Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

William Law's bond for costs, recto, signed "Wm. Law," 16 March 1843

Manuscripts · Hancock County, Illinois (Hancock Circuit Court) · 16 March and 27 May 1843

William and Wilson Law court papers in Rayburn v. Foster, Hancock Circuit Court, 1843

William Law, surety for costs; Wilson Law, witness; J. B. Backenstos, circuit clerk

Two original papers from case No. 122, Thomas [G.?] Rayburn & Co. v. Robert D. Foster, in the Hancock Circuit Court, May term 1843. In the first, dated 16 March 1843, William Law binds himself as security for all costs in the action. In the second, dated 27 May 1843, Wilson Law swears that he attended the court as a witness for six days. Both carry original signatures and the endorsements of clerk J. B. Backenstos. They date from the period before the brothers broke with Joseph Smith.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0029
Author / maker
William Law, surety for costs; Wilson Law, witness; J. B. Backenstos, circuit clerk
Place
Hancock County, Illinois (Hancock Circuit Court)
Date
16 March and 27 May 1843
Format / binding
Two separate papers, each written on the recto with clerk's endorsements on the verso. (1) Handwritten undertaking on ruled paper, signed "Wm. Law"; verso endorsed "Bond for Costs," filed 20 March 1843, with a "PAID" mark and other notations. (2) Printed Hancock Circuit Court witness-affidavit form completed in manuscript, signed twice by Wilson Law and attested by J. B. Backenstos, clerk; verso endorsed "Affidavit," No. 122, filed 27 May 1843 by deputy clerk M. Avise.
Signed
Yes
Case
Thomas [G.?] Rayburn & Co. v. Robert D. Foster, No. 122
Court
Hancock Circuit Court, May term 1843
Signatories
William Law; Wilson Law; J. B. Backenstos, clerk
Pieces
Two: bond for costs and witness-attendance affidavit
Filed
20 March 1843 and 27 May 1843

Condition

From the photographs: both papers show horizontal fold lines. The Law bond has an irregular lower edge with a small loss at the lower right, a ragged left edge on the verso, and a faint blue offset mark on the verso. The affidavit has a small chip at the upper right corner and a rough left edge. Light toning to both.

The story behind this item

Two papers from one lawsuit

This lot holds two original papers from the same suit in the Hancock Circuit Court. The plaintiff was Thomas [G.?] Rayburn, trading as Thomas [G.?] Rayburn & Co. The defendant was Robert D. Foster. The surname also appears as Raybourn, and the middle initial is a tentative reading. Both papers carry case No. 122 in their filing endorsements. The clerk was J. B. Backenstos.

William Law's bond for costs

The first paper is a handwritten undertaking dated 16 March 1843, for the May term of 1843. William Law entered himself as security for costs. He acknowledged himself bound to pay all costs that might accrue in the action, to the opposite party or to the officers of the court. He signed it "Wm. Law." The reverse is endorsed "Bond for Costs" and filed 20 March 1843 by Backenstos. A "PAID" mark and other notations also appear there. The report states that the mark is not a judgment or satisfaction of the claim. The paper does not say why William signed. It does not identify him as an attorney.

Wilson Law's witness affidavit

The second paper is a printed Hancock Circuit Court form completed by hand. Wilson Law swore that he attended the court as a witness in the case for six days during the May 1843 term. He signed it twice, once in the body and once below. It was sworn before Backenstos on 27 May 1843. The reverse records filing the same day by deputy clerk M. Avise. The handwritten party designation appears to name both plaintiff and defendant. The report treats that reading as provisional. The affidavit records attendance only. It does not preserve Wilson's testimony.

The Law brothers in Nauvoo

William Law, born in Ireland in 1809, led the Churchville branch in Upper Canada before reaching Nauvoo in autumn 1839. He was appointed to the First Presidency in 1841. Wilson Law, born in 1806, served on the Nauvoo City Council and became major general of the Nauvoo Legion in August 1842. The brothers built a steam mill for flour and sawing on Sidney Street. Joseph Smith performed Wilson's marriage to Elizabeth F. Sikes on 25 December 1842. The couple attended Joseph and Emma Smith's dinner on 18 January 1843. These two papers date from the same spring.

Robert D. Foster was a physician and justice of the peace in Nauvoo. In 1843 he was not yet a public opponent of Joseph Smith. On 4 May 1844 he took the affidavits of William and Jane Law on the plural marriage revelation.

After 1843

William's place in the First Presidency ended by January 1844. William, Jane and Wilson were excommunicated in April 1844. Both brothers were among the publishers of the Nauvoo Expositor of 7 June 1844. The city council declared the press a nuisance on 10 June, and it was destroyed. Joseph and Hyrum Smith were killed at Carthage Jail on 27 June. The report states that these two papers give no evidence that the Law brothers planned or took part in the killings.

What remains unresolved

The papers show William securing costs and Wilson attending as a witness. They do not show the substance of Rayburn's claim, the reason William stood as security, or Wilson's testimony. No judgment has been recovered. Rayburn's identity is unknown. The Illinois State Archives lists Hancock Circuit Court case files, index and record series at the Western Illinois University IRAD depository. These are series-level leads. Survival of the case No. 122 file has not been confirmed. A separate May 1843 complaint by Thomas Rawcliff about Foster and the Laws has not been connected to this case.

Related items

More manuscripts