Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Case wrapper: Jesse Spurgin vs Britton Willis, Covenant, with red figures and "Costs made out"

Manuscripts · Hancock County, Illinois · 25 September to 3 October 1843

Declaration and praecipe in Spurgin v. Willis, farm lease covenant, Hancock County Circuit Court, 1843

Warren & Higbee (Calvin A. Warren and Chauncey L. Higbee), attorneys for the plaintiff; filed by Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk

Original Hancock County Circuit Court papers from Jesse Spurgin's 1843 suit in covenant against Britton Willis. The file holds a case wrapper, a praecipe for summons dated 25 September 1843, and a two-count declaration filed 3 October 1843, subscribed by Warren & Higbee and endorsed by clerk Jacob B. Backenstos. Spurgin alleged that Willis leased him a farm, let him dig a well, then refused him possession, leaving his family in an open cabin. The witness to the copied lease was Levi Jackman.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0037
Author / maker
Warren & Higbee (Calvin A. Warren and Chauncey L. Higbee), attorneys for the plaintiff; filed by Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk
Place
Hancock County, Illinois
Date
25 September to 3 October 1843
Format / binding
Manuscript court file: folded case wrapper; praecipe for summons on ruled paper with separate filing endorsement; long two-count declaration on several stitched leaves, photographed in seven overlapping sections, with docket endorsement. Ink. Subscribed by the firm Warren & Higbee; filing endorsements by the clerk. Lease names, cross mark, seals and witness appear only as copies within the declaration.
Signed
Yes
Parties
Jesse Spurgin, plaintiff; Britton Willis, defendant
Court
Hancock County Circuit Court, October Term 1843
Action
Covenant (civil)
Damages demanded
$1,000
Parcel
Fractional NW quarter, section 31, T6N, R8W

Condition

From the photographs: old folds throughout; toning and a dark stain band across the wrapper, with small edge chips; small tear and loss at the foot of one declaration section (IMG 3714); declaration leaves sewn at the head with cord; some ink show-through on the docket leaf.

The story behind this item

The papers in the case

This file preserves the plaintiff's side of a civil action of covenant in the Hancock County Circuit Court, October Term 1843. It holds a case wrapper endorsed "Costs made out," a praecipe dated 25 September 1843 asking the clerk to issue a summons, and a long two-count declaration filed 3 October 1843. Both filings carry the endorsement of the circuit clerk, read as J. B. Backenstos. The firm of Warren & Higbee subscribed the pleadings as attorneys for the plaintiff.

A farm promised and withheld

The declaration states that on 9 September 1842 Britton Willis agreed to lease to Jesse Spurgin the farm where Willis then lived, with its buildings and adjoining cleared and fenced ground. The term was to begin 13 October 1842 and run through the season or year 1843. Rent was $1.50 per acre of farming ground, due at the end of the term. Spurgin was allowed to sink a well and make necessary improvements, to be compensated from the rent or otherwise. He alleged that he dug the well, found water, and made improvements worth $100. He alleged that Willis never gave possession. He said his family was forced to live in an "open Cabin" and lost their health. He sued for $1,000 in damages.

The lease also held out a possible purchase. If Willis obtained the land from heirs who claimed it and could give a lawful deed, and Spurgin paid under a former contract, no rent would be due. The heirs and the price are not named. The copied land description reads the fractional northwest quarter of section 31, township 6 north, range 8 west, with a correction from south to north. Published property notes for Britton Willis list land in the same quarter section.

The people named

The report connects the plaintiff with the Jesse Spurgin listed as a priest on an 18 October 1842 branch petition south of Nauvoo, with Lydia and Susanna Spurgin. He later appears as a Montebello representative for the sale of the Saints' lands in 1845, and with Lydia in the Nauvoo temple endowment index under 12 January 1846. The lease witness, Levi Jackman, was a carpenter who worked on the Kirtland and Nauvoo temples and went west with Brigham Young's pioneer company in 1847. Calvin A. Warren had advised Joseph Smith on bankruptcy in 1842. Chauncey L. Higbee had been excommunicated in May 1842 and in 1844 was among the publishers of the Nauvoo Expositor. The clerk, Jacob B. Backenstos, never joined the Church. As sheriff in 1845 he called out a posse to defend Mormon residents.

Two counts, two dates

The declaration tells the story twice. The first count sets out the covenants in legal narrative. The second quotes the articles of agreement, including Willis's cross mark, the two seals, and the attestation "Test Levi Jackman." The report reads these as two pleaded versions of one agreement. A second lease has not been established. The first count dates the well digging to 12 September 1842 and the second to 12 October 1842. The report retains both dates and does not choose between them.

What remains unresolved

The papers record allegations, not findings. No answer from Willis, sheriff's return, judgment, or settlement has been found. The $1,000 is the sum demanded. No award is recorded. The original lease is not among the photographed papers; the names, mark and seals appear only as copies within the declaration. Which partner wrote the pleadings or signed the firm name is not established. Willis's identity rests on the tract match with compiled property notes, and the report states that no deed chain has been inspected. Court records at the Illinois Regional Archives Depository at Western Illinois University are named as the next place to look.

Related items

More manuscripts