Home › Collection › Manuscripts
Front: Pardon Webb's affidavit of service, sworn before Orson Spencer, 15 May 1843
Affidavit of service in Webb v. Rigby, ejectment, Hancock Circuit Court, Nauvoo, May 1843
Pardon Webb, deponent; sworn before Orson Spencer, justice of the peace
Original affidavit of service from the Hancock Circuit Court ejectment suit Chauncey G. Webb v. Edward Rigby and Barnard Rigby. Pardon Webb swore that on 11 May 1843 he served both Rigbys, as tenants in possession, with the declaration and notice. Orson Spencer took the oath as justice of the peace on 15 May, and the clerk filed it on 16 May. The paper ties the Webb wagon-making brothers, a Lancashire immigrant family, and a future Nauvoo mayor to one contested lot in Kimball's Addition.
- Inventory no.
- M-0033
- Author / maker
- Pardon Webb, deponent; sworn before Orson Spencer, justice of the peace
- Place
- Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 15 May 1843 (service 11 May; filed 16 May 1843)
- Format / binding
- Single manuscript sheet. Affidavit of service written on the front, signed by Pardon Webb and Orson Spencer, each with a drawn L.S. seal notation. Clerk's docket and filing endorsement on the reverse. Folded into a narrow packet for the court file.
- Signed
- Yes
- Parties
- Chauncey G. Webb, plaintiff; Edward Rigby and Barnard Rigby, defendants
- Court
- Hancock Circuit Court, May Term 1843
- Action
- Ejectment (recovery of possession)
- Parcel
- North half of Lot 38, Block 6, Kimball's Addition, Nauvoo
- Signatories
- Pardon Webb; Orson Spencer, justice of the peace
Condition
Photographs show fold lines from packet folding, overall toning, scattered staining, and small chips along the left edge. A later pencil notation "300" appears at the upper right of the front. The attorney endorsement on the reverse is faint.
The story behind this item
The document
This is the original affidavit of service in Chauncey G. Webb v. Edward Rigby and Barnard Rigby, an ejectment action in the Hancock Circuit Court. Pardon Webb swore that on 11 May 1843 he personally served Edward Rigby and Barnard Rigby, each separately, as tenants in possession of the premises named in the declaration. He gave each a true copy of the declaration and notice and explained their intent and meaning. He swore to this before Orson Spencer, justice of the peace, on 15 May 1843. The docket on the reverse records the May Term 1843, the word "Ejectment," and filing on 16 May 1843 by J. B. Backenstos, clerk, by M. Avise, deputy clerk.
The parties and the ground
Chauncey Webb, the plaintiff, was Pardon's older brother. On 29 December 1842 Ethan Kimball, acting through his attorney Hiram Kimball, conveyed to him the north half of Lot 38, Block 6, in Kimball's Addition for a stated $500. An assessment compiled in 1841 and early 1842 already associates Edward and "Barner" Rigby with portions of that lot. The assessment is not a deed, but it places the Rigbys on the ground before Chauncey bought it. Their own explanation of their claim has not survived among the papers examined. The phrase "tenants in possession" describes their place in the proceeding. It does not establish that they rented from Chauncey.
The Rigbys
The report identifies the defendants, with considerable confidence, as Edward Rigby, born in 1789, and his son Barnet or Barnett, born in 1815. Edward's compiled family history names the same three-tenths of an acre in the north half of Lot 38. The family sailed from Liverpool on the Sheffield on 7 February 1841 and reached New Orleans on 30 March. On 15 January 1842 the Book of the Law of the Lord credited Edward with a cow valued at $10, "as he says 1/2 his property." Susanna Rigby joined the Female Relief Society on 27 May 1842. Edward died in October 1846 in the Council Bluffs region. Barnett reached Utah in 1848.
The Webbs and the Spencers
Pardon Knapp Webb was twenty-four. He was one of five brothers remembered for the Webb blacksmith and wagon shop in Nauvoo, a trade taught by their father James. The shop later helped outfit departing Saints. Pardon attended the Nauvoo Masonic Lodge on 31 January 1843 and served missions in Michigan and at Salmon River. Chauncey crossed to Utah in 1848 and joined the 1856 rescue party. Orson Spencer, a former Baptist minister, was a Nauvoo alderman and University of Nauvoo professor. He had been called to New Haven at the April 1843 conference but was still in Hancock County on 15 May. He later presided over the British Mission and became chancellor of the University of Deseret.
The course of the case
Joseph Smith's journal records a "Webb & Rigby" possession hearing on 30 March 1843, with Joseph assisting George W. Harris. The Joseph Smith Papers editors connect it with this dispute, a qualified identification. The jury trial ran until one o'clock the next morning and the verdict is unknown. On 16 October 1843 the circuit court entered a default judgment awarding Chauncey possession and costs. On 23 May 1846 a second entry recorded withdrawal of a defendant's plea and again awarded him possession.
What remains unresolved
The affidavit proves the parties' legal roles, the asserted service, the oath and the filing date. The reverse is labeled "Declaration," but the declaration itself and its property description are not on the photographed sides. The defense, the steps between the two judgments, and any sheriff's return are missing. The reasons for the dispute and the date Chauncey took possession remain unresolved. The attorney endorsement on the reverse is faint and needs further collation.
Related items
More manuscripts


