Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Manuscripts

The promissory note, 11 December 1840, signed by Claiborne Wilson and H. T. Wilson

Manuscripts · Hancock County, Illinois; circuit court papers issued at Carthage · 11 December 1840 to 1 November 1841

Promissory note and case papers, William Smith v. Claiborne and Harmon T. Wilson, Hancock County, 1840-1841

Claiborne Wilson and Harmon T. Wilson, makers of the note; court papers signed by Samuel Marshall, justice of the peace, and S. Otho Williams, circuit clerk

A promissory note of 11 December 1840 in which Claiborne Wilson and Harmon T. Wilson promised to pay William Smith, with papers from the debt suit that followed in Hancock County. The file runs from a justice's judgment by Samuel Marshall through an appeal bond, circuit subpoenas and service returns to a jury verdict for Smith on 13 October 1841. Harmon Wilson later helped arrest Joseph Smith in 1843, and several officers named here figure in the conflicts around Nauvoo.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
M-0017
Author / maker
Claiborne Wilson and Harmon T. Wilson, makers of the note; court papers signed by Samuel Marshall, justice of the peace, and S. Otho Williams, circuit clerk
Place
Hancock County, Illinois; circuit court papers issued at Carthage
Date
11 December 1840 to 1 November 1841
Format / binding
Group of manuscript and printed-form court papers. Handwritten promissory note on a narrow slip, signed by both makers. Handwritten certified transcript signed by Samuel Marshall, J.P. Printed appeal bond completed by hand, with three signatures beside printed seals, witnessed and approved by S. Otho Williams. Printed supersedeas and subpoena forms completed by hand and signed by S. Otho Williams, clerk, with embossed seal impressions. Printed service returns with sheriff's fee panels on folded file sheets. Handwritten jury verdict signed by Vernon Doty, foreman. Printed witness certificate signed by Alfred Newell and J. C. Davis, clerk.
Signed
Yes
Parties
William Smith v. Claiborne Wilson and Harmon T. Wilson
Courts
Justice of the peace (Samuel Marshall); Hancock County Circuit Court on appeal
Amounts
Demand $67.88; justice's costs $6.07; jury verdict $70.16
Verdict
For the plaintiff, 13 October 1841, Vernon Doty foreman
Signatories
Claiborne Wilson, H. T. Wilson, John Wilson, Samuel Marshall, S. Otho Williams, W. D. Abernethy, Vernon Doty, Alfred Newell, J. C. Davis

Condition

From the photographs: fold lines on all papers and general toning. The transcript has a loss at the lower right corner. The verdict slip is torn along its lower edge and has an ink smudge at left. Small dark spots at the top left of the subpoena.

The story behind this item

The note and the suit

On 11 December 1840 Claiborne Wilson and Harmon T. Wilson signed a short promise to pay William Smith or bearer in ninety days "for value received." The note gives no account of what changed hands. Claiborne signs above Harmon's heavier "H. T. Wilson." The report reads the written amount as sixty-seven dollars with cents that appear to read "seventy Eight," while the court record carries a demand of $67.88. It asks that the difference be checked against the original.

The report states that Samuel Marshall, justice of the peace, recorded a 15 March 1841 filing on the reverse of the note. Marshall's certified transcript records the $67.88 demand and a judgment for Smith on 1 April 1841, with costs of $6.07.

The appeal to the circuit court

The Wilsons appealed. An appeal bond dated 19 April 1841 carries the signatures of Claiborne Wilson, Harmon T. Wilson and John Wilson, with S. Otho Williams witnessing and approving as clerk. The report treats John Wilson's signature as practical support for the defendants and does not assume his kinship from the surname. A printed supersedeas directed to Marshall ordered him to stop further proceedings on his judgment while the appeal went forward.

For the October 1841 term, a subpoena dated 16 September 1841 summoned Gilmore Callison, Jacob Brumbach, Samuel Comer and Alfred Newell to Carthage at the plaintiff's request. Its reverse records 24 miles of travel and the sheriff's fees. A separate return records service on Robert F. Harris on 6 October 1841 under Sheriff William D. Abernethy, by deputy Michael Barnes.

The verdict

On 13 October 1841 the jury found for the plaintiff in the sum of seventy dollars and sixteen cents. Vernon Doty signed as foreman. On 1 November Alfred Newell swore that he had attended court eight days at the plaintiff's instance; the certificate is signed "J. C. Davis," clerk. The report notes that the verdict exceeds the $67.88 demand by $2.28. Six percent interest is offered as a possible explanation only.

The people in the file

Harmon T. Wilson, born in Virginia in 1815, came to Hancock County in 1836, worked as a merchant and was elected county coroner in 1840. In June 1843 he helped arrest Joseph Smith under Missouri extradition process, and Joseph Smith later sued him and Joseph H. Reynolds over the arrest. The report's militia research places Harmon and Claiborne among the Carthage Greys, but it states that a roster cannot establish either man's actions in June 1844. Family research strongly identifies Claiborne as Harmon's brother; the report says the underlying records still need to complete that proof.

Samuel Marshall was killed in a struggle with Sheriff Miner R. Deming at Carthage on 24 June 1845. S. Otho Williams, identified as Samuel Otho Williams, died in November 1844, and his widow Helen married Harmon Wilson in July 1846. The report identifies the "J. C. Davis" signature as plausibly Jacob Cunningham Davis, later tried and acquitted in 1845 for Joseph Smith's murder, pending a handwriting comparison. Gilmore Callison sat on the 1845 murder-trial jury beside a William Smith.

What remains unresolved

The creditor's identity is not established. The leading candidate is Major William Smith of La Harpe, a merchant and town founder, but no ledger or endorsement connects this note to him. The report states that nothing identifies the plaintiff as Joseph Smith's brother, and that the juror William Smith of 1845 is not shown to be the same man. The papers do not show what transaction produced the note, what the defense was, or whether Smith ever collected. The report also records that the debt papers contain no religious accusation and no evidence of a political purpose behind the note.

Related items

More manuscripts