Larsen Rare Books and Collectables
Early Latter-day Saint books · manuscripts · letters · photographs · art

Home › Collection › Documents

The notice in chancery, Asa J. Bump v. Frank, Milliken, Marks and Johnson, with heading strip and adjacent scraps

Documents · Lake County, Ohio · 1850 (bill filed 31 July 1850)

Newspaper notice in chancery, Asa J. Bump v. George Frank et al., Lake County, Ohio, 1850

Bissel & Mathews, attorneys for the complainant Asa J. Bump (printed notice)

A printed newspaper notice in chancery announcing Asa J. Bump's bill of 31 July 1850 in the Lake County, Ohio, Court of Common Pleas against George Frank, Nathaniel Milliken, William Marks and Aaron Johnson. It recites a sheriff's sale of one acre in Kirtland Township and charges that earlier deeds were made for a fraudulent purpose. The research report identifies the acre as very probably the former Sidney Rigdon home lot across the road from the Kirtland Temple, pending a full boundary comparison.

PricePrice on request
Inquire about this item
Inventory no.
D-0010
Author / maker
Bissel & Mathews, attorneys for the complainant Asa J. Bump (printed notice)
Place
Lake County, Ohio
Date
1850 (bill filed 31 July 1850)
Format / binding
Printed newspaper clipping, one column, notice in chancery. Attorneys' names and printer's mark r38 in type; no manuscript signatures on the clipping. Retained with a printed 'State of Ohio, Lake County, ss.' heading strip and adjacent scraps.
Parties
Asa J. Bump v. George Frank, Nathaniel Milliken, William Marks and Aaron Johnson
Court
Court of Common Pleas, Lake County, Ohio
Parcel
One acre, part of Lot 30, Tract One, Kirtland Township
Amounts
$263 judgment debt; $400 sheriff's sale price
Attorneys
Bissel & Mathews, for complainant

Condition

Clipping toned, with ragged edges and a crease across the lower third. Adjacent backing paper shows edge tears and losses. Housed in a clear sleeve.

The story behind this item

The notice

This is a printed newspaper notice in chancery from Lake County, Ohio. It announces that Asa J. Bump filed a bill in chancery in the Court of Common Pleas on 31 July 1850. The defendants are George Frank, Nathaniel Milliken, William Marks and Aaron Johnson. The notice recites a judgment won by Jacob Bump against Marks at the October term of 1847 for $263 debt, six cents damages and $4.20 costs. Execution issued on 18 October 1847 and was levied on one acre, part of Lot 30 in Tract One, Kirtland Township. Jacob assigned the judgment to Asa on 27 October 1847. The sheriff sold the acre to Asa on 7 February 1848 for $400, and the April 1848 term approved the sale and ordered a deed.

The bill then alleges that Marks conveyed the land to Johnson on 1 September 1843 "for a fraudulent purpose," and that Johnson conveyed it to Frank and Milliken on 26 February 1848, with both men knowing of the fraud. Asa asked that both deeds be declared void as far as they interfered with his quiet possession, and that Frank and Milliken be perpetually enjoined. The notice is signed in type by Bissel & Mathews for the complainant and carries the printer's mark r38.

The acre

The report identifies the acre as very probably the former home lot of Sidney and Phebe Rigdon, across Chillicothe Road from the Kirtland Temple. Newel K. Whitney bought the one-acre site from Jemima Doane in February 1832 and deeded it to Rigdon on 30 April 1834 for $100. Rigdon built a frame house there and sold the property to William Marks on 7 April 1837 for a stated $1,500. The Geauga deed index records that conveyance as one acre in Tract One, Lot 30. The report calls the identification persuasive but unfinished, because the full boundary descriptions have not yet been compared. The modern address 9047 Chillicothe Road is carried only as a working candidate.

The people

Jacob Bump was a mason and plasterer who joined Zion's Camp in 1834 and worked on the Kirtland Temple's interior plastering. He broke with church leadership in 1837 and stayed in Ohio. William Marks became Kirtland stake president and later presided over the Nauvoo stake. Aaron Johnson is probably the Connecticut-born convert who later served as a justice of the peace at Nauvoo and became the first bishop of Springville, Utah. The report treats that identification as strongly probable, pending the 1843 deed itself. George Frank was a Kirtland farmer and tavern keeper. Nathaniel Milliken joined the church in 1833 and was excommunicated by early 1838.

A divided family

The parties were related by marriage. In 1842 Asa's brother Augustus married Mary F. Milliken, daughter of the defendant Nathaniel Milliken. In 1849 her sister Elizabeth married George Frank. The report finds no record of how the family regarded the lawsuit.

Outcome and open questions

A matching notice is indexed in the Painesville Telegraph for 11 September 1850. The issue date of this clipping cannot be fixed from the cropped image. On 25 May 1853 the Telegraph reported a verdict for the defendants in Asa's ejectment suit against Frank and Milliken, with no reason given. The chancery decree has not been found, and the report does not call the ejectment action an appeal. The fraud charges stand only as Asa's allegations. The source of the $263 debt, the terms of the 1843 deed and the reasons for the verdict remain unresolved.

Related items

More documents