Home › Collection › Documents
Front: the appeal bond of Joab Green and Henry Hunter to James Stark, dated 28 November 1842.
Appeal bond in Stark v. Green, Hancock County Circuit Court, 28 November 1842
Joab Green, appellant, and Henry Hunter, surety; witnessed by George Bachman; approved for J. C. Davis, circuit clerk, by M. Avise, deputy clerk
Printed appeal bond, completed by hand and filed 28 November 1842 in James Stark v. Joab Green, Hancock Circuit Court, No. 65. Green and his surety Henry Hunter bind themselves to Stark for $100 on an appeal from a justice's judgment in a trial of the right of property. The witness, George Bachman, offered Joseph Smith his help two months later. The clerk, J. C. Davis, was tried for Smith's murder in 1845 and acquitted. The outcome of the appeal is not established.
- Inventory no.
- D-0002
- Author / maker
- Joab Green, appellant, and Henry Hunter, surety; witnessed by George Bachman; approved for J. C. Davis, circuit clerk, by M. Avise, deputy clerk
- Place
- Hancock County, Illinois (Hancock Circuit Court)
- Date
- 28 November 1842
- Format / binding
- One leaf, printed court blank completed in manuscript on both sides. Front: bond text with ornamental border at left and the imprint of Jas. Gemble, Jr., printer, Warsaw. Signed by Joab Green and Henry Hunter beside printed [SEAL] marks, witnessed by George Bachman, approved "J. C. Davis Clerk, By M. Avise Dep". Reverse: printed docket panel completed by hand, No. 65, filed 28 November 1842. Printed terms for a money-debt appeal are cancelled by hand.
- Signed
- Yes
- Court
- Hancock Circuit Court, Appeal Bond No. 65
- Parties
- James Stark, claimant; Joab Green, defendant and appellant
- Surety
- Henry Hunter
- Penal amount
- $100
- Witness and officers
- George Bachman, witness; J. C. Davis, clerk; M. Avise, deputy clerk
Condition
From the photographs: several horizontal folds, light overall toning, and show-through of the printing from the opposite side. A small nick or loss at the right edge near the line naming the justice. The handwriting is dark and legible.
The story behind this item
What the document is
This is the original appeal bond filed in James Stark v. Joab Green, Hancock Circuit Court, docketed as No. 65. It is a printed court blank from the press of Jas. Gemble, Jr., of Warsaw, completed by hand and dated 28 November 1842. Joab Green and Henry Hunter bind themselves to James Stark in the sum of one hundred dollars. The condition is that Green will pay and satisfy whatever judgment the circuit court renders on the dismissal or trial of his appeal.
The appeal was taken from a judgment given on 23 November 1842 by a justice of the peace whose name the report reads, tentatively, as "[Wm?] Berry". Stark was the claimant in a "trial of the right of property", a procedure for deciding ownership of personal property seized to collect a debt. The clerk struck the printed words for a money-debt appeal and wrote in "Claimant" and "trial of the right of property". The reverse carries the docket caption and the filing note.
What the hundred dollars meant
The $100 is the penal amount of the bond. The report states that it is no known purchase price, property valuation, damages award or payment actually made. Hunter signed as surety and co-obligor. The condition names only Green as the person who must satisfy the judgment, and the reverse caption lists only Stark and Green.
The witness and the clerk
George Bachman signed as subscribing witness. The report identifies him, on very strong grounds, as George Ogden Bachman, a lawyer practicing in Springfield and Hancock County. The bond does not name him as counsel for either party. On 21 January 1843, less than two months later, he wrote from Carthage to Joseph Smith as "Respected Friend" and offered his services "both professional and personal". He later did paid legal work for Smith and for the city of Nauvoo, had a claim allowed against Smith's estate in April 1845, and served on the coroner's jury on the deaths of Joseph and Hyrum Smith. His baptism or Church membership is not established.
The bond is approved in the name of J. C. Davis, clerk, by deputy clerk M. Avise. Jacob Cunningham Davis became circuit clerk in 1841 at about twenty-one and was elected to the Illinois Senate in 1842. In June 1844 he commanded the Warsaw Rifle Company. He was arrested in Springfield on 25 December 1844 on a murder indictment arising from Joseph Smith's killing, was released by order of the Senate, and stood trial in May 1845 with Thomas C. Sharp, Mark Aldrich, William N. Grover and Levi Williams. The jury acquitted all five on 30 May. He later sat in Congress from 4 November 1856 to 3 March 1857. His approval of this bond was a routine administrative act.
The parties and the surety
James Stark settled at Augusta in 1842 as a merchant and a minister of the Christian Church, or Disciples of Christ. Thomas Gregg's county history places his 1846 to 1847 legislative candidacy on an Anti-Mormon ticket. Joab Green appears in the 1842 Hancock tax index. He and Henry Hunter both appear on the May 1844 grand jury roster connected with the perjury indictment against Joseph Smith, a roster that also names the Latter-day Saints Edward Hunter and William Marks. Individual votes are not recorded.
A Henry Hunter was appointed on 19 August 1843 to a committee of nine at an anti-Mormon meeting in the Carthage courthouse. That committee asked to be discharged without a formal report. The Nauvoo Neighbor of 18 and 25 October 1843 listed Henry Hunter among those it called the leading "anties". The report treats the identification with Green's surety as probable, short of proved.
What remains unresolved
The bond records the start of the appeal only. It does not identify the property in dispute, the debtor, the creditor or the officer who made the seizure. No later judgment, settlement or dismissal has been established. The evidence does not show that either litigant was a Latter-day Saint or that religion caused the suit. Joab Green has not been shown to be the Latter-day Saint Job Edward Green. Henry Hunter's family, birth and death are not securely joined to the signer. The reading of the justice's name remains tentative. The report points to the original case packet, the circuit court docket and the justice's docket for November 1842 as the next sources to search.
Related items
More documents


