Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Indictment, May term 1844: grand jurors charge six men with falsely imprisoning Daniel Avery; signed E. A. Thompson, state's attorney

Manuscripts · Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois · 1844-1845

False-imprisonment case file, People v. Joseph McCoy et al., Daniel Avery kidnapping, Hancock County, 1844-1845

Hancock County Circuit Court; indictment signed by E. A. Thompson, state's attorney; writs issued by clerks J. B. Backenstos and D. E. Head

The Hancock County Circuit Court file in the prosecution of six men for the false imprisonment of Daniel Avery, a Latter-day Saint seized at Doty's mill on 2 December 1843 and carried across the Mississippi into Missouri. It holds the manuscript grand jury indictment, filed 24 May 1844, and later court papers: subpoenas, arrest writs and defense requests running to October 1845. Together they record Illinois's effort to prosecute a kidnapping that alarmed Joseph Smith and Nauvoo, and they end without a verdict.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0022
Author / maker
Hancock County Circuit Court; indictment signed by E. A. Thompson, state's attorney; writs issued by clerks J. B. Backenstos and D. E. Head
Place
Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
1844-1845
Format / binding
Group of court papers from one case file, in a green paper wrapper. Manuscript indictment, one sheet folded, written on one side, with manuscript grand jury endorsement and filing docket on the reverse. Printed subpoena and capias forms completed in manuscript, each with an embossed court seal on the face and manuscript sheriff's returns, fees and filing endorsements on the reverse. Manuscript defense requests for subpoenas, one a small slip. Signatures of E. A. Thompson, J. B. Backenstos, D. E. Head, M. R. Deming and others. With a partial leaf of the Warsaw Message, 3 January 1844, modern printouts and modern research notes.
Signed
Yes
Case
The People v. Joseph McCoy et al., no. 56, false imprisonment
Court
Hancock County Circuit Court, Carthage, Illinois
Contents
Indictment, wrapper, subpoenas, writs of capias, defense requests; Warsaw Message leaf
Signatories
E. A. Thompson; Benj. Cook, foreman; J. B. Backenstos; D. E. Head; M. R. Deming
Victim
Daniel Avery, seized 2 December 1843, discharged in Missouri 25 December 1843

Condition

Papers folded into docket panels, with fold lines throughout. General toning. Brown spots and small edge losses at the top edge of the July 1844 capias. The newspaper leaf has a ragged right edge and a tear across the column. The Doty request slip has a small loss at one lower corner. Light soiling on the indictment reverse. Photographed in plastic binder sleeves with modern notes attached or laid in.

The story behind this item

What the file contains

The file is the working record of case no. 56 in the Hancock County Circuit Court, The People v. Joseph McCoy and others, a charge of false imprisonment. A paper wrapper is docketed "People vs Joseph McCoy et als." The central piece is the manuscript indictment of the May term 1844. The grand jurors charged Joseph McCoy, William Middleton, William Clark, John Elliott, Levi Williams and John Williams with imprisoning Daniel Avery in Hancock County on 1 December 1843, "without any legal warrant authority or reasonable or justifiable cause." The charge alleges a detention of four hours. It is signed by E. A. Thompson as state's attorney. The reverse carries the grand jury's "true Bill," the foreman's signature read as Benj. Cook, Avery's name as prosecutor, four witnesses, the filing date of 24 May 1844 under J. B. Backenstos as clerk, and bail of $300 each.

The other papers follow the case through the clerk's and sheriff's offices: subpoenas, writs of capias on the indictment, and manuscript requests from defense counsel. A partial leaf of the Warsaw Message for 3 January 1844 accompanies the file, with modern printouts and research notes.

The kidnapping behind the charge

Daniel Avery was a farmer and carpenter who had presided over an elders quorum at Montrose, Iowa Territory. In an affidavit of 28 December 1843, sworn before Joseph Smith as mayor of Nauvoo, he said that armed men seized him at Vernon Doty's mill in Bear Creek Precinct on 2 December, bound him, and took him to the river below Warsaw. About midnight five men forced him into a skiff and carried him into Missouri. He was jailed at Palmyra, for a time chained to the floor, on a horse-theft charge supported by a statement his son Philander later swore had been forced from him. A Clark County court ordered his discharge on 25 December 1843. That affidavit is held by the Church History Library. The report transcribes it from the Joseph Smith Papers.

The people named

Levi Williams was a militia colonel and the Green Plains postmaster. He was later tried and acquitted in the prosecution arising from the murders of Joseph and Hyrum Smith. John C. Elliott, a schoolmaster near Warsaw, was arrested in connection with those murders and never tried. The report identifies the indictment's John Williams as Levi's son, John Reid Williams, from linked records; the indictment itself says only John Williams. McCoy, Middleton and Clark were Clark County, Missouri, men. Sisson A. Chase, named on every prosecution subpoena, had sworn the December 1843 complaint against Elliott. The process is signed by Sheriff Minor R. Deming, by clerk Jacob B. Backenstos and by his deputy David E. Head. Backenstos appears as clerk in 1844 and as sheriff on the returns of October 1845.

The prosecution in the record

The papers show the case moving term by term. A subpoena of 16 July 1844 summoned Avery, Andrew M. Hamilton, James Hamilton and Chase for the October term. A capias of the same date ordered the arrest of all six defendants. On 21 October 1844 Deming took Levi Williams, John Elliott and John Williams, and returned that he could not find McCoy, Middleton or Clark in his county. The defense summoned its own witnesses in October 1844, among them John Dedman, the Missouri justice who had committed Philander Avery, and again in May 1845. Avery was served on 24 May 1845. Writs dated 1 September 1845 again sought McCoy, Middleton and Clark and again called Avery and his witnesses, for 20 October. Backenstos, by then sheriff, returned both. Both were filed 27 October 1845.

What remains unresolved

The file shows that a Hancock County grand jury indicted six men for Avery's imprisonment and that the court kept issuing process through October 1845. It contains no verdict. The Joseph Smith Papers concludes that the case never went to trial. The report treats the file as consistent with an unfinished prosecution and says a final disposition would require the circuit court minutes in Record D. The indictment's date of 1 December differs from Avery's 2 December. One capias carries a face date of 30 May 1844 and a May 1845 term on its reverse. Dr. Charles Coolidge, whom Avery named among the men in the skiff, was not indicted, and the reason is unknown.

Related items

More manuscripts