable

Aaron Johnson reached Commerce in March 1839, before the town became Nauvoo. He served as a high councilor, temple worker, missionary and justice, and his name appears in Doctrine and Covenants 124. In December 1843 he asked Joseph Smith for Legion support to serve a warrant on Levi Williams in the Daniel Avery kidnapping affair. After the Carthage murders he received William Daniels's affidavit and John Taylor's complaint against suspected participants.

Samuel Gully came to Nauvoo from Mississippi. Hyrum Smith gave him a patriarchal blessing in February 1843. Nauvoo Lodge minutes list Gully and Johnson with Joseph and Hyrum Smith at a December 1842 meeting. Gully later served in the Mormon Battalion and in 1849 captained the Gully-Spencer company. He died of cholera on the Platte on 5 July 1849 and was buried beside the trail.

Counsel and witnesses

For the May 1845 term, Stiles asked the clerk to summon John Hamer for the defense. In May 1844 Stiles had written the habeas corpus petition used to challenge Joseph Smith's arrest in the Francis Higbee suit. Brigham Young baptized him in August 1844, after the Smith brothers were killed. The witness was probably John Wood Hamer, an English convert who arrived in 1842. The report treats that identification as unproved. Carter's first name is blank, and Gully reported that Carter could not be found.

The appeal in a year of crisis

The circuit papers pass through officers tied to the Carthage story. David E. Head, the circuit clerk, signed the writs. The May service return appears to be signed by Miner R. Deming, who wrote to Joseph and Hyrum Smith in jail on 26 June 1844. The later returns are in the name of Sheriff Jacob B. Backenstos, a friend of the Saints who never joined the Church. In October a subpoena for Russell Rogers came back with the return that he could not be found in the county. On 9 December 1845 Head issued a procedendo directing Johnson to proceed with the case. Service was recorded on 27 December. Nothing in the file shows a religious or political motive for the assault.

What remains unresolved

The papers name the defendant but do not identify him. Two James Porters are possible. James Buchanan Porter went west and later worked in Utah. A James Porter married to Mary Buchanan stayed in Hancock County. The case gives no wife, age, trade or signature to separate them. The complainant is probably Russell Heber Rogers, but no record yet joins him to the affidavit. Joel Sands may be the Nauvoo miller who planned in January 1846 to go west. That link is also unconfirmed. The final outcome of the case is not known. No later acquittal, reversal, payment or reason for the circuit court's action has been found.

Related items

More manuscripts