Home › Collection › Documents
Front: printed summons completed by hand, Wyrick v. Greene and Taylor, issued at Carthage 28 May 1841 by Samuel Otho Williams, clerk.
Summons in Wyrick v. Greene and Taylor, Hancock County Circuit Court, 1841
Samuel Otho Williams, clerk of the Hancock County Circuit Court; return by M. Barnes, deputy sheriff, for Sheriff William Abernathy
Summons issued at Carthage on 28 May 1841 in Jacob Wyrick v. John P. Greene and Jonathan Taylor, an assumpsit action claiming $300 in damages. Samuel Otho Williams issued it as clerk of the Hancock County Circuit Court. The return on the reverse records personal service on both defendants on 14 June 1841. Greene was Brigham Young's brother-in-law and later Nauvoo city marshal. The clerk and the serving deputy were both Carthage Greys lieutenants by June 1844. The underlying debt or promise is unknown.
- Inventory no.
- M-0013
- Author / maker
- Samuel Otho Williams, clerk of the Hancock County Circuit Court; return by M. Barnes, deputy sheriff, for Sheriff William Abernathy
- Place
- Carthage, Hancock County, Illinois
- Date
- 28 May 1841
- Format / binding
- Printed Hancock County Circuit Court summons form, completed in manuscript and signed by Samuel Otho Williams as clerk. The reverse is a printed docket and return form, also completed by hand, with the sheriff's return signed "M. Barnes D. S." and the fee and travel calculation. The report gives no dimensions.
- Signed
- Yes
- Parties
- Jacob Wyrick (or Wirick) v. John P. Greene and Jonathan Taylor
- Court
- Hancock County Circuit Court, No. 78, October Term 1841
- Action
- Assumpsit (trespass on the case on promises); damages claimed $300
- Service
- Personal service on both defendants, 14 June 1841, by M. Barnes, deputy sheriff
- Fees
- $3.37 1/2, apparently including 36 miles travel
Condition
Fold lines, with toning and light soiling along the folds and edges. Small chips at the edges. Description from the owner's photographs.
The story behind this item
The summons
This is a printed summons form, completed by hand, in Jacob Wyrick v. John P. Greene and Jonathan Taylor, No. 78 on the docket of the Hancock County Circuit Court for the October Term 1841. It was issued at Carthage on 28 May 1841 by Samuel Otho Williams as clerk and directed to Sheriff William Abernathy. The action is assumpsit, described as trespass on the case on promises, and the damages claimed are $300. The plaintiff's name is read as Wyrick or Wirick.
The return on the reverse
The reverse carries the sheriff's return, signed "M. Barnes D. S." for Sheriff Abernathy. It records personal service on both defendants on 14 June 1841 and fees of $3.37 1/2, apparently including 36 miles of travel. The report identifies the deputy with high probability as Michael Barnes Jr., a Carthage constable.
The defendants
John Portineus Greene (1793-1844) married Rhoda Young, a sister of Brigham Young, in 1813. A Book of Mormon left by Samuel H. Smith in 1830 reached the Greene household. Rhoda read and believed first, and Greene was baptized in April 1832. He served repeated missions, presided over the Eastern States Mission from 1839 to 1843, and published an early account of the Missouri expulsion. He sat on the Nauvoo city council from 1841 to 1843. As city marshal he carried out the council's order of 10 June 1844 against the Nauvoo Expositor press. He died at Nauvoo on 10 September 1844. Rhoda had died there in January 1841, a few months before the summons was issued.
Jonathan Taylor (born 1793, living after 30 April 1864) received Joseph Smith and his companions at his Ohio home on 19 April 1834. He later held property in the Nauvoo Third Ward, served as a school trustee, and received a Nauvoo Temple endowment. He is a different man from the apostle John Taylor.
The plaintiff and the officers
Jacob Wyrick was a Latter-day Saint refugee from Missouri. At Quincy on 11 May 1839 he swore a redress affidavit claiming $3,300 in losses. He is probably the Jacob Wirick who left the Church and bought a tavern in Lee County, Illinois, about 1842 or 1843. The report keeps that identification provisional.
The court officers lead toward 1844. Williams and Barnes were both lieutenants in the Carthage Greys by June 1844. The report states that rank alone does not prove either man took part in the attack on Carthage Jail. Williams wrote a letter on 10 July 1844 denying participation in the conspiracy, and he died on 28 November 1844. Abernathy was a founder of Augusta, Illinois, and its first postmaster. Nothing in the summons suggests misconduct on his part.
What the summons proves
The paper proves that Wyrick sued Greene and Taylor jointly in assumpsit in 1841, that the clerk issued process at Carthage on 28 May, and that a deputy sheriff served both men in person on 14 June. The $300 figure is the damages demanded in pleading and need not equal the amount of any note or account.
What remains unresolved
The underlying promise or debt is unknown. The report found no declaration, plea, account, note, judgment, execution or minute-book entry. A joint note, partnership account, guaranty or purchase are each possible, and each is conjecture. Taylor's connection to Greene outside the suit is unknown. The report found no evidence that the action concerned Missouri redress funds, and nothing proves that Rhoda Greene's death or Greene's remarriage in December 1841 caused the suit. The outcome of the case is not established.
Related items
More documents


