Home › Collection › Manuscripts
File wrapper: People vs Jacob Potts, case number 35
People v. Jacob Potts and George Davison, plow larceny case file, Hancock County Circuit Court, 1843
Hancock County Circuit Court; J. B. Backenstos, circuit clerk (by M. Avise, deputy); J. H. Ralston, state's attorney pro tem; G. O. Bachman, attorney; sheriff's deputies Lewis Robison and E. B. Rose; witnesses and jurors
The court file of a May 1843 Hancock County larceny case. Jacob Potts, a survivor of the Hawn's Mill attack, and George Davison were charged with stealing a plow and clevis owned by William and Wilson Law. The papers include the original manuscript indictment and a certified copy, a defense request signed by attorney George O. Bachman, served subpoenas, signed witness attendance certificates, and the jury verdict signed by twelve jurors. The jury convicted Potts and sentenced him to one year in the penitentiary. It could not agree on Davison.
- Inventory no.
- M-0018
- Author / maker
- Hancock County Circuit Court; J. B. Backenstos, circuit clerk (by M. Avise, deputy); J. H. Ralston, state's attorney pro tem; G. O. Bachman, attorney; sheriff's deputies Lewis Robison and E. B. Rose; witnesses and jurors
- Place
- Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 18-24 May 1843
- Format / binding
- Group of loose court papers from case No. 35. Paper file wrapper with docket title. Manuscript indictment on two sheets with grand-jury endorsement on the folded panel, signed J H Ralston and Wesley Williams, foreman. Certified manuscript copy of the indictment signed J B Backenstos. Handwritten subpoena request signed G O Bachman. Printed subpoena forms completed in manuscript, with embossed circuit-court seals and signed sheriff's returns and fee dockets on the reverse. Printed witness attendance certificates signed by the witnesses (one by mark) and the clerk, docketed on the reverse. A loose affidavit docket. Manuscript jury verdict signed by twelve jurors, with filing wrapper.
- Signed
- Yes
- Court
- Hancock County Circuit Court, Carthage, May term 1843
- Parties
- The People v. Jacob Potts and George Davison
- Charge
- Larceny of a plow and clevis valued at $10, property of William and Wilson Law
- Verdict
- Potts guilty, property assessed at $9.50, one year in the penitentiary; no agreement on Davison
- Signatories
- J. H. Ralston, Wesley Williams, J. B. Backenstos, G. O. Bachman, Lewis Robison, E. B. Rose, witnesses, twelve jurors
Condition
Fold lines on all papers. Brown stains on the indictment's first sheet and an ink blot in the revised plow description on the continuation. General light toning. The wrapper shows edge wear and small chips along the lower edge; the Isaac Allred and Asa C. Earl certificates have small losses along the top edge. Modern sticky notes and handwritten notes sit beside some papers in the photographs and are not part of the 1843 file.
The story behind this item
The case file
These are the loose papers of case No. 35 in the Hancock County Circuit Court, May term 1843: The People v. Jacob Potts and George Davison, on a charge of larceny. The file holds a paper wrapper titled "People vs Jacob Potts," the original manuscript indictment and a certified copy, a short handwritten request for defense subpoenas, printed subpoena forms completed by hand with the sheriff's returns on the reverse, printed witness attendance certificates, and the jury's verdict with its filing wrapper. None of the papers is a transcript of testimony.
The charge
The indictment states that on 5 May 1843 Jacob Potts and George Davison stole "One Plough and Clevis" worth ten dollars, the goods of William Law and Wilson Law. It sets out the accusation in three counts, varying the description of the plow, including a "patent Cary plough." One revised word is tentatively read "Jewetts." The paper ends with the name of J. H. Ralston, state's attorney pro tem. The endorsement records a true bill signed by Wesley Williams, foreman of the grand jury, and lists Wilson Law, George B. Hicks, Isaac Alred and Lewis Robison as witnesses. It was filed 18 May 1843 by clerk J. B. Backenstos, by his deputy M. Avise. A clerk's copy carries Backenstos's certification, "A true copy."
Witnesses for both sides
Attorney George O. Bachman signed a note telling the clerk to issue a subpoena for Peter Huntsman, Earl, William and Nancy Davison "to testify on part of defendant." Peter Huntsman was the brother of Potts's wife, Catherine Elizabeth Huntsman Potts. A separate writ of 18 May summoned Peter and William Huntsman; the identity of this William is unresolved. Another defense writ named Asa Earl, Nancy Davison and William Lincoln. The prosecution summoned Alma Alred and Emily Whitmarsh, Isaac Alred and George Hicks, and Albert Minor and Wilson Law himself. Constable and deputy Lewis Robison, who the BYU catalog of a related search warrant says recovered the plow and arrested both men, served most of the writs. Signed attendance certificates survive for Peter Huntsman (by his mark), Asa C. Earl, Emily Whitmarsh and Isaac Allred.
The verdict
Twelve jurors signed the verdict. They found "the Prisoner Jacob Potts guilty," assessed the property at $9.50, and sentenced him to the penitentiary for one year. The verdict is dated 21 May 1843; its wrapper reads "Filed May 20 1843." The report preserves that mismatch. In a separate note on the same sheet, the jurors said they could not agree upon George Davison and asked to be discharged.
The people
Potts was born in Ohio in 1813. He was wounded at Hawn's Mill on 30 October 1838 and filed a redress claim for $1,420 in 1839. The alleged owners were prominent Nauvoo men. In May 1843 William Law was a counselor in the First Presidency and Wilson Law was major general of the Nauvoo Legion. Their break with Joseph Smith came in 1844. Ralston had been a legislator and circuit judge. Bachman later served on the coroner's jury connected with the deaths of Joseph and Hyrum Smith. William Clayton's journal places Stephen A. Douglas presiding at Carthage on 18 May, which the report treats as strong evidence for the judge of this term.
What remains unresolved
The papers record who was summoned and who attended. They do not record what anyone said. No judgment entry, commitment order or prison record has been found for Potts, so the report does not establish whether or how he served the sentence. Davison's final disposition is unknown. Several identifications are offered only as candidates: the witness William Huntsman, Emily Whitmarsh, Albert Minor, George Davison, and some jurors. Two juror surnames are tentatively read Henthorn and Benham. The report names the court's minute or judgment entry for the May 1843 term as the record most likely to settle these questions.
Related items
More manuscripts


