Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

Case wrapper endorsed People vs William Welch, with filing numbers

Manuscripts · La Harpe, Hancock County, Illinois · 17 August to 19 September 1843

Peace proceeding papers in State of Illinois v. William Welch, La Harpe, Hancock County, 1843

John J. Hicok, justice of the peace, La Harpe; filed by J. B. Backenstos, circuit clerk

The justice's file for an 1843 peace proceeding in Hancock County. On 17 August 1843 Joshua D. Stewart swore before John J. Hicok at La Harpe that he feared William Welch would shoot or kill him. The packet holds the affidavit, Hicok's certified docket, the witness and defendant recognizances, and the case wrapper, all filed for the October 1843 circuit term by J. B. Backenstos. Hicok had sold land to the Nauvoo Temple committee and later clerked the grand jury investigating the Smith murders.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0035
Author / maker
John J. Hicok, justice of the peace, La Harpe; filed by J. B. Backenstos, circuit clerk
Place
La Harpe, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
17 August to 19 September 1843
Format / binding
Manuscript case packet in ink: case wrapper; justice's docket transcript written on both sides with certificate and exterior endorsement; affidavit; witness recognizance; defendant's recognizance. Affidavit and recognizances carry filing endorsements on their reverses. Drawn scroll seals beside signatures. Eight apparent autographs and one mark.
Signed
Yes
Parties
State of Illinois v. William Welch; complainant Joshua D. Stewart
Court
Justice of the peace John J. Hicok, La Harpe; filed for Hancock County Circuit Court, October term 1843
Security
$200 peace recognizance; four witness recognizances at $50 each
Officers
V. M. Conrad, constable; J. B. Backenstos, circuit clerk
Signatories
Welch, Stewart, Hicok, Backenstos, Royse, A. Douglass, M. A. Douglass, Dickison [Giton?]; E. J. Black by mark

Condition

Photographs show the papers folded into panels, with fold lines, light toning, and ink showing through from the opposite sides. Ink blots obscure words on the affidavit and the Welch recognizance.

The story behind this item

The papers

This packet records a peace proceeding before John J. Hicok, justice of the peace at La Harpe, Hancock County. It holds a case wrapper endorsed "People vs William Welch," Hicok's certified transcript of his docket, the sworn affidavit of Joshua D. Stewart, a recognizance for four witnesses, and the recognizance of William Welch and his surety. The reverses carry filing endorsements of 19 September 1843 by J. B. Backenstos, clerk, for the October 1843 term of the circuit court.

The complaint and the hearing

On 17 August 1843 Stewart swore that he had just cause to fear that Welch would "shoot, kill, or otherwise injure" him. Hicok issued a warrant to V. M. Conrad, constable, and subpoenas for Maria Duglass, Elizabeth J. Black, Benjamin Royse and Aaron Duglass. The docket says only that "the evidence being heard," Welch was ordered to give $200 security to appear at circuit court and keep the peace toward Stewart. He could not furnish security and was committed to jail. The next day he was returned to court, and a man the docket calls Dickison joined him in a $200 recognizance. The affidavit records feared injury. It does not report a shooting.

Signatures and marks

The name census in the report counts eight apparent autographs, one execution by mark and one official named without an autograph. Welch, Stewart, Hicok, Backenstos, Royse, Aaron Douglass, Mary A. Douglass and the surety signed. Elizabeth J. Black made her mark. Conrad appears only in Hicok's hand. The surety's surname is read provisionally as Giton or Gitton. The witness recognizance opens on 17 August 1843, but its approval reads "Seventh day of August" in "forty four," and one clause names Elizabeth Stewart where the execution reads Black. The report preserves both discrepancies.

The people

Hicok kept his office at La Harpe and had business in Nauvoo. On 14 June 1842 he conveyed part of Lot 12, Block 3, Kimball's Addition, to Alpheus Cutler, Reynolds Cahoon and Elias Higbee as the temple committee, for a stated $1,200. After the deaths of Joseph and Hyrum Smith he served as clerk of the grand jury investigating the murders. His religious affiliation is not established. Jacob B. Backenstos, circuit clerk from 1843 to 1845, was a friend of Joseph Smith and the Saints who never joined the Church, and later served as sheriff. The constable was probably Vincent M. Conrad, listed as a Seventy in published 1846 temple records, though no record yet ties the full name to the office. A Joshua Stewart signed the November 1843 memorial to Congress for the Saints' Missouri losses, but his identity with the complainant is unproved.

Context

The case falls four days after Joseph Smith's 13 August 1843 funeral sermon for Elias Higbee, while the Nauvoo Temple was under construction. The procedure rested on an 1827 Illinois act that let a justice require security for the peace on sworn evidence of threats. The papers state no religious or political motive for the quarrel.

What remains open

The circuit court's disposition has not been located. The cause of the dispute, the testimony and Welch's answer are absent from the papers. A William Welsh who signed a jury verdict in Dana v. Brink on 23 May 1844 is a strong probable match by handwriting, not a proven identification. The surety's identity, the witnesses' families and the Stewart and Conrad identifications all remain open.

Related items

More manuscripts