Home › Collection › Manuscripts
The affidavit, signed by Phineas Kimball Jr. and sworn before Chas Collins, Notary Public, West Fairlee, 21 May 1859
Affidavit of agency by Phineas Kimball Jr. for Nauvoo land, West Fairlee, Vermont, 1859
Phineas Kimball Jr., deponent; sworn before Chas (Charles) Collins, notary public; certified by S. B. Hebard, clerk of the Orange County Court
Manuscript affidavit sworn at West Fairlee, Vermont, on 21 May 1859. Phineas Kimball Jr., younger brother of Nauvoo merchant Hiram Kimball, swore that for the past two years he had been the lawful agent of the heirs of Horace R. Hotchkiss, Smith Tuttle and John D. Gillett for their real estate in Nauvoo, empowered to keep off and prosecute trespassers. These were the eastern investors whose 1839 land agreement with Joseph Smith underlay much of the city. An Orange County Court certification of 21 June 1859 is attached.
- Inventory no.
- M-0027
- Author / maker
- Phineas Kimball Jr., deponent; sworn before Chas (Charles) Collins, notary public; certified by S. B. Hebard, clerk of the Orange County Court
- Place
- West Fairlee, Orange County, Vermont (certification at Chelsea, Vermont)
- Date
- 21 May 1859; certification 21 June 1859
- Format / binding
- Manuscript affidavit in ink on one side of a leaf, signed by Phineas Kimball Jr., with jurat signed by Chas Collins, Notary Public. Attached printed Orange County Court certification form completed by hand and signed by S. B. Hebard, Clerk, with embossed court seal.
- Signed
- Yes
- Deponent
- Phineas Kimball Jr. of West Fairlee, Vermont
- Principals
- Heirs of Horace R. Hotchkiss, Smith Tuttle and John D. Gillett
- Property
- Real estate in Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois (parcels not specified)
- Officials
- Chas Collins, notary public; S. B. Hebard, clerk of the Orange County Court
- Attachments
- Printed county court certification, 21 June 1859, with embossed seal
Condition
Photographs show old fold lines, overall toning, and brown spots and staining along the left edge of the affidavit leaf and at a fold on the certification sheet. Some faint offset or bleed-through of writing is visible on the lower part of the certification sheet.
The story behind this item
The document
On 21 May 1859 Phineas Kimball Jr. of West Fairlee, Orange County, Vermont, swore before Chas Collins, Notary Public, that he was and for the two years past had been "the lawful authorized agent of the Heirs of Horace R. Hotchkiss, Smith Tuttle & John D. Gillett." He stated that he had full charge and possession of their real estate in Nauvoo, Hancock County, Illinois, and was empowered and requested to keep all persons from trespassing on it and to prosecute trespassers. Kimball signed the statement. A month later, on 21 June 1859, S. B. Hebard, clerk of the Orange County Court, completed a printed certification at Chelsea. He attested that Charles Collins was an acting justice of the peace and that his signature was genuine, and he affixed the court seal.
The investors
Hotchkiss, Tuttle and Gillet were associated with Connecticut. In June 1836 Hotchkiss and Gillet bought Commerce-area land from Alexander White. On 12 August 1839 Joseph Smith, Sidney Rigdon and Hyrum Smith entered an agreement with the investors for about four hundred acres, with payment over twenty years. That arrangement was canceled on 7 July 1843, when most of the land was quitclaimed back to the partnership and a new agreement followed. Gillet died in July 1848 and Hotchkiss in April 1849. Tuttle lived until 1865, so the phrase "the Heirs of" cannot be read as proof that all three men were dead in 1859.
The Kimball family
Phineas Kimball Jr. was born at West Fairlee on 1 May 1822. The 1874 Hancock County atlas places him in Nauvoo in 1842, clerking for his older brother Hiram, who had settled at Commerce in 1833. Hiram married Sarah Granger in 1840. Sarah's effort to organize help for temple workers contributed to the founding of the Relief Society in 1842. Phineas went to California in 1849. In October 1850 George Q. Cannon recorded Howard Egan's complaint that Kimball "had acted the scoundrel with him" in a Mariposa business matter. The entry gives no details and no response from Kimball. Between 1849 and 1852 Kimball also pursued creditor claims involving Joseph Smith's estate in Kimball v. L. C. Bidamon et al., a separate matter from this affidavit. He died in Nauvoo on 7 October 1900.
The officials
The jurat is signed "Chas Collins, Notary Public," while the clerk's form describes him as a justice of the peace. Both descriptions appear on the paper. The report identifies him, probably but not certainly, with Charles Collins, born in Corinth in December 1832, admitted to the Orange County bar on 25 June 1857, and practicing at West Fairlee. That Collins died on 23 December 1861. The report finds no evidence that he settled in Hancock County.
What it shows and what remains open
The affidavit records Kimball's own assertion of existing authority. It is not the owners' appointment of him, and it carries no signature of the heirs or principals. The report therefore describes it as an affidavit of agency and authority to prosecute trespassers rather than a power of attorney. It names no lot, parcel, defendant, tenant or lawsuit. The county certification authenticated the notary and did not verify ownership or the appointment. The sequence fits a statement prepared for use elsewhere, plausibly in Illinois, but no filing endorsement is visible and the recipient is unidentified. The exact parcels, the underlying appointment, and the reason the affidavit was made remain unresolved. The report suggests Hancock County deed indexes and court files for 1857 to 1860, and the Hotchkiss and Gillet estate papers, as the next records to search.
Related items
More manuscripts


