Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Documents

Front: printed Hancock Circuit Court form, October term 1864, with T. C. Sharp's sworn statement of attendance as a witness.

Documents · Hancock Circuit Court, Hancock County, Illinois · 7 October 1864

Thomas C. Sharp witness attendance affidavit, Hancock Circuit Court, October term 1864

Thomas C. Sharp, witness (signature appears to read "Tho. C. Sharp"); sworn before the clerk of the Hancock Circuit Court, whose name is provisionally read

A printed Hancock Circuit Court form from the October term of 1864, completed by hand and apparently signed by Thomas C. Sharp. Sharp swears that he attended court two days as a witness for the plaintiff. Sharp edited the Warsaw Signal, was indicted for the murders of Joseph and Hyrum Smith, and was acquitted on 30 May 1845. This paper finds him twenty years later in a routine civil case. The research report describes the item as a subpoena; the photographs show a witness attendance affidavit.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
D-0004
Author / maker
Thomas C. Sharp, witness (signature appears to read "Tho. C. Sharp"); sworn before the clerk of the Hancock Circuit Court, whose name is provisionally read
Place
Hancock Circuit Court, Hancock County, Illinois
Date
7 October 1864
Format / binding
One small oblong leaf. Printed Hancock Circuit Court form completed in manuscript on the front, with a witness signature and a clerk's signature by deputy. Manuscript filing note on the back. No seal visible.
Signed
Yes
Court
Hancock Circuit Court, Illinois, October term 1864
Witness
T. C. Sharp (Thomas Coke Sharp, 1818 to 1894)
Case
Appears to read Cabeen v. City of Warsaw; unconfirmed in the docket
Attendance sworn
2 days, at the instance of the plaintiff
Clerk
Appears to read S. R. Davis, by A. J. Davis, deputy; provisional

Condition

Even toning. One vertical fold with a short split at the lower edge. Small chips and a short tear at the right edge. Ink show-through visible on the back. Faint pencil figures on the front.

The story behind this item

What the document is

This is a small printed form of the Hancock Circuit Court, Illinois, completed in ink for the October term of 1864. The printed text is a witness's sworn statement of attendance. As read from the photographs, the caption names Cabeen as plaintiff and the City of Warsaw as defendant. T. C. Sharp, "being duly sworn, deposes and says that he attended said court as a witness in the above mentioned case 2 days, at the instance of the Plaintiff during the present term of said court." The form is signed at the right, apparently "Tho. C. Sharp", and was sworn on 7 October 1864. The clerk's line appears to read "S. R. Davis, by A. J. Davis, Dep." The back carries a filing note that appears to read "Filed Oct 7 1864, S. R. Davis Clk."

How the report describes it

The accompanying research report calls the item a printed subpoena commanding "T. C. Sharp" to appear as a witness. It reads the case as "Cahen or a similar surname v. Morgan" and the clerk as George W. Davis. The report states that both the caption and the signature should remain provisional until compared with the circuit docket and known exemplars. The photographs support a different reading on each point, as given above. All readings of the handwriting in this listing are also provisional. The report and the photographs agree on the court, the October 1864 term, the witness and the filing date of 7 October 1864.

Thomas C. Sharp

Thomas Coke Sharp (1818 to 1894) was born at Mount Holly, New Jersey, studied at Dickinson College and was admitted to the Pennsylvania bar in 1840. He reached Warsaw, Illinois, that September and took editorial control of the Western World on 11 November 1840. He renamed it the Warsaw Signal on 12 May 1841 and broke publicly with Joseph Smith within weeks. He lost the paper in 1842 and regained it in February 1844. On 12 June 1844, after the Nauvoo Expositor press was destroyed, his editorial called for action with "POWDER and BALL". Joseph and Hyrum Smith were killed at Carthage jail on 27 June 1844. A Hancock County grand jury indicted Sharp and eight others on 26 October 1844. A jury acquitted Sharp and four co-defendants on 30 May 1845. The report states that the record does not establish that he entered the jail or fired a weapon.

Sharp in 1864

Sharp stayed in Hancock County after the Latter-day Saint departure. He sat in the Illinois constitutional convention of 1847 to 1848 and served as mayor of Warsaw in 1853 to 1854 and 1859 to 1861. Local records list him as Warsaw city clerk in 1864 and 1865, the period of this document. In December 1865 he moved to Carthage and began a four-year term as Hancock County judge. He later practiced law, edited the Carthage Gazette, and died at Carthage on 9 April 1894.

What it shows and what is unresolved

The report values the paper for placing Sharp in the ordinary legal life of Hancock County twenty years after the Carthage killings, shortly before his move to Carthage. He appears here as a witness in a routine civil action. The form also appears to carry his signature. The case has not been identified in court records. The report lists the open questions: the caption, the parties, the clerk, the filing date, the witness appearance and the disposition, all to be confirmed in the circuit docket and minute book. If the defendant is the City of Warsaw, the document would show the city's clerk attending for the plaintiff in a suit against the city. That reading is unconfirmed, and the report does not discuss it.

Related items

More documents