Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Outer wrapper docketed "People vs John Mackimer," with red 19 and canceled 52

Manuscripts · Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois · 8 October 1842 to 17 May 1843

Case papers in People v. John Mackemer, challenge to a duel, Hancock County, 1842-1843

Jonathan Berry, justice of the peace; J. H. Ralston, state's attorney pro tem; with signatures of George P. Stiles, John Mackemer, John Wilson and county officers

The surviving case packet in a Hancock County prosecution for challenging a man to a duel. On 8 October 1842 George P. Stiles, a lawyer who did legal work for Joseph Smith, swore that John Mackemer had challenged him at Carthage. The six manuscripts carry the complaint, warrant, constable's return, justice's transcript, two fifty-dollar recognizances and the May 1843 indictment, signed by officers with documented ties to Nauvoo. The packet records no outcome.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0034
Author / maker
Jonathan Berry, justice of the peace; J. H. Ralston, state's attorney pro tem; with signatures of George P. Stiles, John Mackemer, John Wilson and county officers
Place
Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
8 October 1842 to 17 May 1843
Format / binding
Packet of six manuscript documents and an outer wrapper: complaint affidavit, arrest warrant with constable's return, justice's transcript, defendant's recognizance, witness recognizance, and grand-jury indictment. Each written on the recto with docket endorsements on the verso, thirteen photographed sides in all. Signatures of Stiles, Mackemer, Wilson, Berry, Rose, Davis, Ralston, Williams and Avise; written seals on the recognizances and warrant.
Signed
Yes
Parties
People of the State of Illinois v. John Mackemer
Charge
Challenging George P. Stiles to fight a duel with a deadly weapon
Court
Justice Jonathan Berry; Hancock County Circuit Court, May term 1843
Amounts
Two recognizances of $50 each
Contents
Six documents and outer wrapper, 13 photographed sides

Condition

Sheets folded for filing, with fold lines visible. Cancellations and ink smudges in the text of the affidavit and recognizances. Small ink spots and light staining along folds on the warrant and indictment. Bleed-through visible on several versos. Wrapper creased with edge wear.

The story behind this item

The case file

This is the surviving case packet in People v. John Mackemer, a Hancock County prosecution for challenging a man to a duel. It holds six manuscript documents and an outer wrapper docketed "People vs John Mackimer." On 8 October 1842 George P. Stiles swore before Justice of the Peace Jonathan Berry that John Mackemer had challenged him "to fight a Duel With a Deadly Weapon" about the middle of September 1842. Berry's transcript places the challenge in the town of Carthage.

From complaint to indictment

Berry issued a warrant the same day. Constable E. B. Rose returned it, reporting that he had taken Mackemer and that the defendant was present on 8 October 1842. At the hearing Berry swore Stiles as a witness and held Mackemer to bail in $50 for his appearance at the next circuit court term. Mackemer and his surety, John Wilson, signed a fifty-dollar recognizance. Stiles signed a separate fifty-dollar recognizance to appear and give evidence for the state. Clerk J. C. Davis filed Berry's transcript on 11 October 1842. At the May term of 1843 the grand jury returned the indictment, No. 34, signed by J. H. Ralston as state's attorney pro tem and endorsed "A True Bill" by foreman Wesley Williams. It was filed on 17 May 1843 for clerk J. B. Backenstos by deputy M. Avise. A true bill records the grand jury's approval of an accusation for prosecution. It is not a verdict.

The people on the papers

Stiles was a lawyer who did legal work for Joseph Smith. On 30 November 1842 he wrote a complaint that Joseph signed, and Joseph performed his marriage to Sophia J. Schofield on 4 February 1843. Stiles's recorded baptism came on 26 August 1844, after this case began. James Harvey Ralston, a Quincy lawyer, former judge and Illinois senator, had been acknowledged by the First Presidency in January 1841 among the Saints' benefactors. William Backenstos, listed as a witness, was the sheriff elected in 1842; Joseph performed his marriage to Clara Wasson, Emma Smith's niece, in October 1843. His brother Jacob, the clerk named on the filing, supported Joseph's extradition defense in January 1843 and never joined the Church. Jacob Cunningham Davis, who filed the transcript, was later indicted and acquitted in the prosecution arising from the murders of Joseph and Hyrum Smith. Wesley Williams had recorded the Nauvoo plat in 1839 and by 1842 stood on an anti-Mormon ticket.

The law and the dates

The 1833 Illinois criminal code made a challenge to a potentially deadly duel an offense in itself, punishable by a fine of up to $100 and disqualification from state office. The papers name no particular weapon. The October 1842 papers place the challenge about the middle of September. The indictment alleges 15 October 1842, a week after Berry's hearing. The file does not explain the discrepancy, and the report preserves both dates without reconciling them.

What remains unresolved

The packet contains no plea, trial, verdict, dismissal or sentence. Nobody's account of the quarrel survives. The cause of the challenge, whether the men ever fought, and how the prosecution ended are unknown. Stiles had married a Julian Mackemer in Hancock County on 7 November 1841, but no record yet joins her to the defendant. An 1889 Muscatine County, Iowa, family history describes a John Mackemer living in Carthage from October 1840 to April 1846; his identification with the defendant remains provisional. The identities of the surety John Wilson and of the constable, probably Ethel B. Rose, are also not settled. The red 19 and canceled 52 on the wrapper are visible marks whose function has not been established.

Related items

More manuscripts